4 ms·
- The $15,300 in payroll tax is over and above your 100k. If you are going too call that a tax on you, then you need to call your income $115,300 for the purpo
by danans 12y ago
- The $15,300 in payroll tax is over and above your 100k. If you are going too call that a tax on you, then you need to call your income $115,300 for the purposes of the % calculation.
- You can't subtract the opportunity cost of not working from your income when you make $115k, because you've made the decision to work and earn that salary.
- The EITC is for people who work (hence the "earned" part). If you chose to go exclusively on govt assistance, your max EITC is $11 for a family of 4: http://www.irs.gov/uac/Newsroom/Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-Do-I-Qualify http://www.irs.gov/uac/Newsroom/Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-Do-...
- I don't doubt that there is a measurable amount of disability insurance abuse, but the fact remains that you probably have a disability that prevents you from doing child care. The poor still often have to pay for childcare. In any case, the average annual benefit for a family of 4 comes to about $24k, not $30k: http://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/quickfacts/stat_snapshot/ http://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/quickfacts/stat_snapshot/
Subtracting the opportunity cost of not working from vs working at 115300k muddies the comparison. It's more sensible to compare the two scenarios separately:
115300-15300(payroll tax)-6500(fed tax)-4000(CA tax)-8000(foodstamp equivalent food cost)-2600(typical employee cost for PPO-health program)= 78900
vs.
12000(ACA)+8000(food stamps)+11(per EITC comment above)+24000(per disability citation above) = 44011
Even this comparison isn't apples to apples. In the $100k figure, are you accounting for the employer paid portion of health-insurance (and the lower rates that those in a employer-negotiated plan pay?), any tax-free employer retirement plan contributions, and other pre-tax benefits (DCAP, flex-spending account, employee health insurance contributions?). If you own a home, are you accounting for the mortgage interest and property tax deduction?
I do agree with one sliver of your argument: making financial progress on $100k income is challenging for a family of 4 in VERY high cost-of-living places such as the Bay Area, where that remaining 79k easily gets eaten up by childcare, housing, food, transportation, etc.
Is the standard of living on the $115k salary equivalent to that of a family of 4 on govt assistance? I don't know, but I doubt it, and I would bet on the latter's standard of living being significantly worse. Neither situation is easy street.
EDIT: wording.
EDIT2: formatting
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The $15,300 in payroll tax is over and above your 100k. Actually, only half (the employer share) is.
- zaroth 12y agoMy Macroeconomics 101 class claimed it's been "proven" the full cost of payroll taxes is born by the employee. It's obvious when you are self-employed that's the case, it's less obvious on W-2, but the net effect is the same. Going from "Payroll Cost" on the Company Income Statement to "Net Benefit" on the Family Annual Budget, $140,000 becomes about $15,000, and actually often times much less, or negative. You have to take a careful accounting of where all the money is going, and what your expenses would have been had you NOT earned any of that money, and just stayed home. Unfortunately, it's an extremely demoralizing exercise. If you go a step further, and even say I'm going to earn some gray-market money off-the-books from home instead of taxable income... then you really do just throw in the towel. But all the numbers I'm quoting are assuming the completely legal and above-board approach. The good news for all the self-employed boot-strapping startups out there; STOP paying yourself. It's the absolute worst use of your company's cash. If you take a full and honest accounting, you aren't actually paying yourself anything, you're mostly just paying government taxes and forgoing government benefits. Think of it as the unwritten startup tax credit if it makes you feel better! :-)
- dragonwriter 12y ago> My Macroeconomics 101 class claimed it's been "proven" the full cost of payroll taxes is born by the employee. Whether or not that's true, that's already reflected in you showing the full cost of payroll taxes (employee + employer share) as an expense to the employee. What you failed to do is show all of the income that pays that expense (including the money from the employer that goes directly to paying the employer share) as part of the income from which that cost was being paid. > The good news for all the self-employed boot-strapping startups out there; STOP paying yourself. It's the absolute worst use of your company's cash. Perhaps its worse for your company, OTOH, it mitigates the risk to you should the company -- as many do -- fail, since in that case you will have forgone labor income for equity in the failed firm.
- zaroth 12y ago> FICA / Payroll Taxes I run a business, from my perspective the meaningful number is the total payroll cost for the employee. Taxes are taken before it even leaves my pocket and goes to the employee, and then more and more taxes by the time the employee finally sees it. You can't waive away the taxes just because the law says you can't show the true tax burden on the pay stub. > Opportunity Cost There are real, direct, added costs to choosing to work. It's reasonable to subtract those from salary when trying to calculate the net benefit of working. Just like there's an opportunity cost for waiting in line for bread. It's a real thing. > $115300 -> $78,900 vs. $0 -> $44,011 (for a gap of $35k) First, you can't take home quite $78,900 on $115,300 -- you've shifted up income but haven't adjusted taxes accordingly. From my perspective that employee is earning more like $140,000 (you can't just waive away the cost of paying for all those benefits that otherwise would be provided free by the government, just because they are taken out of your earnings before you see them). Second, you can't just count $100 / pay period as the cost of insurance. It's the full cost of the plan (up to almost $24k / year for Platinum insurance for a family of 4) that has to be paid every two weeks at payday. Benefits are tax advantaged income, income paid out before you see it, but income all the same. If you are self-employed all this becomes obvious, but if you've never worked outside a W-2 the true cost is very much hidden out-of-sight. Employer group insurance plans are more expensive than individual plans, which are obviously way more expensive than free means-tested plans. Going from $0 -> $30k you lose about $8k of value from losing Medi-Cal and going to the Cost-Shared Silver Plan. Going from $30k -> $60k you lose another $12k of subsidies. "Total actuary value" of having Medi-Cal is around $20k / yr for a family of 4. So if you are at $0 income, it's not just +$12k for ACA subsidies, it's more like +$20k for Medi-Cal since it's comparable coverage to a Platinum plan. Third, yes the EITC phases-in and phases-out, it doesn't mean it's not a cost you pay for earning more. It's a curve and it's not a straight line, but it's still a real refundable tax credit that is clawed back as earnings increase over $24k. I agree it's impossible to maximize all benefits concurrently, it's a very complex equation with local and global minima/maxima. One day I really hope to be able to program it and put in on GitHub. > Making financial progress on $100k income is challenging So very true! Even per all your numbers, which are way more conservative than mine... the 'net benefit' to the family of earning "$115,300" of income (~$140k payroll) is only $35,000 !! (the gap) And if you dig deep into all the assistance available, start counting things like income-based rent control, income-based property tax limits, income-based car registration fees, income-based electricity bills, etc.... you can easily erode that $35k down to more like $15k. Isn't that just astounding?! Starting at $140k of employee payroll expense, by the end of the year you've only added $15k of net cash benefit to the family?! As they say, "What the actual fuck!"