5 ms·
Smartphone controlled anything never feels great to me. If I have to type in code to unlock my keypad, then wait for an app to launch, just to change the temper
by untog 12y ago
Smartphone controlled anything never feels great to me. If I have to type in code to unlock my keypad, then wait for an app to launch, just to change the temperature on the thermostat, it's already over.
On a similar note, I wanted to love the Chromecast, but I found the phone to be a terrible controller. Now I use a Roku, which has a great remote. Instead of my girlfriend and I crowding ourselves around a tiny smartphone screen to browse what we're going to watch, we bring up the Netflix app on the Roku and browse on the much more suitable TV.
- pbreit 12y agoI think actually you need both. The Amazon fire tv's remote is critical but I miss not being able to cast from a phone.
- seivan 12y agoSo much wrong with your statement... Unlock with fingerprint. App launches aren't that slow on iPhones :/ How about an extension to do it from the notification center? Or even Siri? Neither requires unlocking. You could technically have an iPhone plugged into a power source and activate Siri with "Hey Siri" and then do your thing. Then.... we have the Watch :)
- lelandbatey 12y agoAnd yet all of those actions pale in comparison to just picking up a remote with nice tactile buttons and using it immediately, no weird navigation, no apps, nothing. I mean, I'd still use my smartphone as a remote for other reasons. But the parent does make a good point.
- coldtea 12y agoSo, instead of the phone (which for most people is always with you), have an extra task-specific remote, to feed with batteries, lose, and go fetch from another room when you need it. Plus "nice tactile buttons"? 2005 called. Of all the things one would need those for, setting a thermostat (which takes like 5 seconds) is very low in utility...
- walterbell 12y agoSome people like using the human sense of touch. Just because there is not yet a billion-dollar corporation profiting from "tactile input devices" (http://research.nokia.com/publication/11833 http://research.nokia.com/publication/11833), doesn't mean we all have to buy into the marketing of "screens-and-rectangles" manufacturers who are optimizing for the visual sense. When the iWatch launches, it will become "fashionable" to receive signals via vibration, i.e. tactile input. Apple and others will make sure we remember our sense of touch, because it has been monetized. We don't need to wait for each of our senses to be monetized, before recognizing that they are already useful with proven technology. A special-function remote or panel has fixed positions and shapes that can be stored in motor memory, requiring minimal use of the visual sensory system, without the need for eye-hand coordination to push soft buttons on a smartphone. Note: the act of getting up and sitting down is good for health, as astronauts will attest from experience in gravity-free environments.
- untog 12y agoThe remote is always exactly where you need it, in front of the TV. As for batteries.. when was the last time you changed your remote batteries? How about the last time you charged your phone? I'll take my once-every-six-months battery replacement over the chance that I'll need to plug my phone in to charge while I'm also trying to use it as a remote. And if you think that tactile buttons are somehow "over", you're wrong. They're tremendously useful.
- omnibrain 12y agoWith Android you can put the control apps on the lock screen. I have the control widgets for my Sonos on the lock screen of my Nexus 7 and it works like a charm. On the other hand I always have to unlock my iPhone if I want to controle my Sonos from it.
- deminature 12y agoXbox One's voice control would be my preferred input mechanism for controlling my entire home - no unlock, no app launch, not even any picking up a device/remote. Microsoft must have plans about this though, because it seems so obvious after getting used to voice control on the console.
- vmarsy 12y agoThat's what Cortana is for. For instance today if you have a Philips hue lights and a windows phone, you pick your phone, screen is off, you press the search button, and says "huestro, set my lights to ..." Hopefully you'll be able to say that directly from your Xbox one microphone. But this article is spot on, that's a reason Philips released the pricey "hue tap", a switch that frees you from using a smartphone http://www.windowsphone.com/en-us/store/app/huetro-for-hue/f14faa22-179d-42e4-99ca-88b44d10449b http://www.windowsphone.com/en-us/store/app/huetro-for-hue/f... http://www2.meethue.com/en-us/the-range/hue-tap/ http://www2.meethue.com/en-us/the-range/hue-tap/
- recursive 12y agoDo you get accurate results with voice control? My success rate with attempted voice commands is something less than 50%. I wouldn't like that to be my primary mechanism for dealing with locks and climate.
- coldtea 12y ago>Smartphone controlled anything never feels great to me. If I have to type in code to unlock my keypad, then wait for an app to launch, just to change the temperature on the thermostat, it's already over. For one, newer smartphones will mostly come with fingerprint sensors. So no code typing there. Second, apps launch almost instantly in any recent iOS or Android phone. It's not like you'll wait 1 minute for he app to launch or anything. Third, "it's already over" over typing and app-launching wait time? Oh, the humanity. I've lived in houses where the thermostat was in a specific room, or even in the basement next to the heater.
- tmuir 12y agoSome of the first world problems of HN users using technology are beyond the pale. I was arguing mouse vs remote/phone for playing media on a media server, and someone's retort was that a mouse would require them to have a surface upon which to use the mouse at their couch. I've spent way too much time envisioning this mythical surfaceless couch and person.
- dllthomas 12y agoI regularly struggle with an optical mouse on my couch or knee, when I need to poke netflix. It's manageable, but it's also annoying.
- polynomial 12y agoNot that I spend a lot of time on couches, mine or others, but even if there is a "usable" surface nearby (I have no surfaces near my couch) it's usually a coffee table with terrible ergonomics for use as a controller plane. But this doesn't seem like a major issue, since it really seems a tablet (or just your phone) solves the problem.
- tmuir 12y agoWait, what are these unusable surfaces? I have a $25 logitech wireless mouse and keyboard that I use roughly 8ft from the usb receiver. Besides the screen of my monitor, I actually cannot find a surface in my direct vicinity that my mouse doesn't track extremely well upon. This includes jeans, shirt, skin, paper towel, microfiber, drywall, carpet, rug, whiteboard, a glass coffee table (surprisingly), and books. How can the capabilities of something as cheap, commoditized, and refined as a computer mouse vary so much that some people's mice are only usable on a small and inconvenient set of surfaces, while other mice have completely mastered the process to the point that nearly every surface imaginable works flawlessly?
- agumonkey 12y agoThink larger, with ~IoT networks you can express richer abstractions. "ensure all rooms lights are off", "all rooms facings south don't need the heater on", "are my doors locked ?". For one off tasks I agree.