3 ms·
Making money from media is NOT a legal right. You don't have a right to profit. You have the right to attempt to profit from it and exclude others from doing t
by the8472 12y ago
Making money from media is NOT a legal right. You don't have a right to profit.
You have the right to attempt to profit from it and exclude others from doing the same with your work.
That's all copyright provides. A limited right to an opportunity to make money, granted to you by society so you can make more of that work if society (by proxy of "The Market") deems your works as successful.
This right is granted to you because it's considered beneficial to society as a whole, because it incentivizes you to create more and ultimately have all the things you produced released into the public domain once your limited right expires.
So you're not getting the right to copyright because it's a natural right, you're getting it as part of a contract with society. The question is whether that contract is worth it to restrict speech, to have all the side-effects of the DMCA, to put people in prison, to slap families who pirated a few songs with 200k$ fines etc.
Let's say some people are questioning the tradeoff being made, at least in its current state.
- pdabbadabba 12y ago> Making money from media is NOT a legal right. You don't have a right to profit. > You have the right to attempt to profit from it and exclude others from doing the same with your work. I think this is a distinction without a difference when the context is whether someone can interfere with your "attempt" to profit by violating your right to exclude others.
- the8472 12y agoThe context is that it's just a legal right and not a human one. It's one that society constructed for a purpose and then got extended further and further over time for commercial purposes. People's moral compass does not always align with what's legal and at some point they may simply start ignoring the law. Which is what's happening with copyright.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]