3 ms·
Are the control links of hobby RC aircraft encrypted? I would assume not. I wonder then if it would be possible for airports or planes (or both) to emit contro
by snowwrestler 12y ago
Are the control links of hobby RC aircraft encrypted? I would assume not.
I wonder then if it would be possible for airports or planes (or both) to emit control signals what would guide RC aircraft away. From the operator's perspective, the aircraft would simply refuse to follow commands to go in a certain direction.
- mod 12y agoI'm not sure they could know ahead of time what signals would operate which motor. Plus it'll vary per setup. 40% thrust might bring some rc models down quickly & dangerously, and might actually increase height on others. Without being able to view the models, I don't think this is a very viable solution.
- snowwrestler 12y agoI was thinking that a smart system could vary the input signals and measure whether the aircraft gets closer or farther--teaching itself pretty quickly which signal does what. But now that I think about it, even if the signal is not encrypted, it's certainly operating in a narrow slice of bandwidth, and might be digitally encoded. A naive search would probably take way too long just to find the input signal at all. It would only work if manufacturers were forced to share information that would allow an "authorized" system to quickly find and alter the control inputs. Seems messy and risky. And of course this does nothing for self-controlled drones.
- ryan-c 12y agoThere are a very limited number of frequencies used for RC aircraft and I've never heard of the signal being encrypted (authenticated would be more important than encrypted anyway). I also think the control protocols are fairly standardized. The main exception would probably be the ones that are controlled over WiFi (which, as far as I've seen, are not normally encrypted either).
- corobo 12y agoOr just used the mini radar system Plextek (iirc) is creating and have a guy go out there with a beanbag gun and bop the thing out the air http://xkcd.com/538/ http://xkcd.com/538/
- tjohns 12y agoTraditional controllers are pretty basic, but some of the newer systems use frequency hopping (direct-sequence spread spectrum) technology. It's technically not encrypted, but it would be difficult to interfere with since the whole idea behind DSSS is to resist interference, natural or otherwise. On top of that, at best you'd just be able to make the plane crash, which could be bad if it lands in a populated area. A much better idea is what DJI is doing on their newer systems, where on-board GPS is used to enforce no fly zones around airports: http://www.dji.com/fly-safe/category-mc http://www.dji.com/fly-safe/category-mc
- neurotech1 12y agoForget encryption: The airport operators should setup detection for the channels these UAVs transmit, and geolocate the source. I'm all for intelligent deregulation of UAVs, but 700ft altitude directly into the approach path is reckless flying. This is close to the level of (illegal) moronic behavior like flashing lasers at aircraft. I also think the FAA should move forward with cheap low-cost ADS-B transponders for ultralights and UAVs. With a micro transponder on the UAV, the pilots TCAS would have warned them of the UAV close by.