4 ms·
Ask HN: Is it ok to use the same name as an existing service?
I had an idea for a side project/service late last year and but haven't had time to implement it yet (busy with $DAY_JOB). I did get the .com domain and the major social media properties for it. They were all unregistered so I registered them all. All of it is still empty as I haven't started work on it.
I recently noticed that someone else has created the exact service I was envisioning with the exact same name. As the .com was taken (by me) they registered it with a different suffix.
Ex: I was planning foobarservice with the domain foobarservice.com and they registered (and went live with) foobarservice.blah.
I'd still like to pursue this idea and I really like the name.
Would it be wrong to do so? Answers for both the moral and (IANAL-qualified...) legal question would be appreciated.
- RubberSoul 12y agoWho owns the trademark?
- koolba 12y agoI don't think anyone has trademarked the name. I don't have it registered and it doesn't show up if I search for it either.
- gojomo 12y agoFrom the description so far, the other team – out trading in the market under the name – owns a common-law trademark, at least in the US, even if they haven't begun (or indeed never do) any formal registration.
- gojomo 12y agoIANAL, but: If they're operating, they have a common-law trademark even if not a formally-registered one. A same-named service of the same general functionality would certainly cause consumer confusion, and possibly damage to their business, putting you at risk of a legitimate lawsuit. Legally and morally, they won the race to that name, so for trade purposes in that field of business, it's theirs. If you love the idea, there's surely another good name. Perhaps after studying them, and noticing another area of differentiation, that can inspire another name. You might be able to sell them your holdings, but don't expect much and the offer would have to be delivered very delicately so you don't seem like you're ransoming off properties they already have a strong claim to (and that in their mind, you might have acquired just to shake them down).
- koolba 12y agoI can't say I implemented much but I did design out what I'd like to build (in a dated notebook) and pitched the idea a bit to get feedback. I didn't acquire anything (domain, handles, etc) with the intent of a shakedown (nor is it on my mind at all). I can tell from the domain registration dates that they registered their alternative name after me. My immediate reaction to seeing the competitor was validation, "whoa somebody else had the same idea as me... I guess it's not terrible!" I do really like the name (it's fairly catchy). I think a part of my attachment to the idea comes from that. At the very least it the catchiness keeps it in my mind.
- davismwfl 12y agoThe bigger question is that even if you get around to launching is it worth having the brand confusion and potential lawsuit. Without trademarks currently it would be argued that they had the first commercial release and were using the name commercially first. Therefore they may come after you for creating brand confusion if you both start being successful. It may be a good name but it may not be worth it. You want to be focused on solving problems not dealing with a fight over a name. Just my 2 cents.
- acesubido 12y agoA question that I've always wanted to ask: What if you were in an another country? How does that one play out?
- davismwfl 12y agoI don't really know from a legal aspect as I am not an attorney. From a digital marketing and branding perspective though, I generally advise our ecommerce and SaaS clients to never utilize a name that might cause confusion regardless of Country of origin for competitors. We have our own offering coming out in Jan 2015 for a SaaS product and we ditched 2 awesome names because we saw others using names either identical or way too similar that could cause confusion. Better to be unique than have confusion, especially if the idea that you and the other guy have are the same industry or problem solution. One point though, is that since you own the .com domain people will likely hit your site first even when looking for the other guy as it is so common for people to type .com over any other TLD. But, I still don't like using a name that could be confusing. The web is global as a whole, and so is branding when dealing with SaaS and web properties.
- dshanahan 12y agoThis. I go this direction on all my brand and digital marketing consulting advice - find another name and avoid confusion. You don't *want the people who mistakenly type in .com and wanted the other product. Execution is all that matters anyway - the strength of your brand will be derived from the product and effort behind it.