3 ms·
Where do the '40' and '70' come from? Who's defining what the final amount of available information is, and judging what the current percentage is? How do you e
by crazygringo 12y ago
Where do the '40' and '70' come from? Who's defining what the final amount of available information is, and judging what the current percentage is? How do you even know at the time?
I mean, it would be one thing to create some kind of simulation and discover that this was actually something statistically meaningful. But there aren't exactly any citations here..
- OvidNaso 12y agoYour second question answers the rest. There is no way to accurately give numerical values in real world applications, so 40 and 70 are chossen as mental model approximations. The fallacy of drawing the line is making no choice or distinction because there is no method to determine the correct one.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoIt's really just pseudo-scientific hand-waving to make people feel better about decisions that they make. As you noted, if this was something more than that there would be simulations, citations, examples, or really anything, other than feel good puffery.
- gone35 12y agoWell, if you think of it as some generalized instance of the secretary problem, the 40-70% rule wouldn't necessarily be that bad --I guess it depends on how adversarial are your assumptions [1]. [1] http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/33227/3-other-extensions-of-the-secretary-problem http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/33227/3-other-extens...