8 ms·
Seems like we are trying to engineer a solution that is fundamentally a behavioral issue rather than mechanical. I do realize though that assuming we can reign
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
Seems like we are trying to engineer a solution that is fundamentally a behavioral issue rather than mechanical. I do realize though that assuming we can reign in consumption socially is a non-starter at the same time though I think enabling high levels of consumption is the opposite of what we should be doing.
That said, anything we can do to reverse aging I am all for, I just hope our consumption patterns can become less extreme.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoIsn't the change in metabolism as you age mechanical?
- danudey 12y agoThe article discusses the change in metabolism as being (at least partly) as a result of fatty, awful North American diets; it's possible that the change is normal over time as a cumulative result of diet but that the North American diet accelerates the process. That would also explain the childhood obesity epidemic; forcing our kids to run laps and play sports doesn't help if they have a fundamentally flawed diet that rapidly accelerates their serotonin production/accretion, especially if younger children are more prone to the process. The metabolic change would also explain the various studies/experiments I've seen where people who became obese and then lost significant weight retained the same appetite as they had when they were obese.
- Igglyboo 12y agoYou can argue that everything in the universe is mechanical, even electricity, if you look at a small enough scale.
- nostromo 12y agoIt's often not behavior changes that turn healthy 20 year olds into obese 50 year olds -- it's that behaviors stay the same while the body changes. If we can find a way to bring some of those perks of youth into older age, I think it's great.
- swalsh 12y agoThis is very true, I'm a creature of habit. When I go to restaurants I always order the same thing, at home I eat the same things. Each week I rotate the same few options. To me it's very satisfying (my wife hates it, she ventures out more often) Right around age 25 or so despite nothing changing in my life other than my age, I started to gain weight. Very slowly, but it was adding up. After doing some calorie counting I lost about 30lbs over 8 months, and returned to my original weight. Though since then I've been struggling to find the right number to increase to. The suggested number of 2000 seems to be too high.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoYou're exactly right on that because I am transitioning from young guy to old guy and can see it happen. That doesn't mean my old eating habits were sustainable though forever. I think we need to be able to reduce our consumption if we aren't growing anymore.
- exelius 12y ago> That said, anything we can do to reverse aging I am all for, I just hope our consumption patterns can become less extreme. I disagree; aging and death are natural processes that could wreak havoc economically if significantly altered. Right now, the young have the ability to progress in the economy because older people eventually leave the workforce through retirement or death. People need to be able to die naturally. If nobody died, and everyone had children, the population would simply grow with no prospect of stopping it. Though the more likely proposition would be that the wealthy who could afford the treatments would never die, and the rest of the population would. That's an even worse scenario in my opinion.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoFeel free to die then. Don't condemn everyone else. Are you going to complain because life expectancies have already gone up by decades? "We need more resources because we cured death" is precisely the kind of problem we ought to have.
- joyeuse6701 12y agoNo need to be facetious, death need not be a condemnation, and there is value in awareness of consequence.
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> there is value in awareness of consequence Awareness of consequence is one thing, and it's fine to anticipate the next set of problems and discuss how to address them. But "we shouldn't fix this problem because it'll raise new ones" is an awful statement, compared to "let's fix this problem; bring on the next ones and we'll fix those too". > death need not be a condemnation If you oppose other people living longer or forever, you're saying you want them dead, sooner or later. Couching it in vague or indirect language makes it no less of a condemnation.
- noobermin 12y agoTaking that hypothesis, do you suppose that the lengthening of the life expectancy of developed countries has had a negative impact on said countries? Or do you think about life prolongation is a good thing up to a point?
- tptacek 12y agoBehavior and biology are intimately linked.
- michaelochurch 12y agoFixing metabolic slowdown isn't going to end obesity or reduce the need for exercise, but it will level the playing field. It's still going to require effort, for many people, to maintain a healthy weight and exercise enough. But it's hard enough to do that as it is; if you can turn off a defect that causes the body to pile on unneeded pounds of fat (that interfere with health, mood, and the ability to exercise) with age, then you should.
- revelation 12y agoHow is metabolic slowdown a defect? I don't see middle-aged people dropping dead around me, so clearly all that has happened is that their bodies are now more efficient. Great news! And piling on fat making it harder to exercise? Sure, on the face of it that's true, but usually the one happens because theres a dire lack of the other.
- michaelochurch 12y agoIt's not basal metabolic rate that makes people fat. It's either unhealthy cracings or low energy (and yes, I know that this sense of "energy" is psychological to some degree) levels. It's not low BMR alone that's the problem and, of course, if you have a high BMR but cravings/appetite issues or lethargy, you're still likely to gain weight.