11 ms·
It depends on what you want. If you're primarily interested in speedy javascript, process isolation across tabs (so busy tabs don't lock out the UI), or debugg
by barrkel 12y ago
It depends on what you want.
If you're primarily interested in speedy javascript, process isolation across tabs (so busy tabs don't lock out the UI), or debugging web apps, I think Chrome is better. Chrome in particular seems to have a much smoother JS execution profile; it may be down to GC, or something else, but Chrome generally has fewer frames dropped for any given demo.
On the other hand, Firefox is way more featureful, and has a better library of extensions. I find it very difficult to configure Chrome to be how I like it - with a bookmarks menu, zero history, and tree style tabs - whereas Firefox is much easier to shape to my purposes. The combination of tree-style tabs and tab panorama means I can - and do - keep in excess of a hundred tabs open without any difficulty in management.
So Firefox is my primary browser, and Chrome is strictly for testing and pseudonymous browsing.
- paulhebert 12y agoYeah, they both have different benefits. Chrome seems faster for most high performance sites I visit and crashes less often. However, I prefer to have less of my browsing data recorded and so primarily use firefox and duckduckgo.
- psychometry 12y agoFirefox certainly has a larger library of add-ons and those add-ons are more powerful than ones available from Chrome in terms of customizing the browser. The problem is that once you install all the add-ons you're accustomed to having in Chrome, Firefox slows down enough that it's not even worth it. This was my experience using FirefoxDeveloperEdition for the past month and although I miss Firefox's far superior address bar and customizability, the huge performance hit just wasn't worth it and I switched back to Chrome.
- swift 12y agoWhich add-ons did you have installed?
- psychometry 12y agoIn Chrome: 1Password, AdBlock, a Gmail checker, a cookie editor, FlashBlock, Ghostery, Hacker News Enhancement Suite, Imagus, Reddit Enhancement Suite, Stylish. Once I'd installed the corresponding Firefox add-ons, the UI became too unresponsive too often for me to put up with it.
- zxcvcxz 12y agoI have most of those installed (plus some others) in FF Nightly and I'm running fine. It sounds to me like one of the plugins probably has a bug.
- Noxchi 12y agoChrome started being annoying for me after version 36, but firefox was bad too. Recently made the switch to Opera and it has been much better than chrome or firefox. Opera is based on webkit, so it renders just like Chrome, has the same web dev features, and you can use almost all of chromes extensions in Opera. On top of that, I find Opera to take out a lot of the annoyances I've had with Chrome. Also Opera doesn't track you like Chrome probably does, and it's not hindered by Google's politics.
- callahad 12y ago> it's not hindered by Google's politics. Opera is actually based on Blink, Google's fork of WebKit, so it does inherit Google's politics, and contributes to Google's monopolization of web standards.
- rifung 12y agoI believe the person you're responding to was referring to how Google inherently wants to track users due to their business model, although I think you bring up a valid point.
- Noxchi 12y agoWhat I meant by that was Opera lets users do what they want, and doesn't try to hinder them like google does when certain features are against their interest. Things like: * Opera's extension store has Youtube Center, which google disallows in it's store. * When you highlight text and want to search it, Opera lets you search using your default SE, and then a second option to use something like duckduckgo, amazon, wikipedia, etc..
- magicalist 12y ago> contributes to Google's monopolization of web standards Make sure to let all the Opera devs working on web standards know this. It'll save them a bunch of hassle to know they're just wasting their time! You can't advance the open web with FUD.
- 12y ago
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoFirefox's JS is pretty speedy too though, and it's faster than Chrome for things compiled with emscripten due to asm.js, like every Humble Mozilla Bundle game, anything made with Unity or Unreal Engine, anything using stuff like sql.js or other C libraries, etc.
- ultramancool 12y agoYeah, I think the main benefit of Chrome these days is mainly about UI performance more than anything else. They achieve that extremely well with the process isolation. Firefox is moving in that direction to with their electrolysis project, so it'll be interesting to see where that goes.
- cbd1984 12y agoIME, Chrome is slower in terms of UI responsiveness, especially when starting up (massive disk usage) and switching tabs/making new tabs (pegs at least one core of my CPU, whole browser goes catatonic).
- singlow 12y agoIME chrome is faster when I have enough RAM. I have a notebook with 16G of memory and Chrome runs great on it- seems quicker than Firefox. But on my workstation I only have 8G and usually have more things fighting for it. When memory is low Chrome gets unusable but Firefox keeps going along at its not-quite-as-fast-as-chrome-with-enough-memory pace.
- mrottenkolber 12y ago16G and chrome runs great on it. What the shit guys.
- mschuster91 12y agoUsually chrome's UI stickyness goes away when you either buy more RAM or install a SSD instead of a HDD. Chrome's disk usage is crazy.
- blaze33 12y agoCan you recommend any particular Firefox tree-tabs or tab panorama addons ? I don't know how I went this far without this...
- barrkel 12y agoTree Style Tab: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tree-style-tab/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tree-style-ta... I use it with Tab Mix Plus for extra tabby features, like progress bar on the tab, tracking unread tab state, lots of undo close tab slots, forcing popups to show up as tabs, etc: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-mix-plus/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-mix-plus/ The tab panorama feature is built in: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/tab-groups-organize-tabs https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/tab-groups-organize-tab...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- grumblestumble 12y agoI'm personally of the opinion that Chrome has jumped the shark with it's emphasis on perf benchmarking and profiling tools. There's no doubt that Chrome's Dev Tools are superior to anything else out there, but real-world usage has suffered. I've seen instances where certain layouts (eg: position: fixed) cause the visible UI to get out of sync with the DOM, then 'magically' correct itself as soon as you inspect element - no doubt an artifact of over-optimizing repaints. Chrome's Pepper Flash plugin is also considerably less performant than Adobe's plugin, with multiple Chromium tickets spanning over a year. As one of the comments lower down indicates, it's awesome if you're running the latest MBPro with 16G RAM, but should you really need that for a browser? And don't even get me started on Chrome/Windows - have they finally decided to render custom fonts in a way that doesn't look like absolute crap? The Chromium thread on that bug was very insightful as to how the Chrome devs view their user base. Additionally, when it comes to rendering CSS3 effects (gradients, shadows, etc) Chrome really performs poorly compared to Firefox or Safari. Radial gradients esp. suffer from extreme banding, even on Retina displays.