5 ms·
That actually sounds like you might be able to back that up - would be interesting to see the actual stats. But I think you're missing a certain qualitative dif
by jameshart 12y ago
That actually sounds like you might be able to back that up - would be interesting to see the actual stats. But I think you're missing a certain qualitative difference though - the services the 100K-income household is getting for their 60k are significantly better than the services the 0-income household is being given. Obviously they're probably spending money on better food than the food stamps would cover, they're likely living in better conditions in a better neighborhood, and their health insurance probably gives them more choices than they would have on medicaid.
- zaroth 12y agoThere's definitely a qualitative argument. Certainly that's what you see if you turn on any ad-supported media, and you're inundated with that "quality of life" everyone is selling to the middle-class. But for example, you can pay ~$1000/mo for a family of 4 for "Silver" health insurance and earning > $63k you would have to pay the full amount. Credits pay for almost the entire cost (aka $12,000 of tax-free income from the Fed) if your household income is $33k. So under just one program (ACA), $30k of incremental work disqualifies you from $12k of assistance. And that's for the same exact plan/service. Then you get below $33k household income and instead of paying thousands for a Silver plan with a $6,000 family deductible, you pay basically nothing and have no deductible for Medicaid / Medi-Cal. That's effectively a $24,000 / year value for a family of 4. [1] In both cases, you can argue about access to top-specialists for chronic care, but certainly access to acute care coverage is equivalent (i.e. hospitals can't base their ER services based on ability to pay). In many ways Medicaid is better because deductibles are a hell of a lot lower than $13,500 Bronze / $6,000 Silver. By the way, Whole Foods takes food stamps. So that's another example where you get straight up cash for not working. Up to $8,400 / year, cash on a debit card, which phases out as household income goes to ~$30k / year (plus allowed deductions) for a family of 4. [2] If you have a qualifying disability and have to make the choice of giving up work and going on DI, assuming you have the work history credits, it's another up to $31,000 / year of income (not entirely tax-free though). [3] That's over $60k right there, and there are many more programs to account. It would add up to well over $100k except you can't fully stack all of the programs, e.g. CA SDI payments count against SSDI payments. I was thinking about making a "how much do you lose by working" micro-site as an excuse to play with D3 and interactive visualization, targeted to residents of California, but the whole thing was too infuriating I haven't mustered the motivation to do it. [1] - http://www.coveredca.com/shopandcompare/#incomeGuidelines http://www.coveredca.com/shopandcompare/#incomeGuidelines [2] - http://www.stanworks.com/community-reports/other-services/content.php?nav=food-stamps/food-stamps-faq.htm http://www.stanworks.com/community-reports/other-services/co... [3] - http://www.disabilitysecrets.com/how-much-in-ssd.html http://www.disabilitysecrets.com/how-much-in-ssd.html
- chipotle_coyote 12y agoWhile this is interesting, I'm not sure what point we should really be taking away from it. That government assistance is so good it's a motivator not to work? It's easy to play with numbers and make it look like you're "losing money" by working, but it's somewhat disingenuous. For instance, in practice that "$30K of incremental work" is statistically very likely to involve a job with a company that provides health care for their employees and dependents. Furthermore, your description of the way food stamps work is correct but elides how that "phase out" works. Under current CalFresh guidelines[1], a household of 4 grossing $30K a year would get $98 a month. If they grossed $24K a year that would go up to $218 a month -- an extra $1440 a year, when you work it out, which is to say much less than what they'd net by just making another $6000 a year. [1]: http://foodstampguide.org/calculating-the-grant-how-much-do-you-get/ http://foodstampguide.org/calculating-the-grant-how-much-do-... In practice, I'd suggest that most of these calculations are going to work out in roughly the same way: yes, you're "losing out" on government assistance by making more money, but the benefits you accrue from actually making more money more than offset that.
- zaroth 12y agochipotle_coyote, you give the perfect example (actually it's close to the worst case part of the curve). A family of 4 making $24k/year, working their ass off to increase their income 25% to $30k/year. But at the end of the year, what happened? Gross Increase in Income: $6,000 - FICA: ($ 918) - Fed Income Tax: ($ 900) - State Income Tax: ($ 500) - Reduced Food Stamps: ($1,440) - Reduced EITC: ($1,260) [21% phase out after $23,260] - Reduced ACA: ($ ???) [Just about to lose Medi-Cal] That's just top of my head. There are other programs I'm definitely forgetting or don't know about. There's at least $5,000 of additional taxes you pay, and credits you lose, for earning that $6,000. If I had all the numbers, I'm sure said hypothetical family is worse off earning the extra $6,000. They literally now have less money to spend on food every week. Think about how broken this is. At the point in the curve where adding $6,000 in family income could actually be life-changing, the government claws back at least 83% of it?! Fucking A... (sorry, this really makes me mad). > "$30K of incremental work" is statistically very likely to involve a job with a company that provides health care I count benefits as part of income. So if part of the increased payroll expense is actually spent by the employer paying for a private health plan (with a high deductible and cost sharing with the employee) that's a huge net-loss for the family versus getting cash income from the employer and keeping their free health care from Medi-Cal. (It makes zero difference to the employer, ACA penalties aside, either way it's a fully deductible business expense) Edit: I see you gave two examples, $24k vs $30k, and lets say $30k vs $60k. If we do a detailed realistic budget accounting for all costs, credits, programs, etc. you will find "earning $60k" you actually have less money to spend than "earning $30k". You will be net-negative if you have any significant health care expenses at all. It's completely counter-intuitive, and in fact, borderline insane.
- Domenic_S 12y agoIn California, Medicaid + MediCal is substantially better than most private insurance, at least for elder care.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> In California, Medicaid + MediCal is substantially better than most private insurance Medi-Cal is the name of California's Medicaid program, so "Medicaid + Medi-Cal" is just counting the same program twice. Which, if you could actually benefit that way, would probably be fairly generous, but the state actually makes a significant effort to prevent that. Did you intend to say Medicare + Medi-Cal, perhaps?
- Domenic_S 12y agoIndeed I did. Thanks.
- maratd 12y ago> Obviously they're probably spending money on better food than the food stamps would cover The inverse is usually true. Good food doesn't cost much, it's the garbage food that's expensive. You can easily afford fresh fruits/vegies/meat with food stamps. > they're likely living in better conditions in a better neighborhood You can get public housing in Manhattan. Granted it's public housing, but hey, location location location. > and their health insurance probably gives them more choices than they would have on medicaid. This is state specific. For New Jersey, it is absolutely the best health insurance to have. You can't even buy the sort of stuff they will cover with almost zero out of pocket.