6 ms·
And what's the alternative ? The world is not the United States, in most countries of the world, there is simply no legal way to get a movie/tv show on the Inte
by realusername 12y ago
And what's the alternative ? The world is not the United States, in most countries of the world, there is simply no legal way to get a movie/tv show on the Internet. I'm not even talking about 3rd world countries here, Netflix (the only service which is good enough to compare to Torrents) just barely arrived in Europe and their list of movies is so poor, it's not even worth talking about it. Torrents are not working only because it's free but because it's the easier/only option in most places.
- pionar 12y ago> there is simply no legal way to get a movie/tv show on the Internet. Yes, how dare someone not sell their widget everywhere! If Ford won't sell me a car in Argentina, I'll just go steal it! It's a freedom issue! I must be able to legally watch Friends!
- icebraining 12y agoThe correct analogy is: Ford doesn't sell a Ford in Argentina, but a legal owner of a Ford car offered to give you a copy of hers/his, and you accepted it.
- jkaunisv1 12y agoExcept that your friend can't just click a button and send you a copy of their Ford. Your analogy makes no sense, Fords aren't made of bits.
- icebraining 12y agoExactly. I was trying to show that analogies between digital content and physical things don't make sense.
- jkaunisv1 12y agoAh..that wasn't clear. My bad.
- the8472 12y agoMaybe a better analogy: If <insert big pharma here> won't sell cancer drugs for reasonable prices in my country then we will have local companies ignore patents and produce knockoffs instead and sell them at production cost. Which is exactly what's happening in india for example. Remember that you're not stealing anything. Just making copies. Of course treating cancer does not have the same societal value as getting hollywood entertainment, but it's still a market failure when the content industry cannot satisfy demand in those countries. And at least turning both eyes is a much better approach than criminalizing millions.
- ars 12y agoHow is that stealing? If they won't sell you the wiget then why should they get to claim copyright? Copyright only exists to promote selling content, take that away and copyright vanishes right along with it.
- pionar 12y agoNo, copyright exists to say, I made this, I get to control how it's distributed.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoNo, copyright exists to incentivize the creation of new works for the benefit of society.
- dragonwriter 12y agoYou're both right. Grandparent is more correct as to why, historically, copyright as a monopoly grant was first created, but parent is correct as to the explicit Constitutional provision granting Congress the power to create copyright (and patents, etc.) in the US system, and generally the most commonly accepted reason for the continuation of copyright in the modern world.
- forgottenpass 12y agoTo promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoNetflix isn't the only option. You can use iTunes (which is available in a lot of countries with a large collection). You can buy the DVD online or in a store. You can buy a DVD online from a different country and have it shipped to you. And if ALL of that fails - what right do you have to that content anyway? You might want to give them your money, they might not want it. It sucks but it's a poor justification for piracy.
- kruczek 12y ago> You might want to give them your money, they might not want it. Actually in such case piracy doesn't need any justification, since it doesn't harm anyone. With only two alternatives - either to download content illegally or to not get it at all, content owners get exactly the same: nothing.
- icebraining 12y agoThe problem is that not everyone agrees with that consequentialist view.
- yitchelle 12y ago> since it doesn't harm anyone How did you come this this conclusion?
- zxcdw 12y agoNo "lost potential sale", when the sale wasn't even a realistic possibility?
- newaccountfool 12y agoI can help back this up by an article that details studies that have been done. http://freakonomics.com/2012/01/12/how-much-do-music-and-movie-piracy-really-hurt-the-u-s-economy/ http://freakonomics.com/2012/01/12/how-much-do-music-and-mov...
- Benji_San 12y ago
- afro88 12y agoThat's a dangerous line of thinking. Just because people in the US have legal access to content doesn't mean you're allowed to steal it. You make the assumption that you're entitled to something if it's commercially available to people in other parts of the world. You're not. Movies and TV Shows aren't basic necessities that you're entitled to. They are luxuries that you can have if companies decide to sell them to you.
- ars 12y agoWhat steal? Copyright only exists so that people have motivation to make more content. If the content is anyway not available, that argument vanishes and you are left without copyright. Copyright is not some fundamental right that always exists, it only exists in certain limited circumstances. (And seriously? Dangerous thinking?)
- afro88 12y ago> If the content is anyway not available, that argument vanishes and you are left without copyright. Except that if people already has a copy of your work and then you finally manage to secure a deal with a publisher in country x, you now can't sell it. Most of the interested parties already have it. > (And seriously? Dangerous thinking?) It's a slippery slope. Content creators should have full control over how their content can be consumed. This goes both ways - if they want it to be free then it should be free. Also, no other company should be able to infringe their copyright and start charging money for it, or modify it, or use it in a context that they haven't approved.
- vidarh 12y agoNo matter what you think about it, copyright infringement isn't theft.
- afro88 12y agoCare to elaborate? As a musician I struggle to wrap my head around how people think this is the case. I record a piece of music, I own it. I say if you want to own a copy for personal consumption, it costs $5. End of the argument.
- 3984239849823 12y agoTechnically watching movies form internet is perfectly legal in most countries. Some distributor made movie accessible under some sort of license. It is not user obligation (or duty) to investigate wherever all legalities are sorted between producer and distributor. Plus some countries made it legal to make copy for personal use... and so on.
- icebraining 12y agoI'm not sure if your first sentence is very accurate. Where did you get that information?
- rjaco31 12y agoWell most of the people prosecuted for piracy, maybe even all of them, were because of uploading/copyright infringement, it's usually a very gray area of just downloading/watching a stream, and I've never seen a case of it being illegal per se.
- Vespasian 12y agoWhile users have not the obligation to investigate the source of a movie in detail, depending on your juristdiction there are laws about "obvious illegal sources" (like sites where one can download crappy copies of movies still in cinema for free, extremly shaddy ads, covered by public media as being illegal). For example if Netflix turned out to not have a license in my country I could argue that I as a user could not have known that since they made looked and acted like a regular respectable company. If on the other hand I download a torrent containing a recently released movie for free and an accompanying txt file allowing me to "share it to the world", my chances of defending that in front of a judge are not the greatest.