3 ms·
Has everybody forgot about the invasion of China? The rape of Nanking? And when does an oil embargo cause another country to take up arms in a sneak attack? Co
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Has everybody forgot about the invasion of China? The rape of Nanking? And when does an oil embargo cause another country to take up arms in a sneak attack?
Come on, guys, Japan always had the option of terminating their belligerence. There was a legitimate reason for the oil embargo, and it wasn't to provoke a war.
Geesh.
- pradocchia 17y agoWell, sure, but one should be careful about bringing moral legitimacy into the discussion. We might accept that the US was a more benevolent hegemon, and still allow that it willfully provoked Japan to attack. You seem to imply that since there was a legitimate reason, this was in fact the motive reason, or that legitimate motive precludes subterfuge.
- Perceval 17y agoI don't know why you're being moderated down. The Japanese had already begun conquering large swaths of East Asia, Southeast Asia, the Philippines, and so on. A U.S.-Dutch oil embargo was hardly belligerent compared to the actual conquests of the Japanese. The grandparent poster reads like they got their information about WWII from the Yasukuni Shrine museum...
- gruseom 17y agoI downvoted because it has nothing to do with the point under discussion, which is whether the US knew about Pearl Harbor before it happened. Imperial Japan certainly was nasty, but "Imperial Japan was nasty, so Donald Gibbs, lisper, and lionhearted are wrong about this factual question" is a non sequitur.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]