5 ms·
The Lurker: How a Virus Hid in Our Genome for Six Million Years (2013)
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoIf this topic interests you, I recommend reading "The Selfish Gene" by Richard Dawkins.
- nkozyra 12y agoIt didn't until I read this, now I'm absurdly interested and The Selfish Gene has been ordered. Any more modern books of note?
- danieltillett 12y agoYes read the extended phenotype next.
- chc 12y agoWell, the author of this article mentions he has a book on the same topic called "A Planet of Viruses." So that might be worth checking out. (I haven't read it myself.)
- hrjet 12y agoGenome by Matt Ridley.
- rebootthesystem 12y agoRead the book twice. Excellent. Dawkins can be a little long-winded and repetitive at time. For me the book got better after the first third or so. Highly recommended.
- curiously 12y agowhat is the book about in a nutshell? will read it eventually.
- mkramlich 12y agonote for the future: Amazon is a tab away and will give you summaries and more of millions of books. mostly a solved problem. would not be surprised if Wikipedia had a summary of it too.
- curiously 12y agoif I wanted a summary from a non HN user I would've gone there. I think people often miss the importance of someone summarizing it in their own words on a network.
- Sharlin 12y agoThe unit of selection is the gene; not the individual, much less a group of individuals. The reproduction of an allele is not necessarily aligned with the well-being and reproduction of an individual carrying the allele.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- curiouser 12y ago"The Selfish Gene" is explicitly directed at the layman, and absolutely no knowledge of biology is assumed. While this presents a danger of boring readers (such as myself) who are already familiar with DNA and meiosis, the colorful metaphors Dawkins uses throughout the book do much to keep the reading engrossing and entertaining. After a lengthy exploration of basic biology, covering topics such as DNA and the origin of life, Dawkins introduces the gene-centered view of evolution that has long been textbook orthodoxy. Dawkins uses the remainder of the book to look at various types of animal behavior in an effort to convey some general conclusions and tools to help the reader understand evolution and natural selection. Much of his effort is devoted to explaining behavior in terms of the 'selfish gene' - especially social behavior that has long been held to have evolved 'for the good of the species.' Dawkins shows that how fundamental axiom of natural selection (that the genes best at surviving and reproducing will eventually spread through the gene pool) leads directly to the selfish gene and the behavior exhibited by nearly all animals (humans being the prime exception). I should warn that conservatives would probably not enjoy the book nearly as much as I did. Dawkins is an open secular humanist with socialist leanings, and is not worried about offending the delicate sensibilities of creationists and fundamentalists. This book should only be read by those willing to 'accept' the validity of natural selection and evolution; others would only waste their time. I would direct readers seeking a more scientific discussion of these issues to G. C. Williams's "Adaptation and Natural Selection." All others will most likely enjoy "The Selfish Gene" a great deal and finish the book with a new appreciation for and understanding of evolution and biology.
- dkarapetyan 12y agoI also recommend "Evolutionary Psychology: A Critical Introduction" which echoes many of the themes in "The Selfish Gene" from a different perspective.
- vanderZwan 12y agoI would add "The Music of Life" by Denis Noble to that.
- methodin 12y agoIt seems plausible that our DNA hosts a myriad of capable dormant viruses than be triggered by some external activator (or binder), much the same way we have receptors for plants found in the wild (cannabis, nicotine etc...). It also seems perfectly reasonable that the (m)(b)(tr)illions of viruses on the planet are waiting in the wings for a host to get infected to start the process on a new epidemic. I'd like to think this is some form of regulation but of course that would necessitate the world as we know it as a part of a single system that can regulate even the tiniest of members. For a hypothetical we could imagine the scenario where viruses existing in say a remote rain-forest, generally innocuous and self-contained. When deforestation occurs the virus is now open and can potentially infect whatever mechanism (human) that has disrupted it, binding to the same virus DNA that has existed for millions of years. It's not that far-fetched to think unintelligent systems have defenses that we are largely unaware of - or cannot understand.
- evol262 12y agoYou're affirming the consequent. We don't have receptors for plants found in the wild (cannibis, nicotine, etc). Rather, compounds formed by those plants match up with receptors we already have. There's an entire endocannabinoid system, and it's not because pot is natural. Nicotine broadly matches up with acetylcholine and nicotonic acetylcholine receptors. It's far more likely that plants evolved and selected for compounds which have beneficial/detrimental effects on possible consumers, like nicotine as a pesticide, than it is that we have receptors for plants found in the wild on the off chance that we may have consumed them or that they would have been so prevalent in the past that receptors for them would have been selected for.
- ceejayoz 12y agoGreg Bear wrote a fun sci-fi novel Darwin's Radio (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darwin%27s_Radio http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darwin%27s_Radio) featuring these viruses.
- maradori 12y agoThis is quite scary .__.
- karsus 12y agoIt would be interesting to see if we could clean up (refactor) the human genetic code into a more efficient form with less baggage, and maybe less chance at getting hit by viruses just by virtue of having fewer random flaws to exploit.
- hayksaakian 12y agothe main issue is that we only really know what a fraction of the human genetic code is directly responsible for. we would need a lot of experimentation to figure out what's safe to remove. you can think about it as a physical "dependency hell"
- qnaal 12y agounfortunately eugenics is immoral or something
- karsus 12y agoIf we could simulate human cells completely, we could try to simulate an embryo's initial formation and see what falls apart if you remove various sequences. Besides that... we need to understand how a cell recognizes its purpose in its local environment - some kind of local communication probably. If we knew what the various environments that control cell responses are, we would have the basis for something like unit tests... and then we could try randomly removing parts of the DNA and see if its failing to perform as expected or not.
- pmalynin 12y agoActually that's an incredibly terrible idea. You see single base-pair (and other) errors are very common during DNA replication. By having a lot of "useless" (allegedly) zones in our DNA, decreases, statistically speaking, chances of that error occurring in more important areas.
- Retr0spectrum 12y agoCould you explain why that is the case? It seems unintuitive.