6 ms·
>whereas all the testing says not really." sounds like his statement is based on facts known to him (and being Nobel winning scientist he probably has good ski
by trhway 12y ago
>whereas all the testing says not really."
sounds like his statement is based on facts known to him (and being Nobel winning scientist he probably has good skills at understanding and analyzing facts)
>Sounds more like racism
Either you're trying to say what his statement wasn't based on his knowledge and analysis of facts or you're introducing a concept of "racism rooted in facts"
I wonder though whether the Watson will accept the medal back from Usmanov's hands.
- peteretep 12y ago> > whereas all the testing says not really. > sounds like his statement is based on facts known to him Really? He follows it up by saying "people who have to deal with black employees" will "know" that it's true. My understanding is that IQ correlates to socio-economic background, but once that's adjusted for, all race considerations fall away. If you've got a credible source that says something else, I'm sure we'd find it interesting.
- smm2000 12y agoIncome does not really explain white-black gap in IQ. Blacks from families with >$200k/year income do about as well as whites from families with income <$20k/year. SAT test is not IQ test but it's probably highly correlated. http://isteve.blogspot.com/2014/03/2008-sat-scores-by-race-by-income.html http://isteve.blogspot.com/2014/03/2008-sat-scores-by-race-b...
- peteretep 12y agoDid you read the article you linked to? It suggested that socio-economic background is more important than just looking at the income.
- smm2000 12y agoArticle speculates about it and does not provide any data. Anyway, it's difficult to argue that kids in black families with 200k+ income have less access to resources than kids in white families living below poverty line. Besides it does not really matter - the fact is that blacks in Africa have much lower average IQ than average in most other countries. It could explain lack of positive examples of countries in Africa developing as fast as China, SKorea or many other countries in other part of the world.
- throwaway451 12y ago> My understanding is that IQ correlates to socio-economic background, but once that's adjusted for, all race considerations fall away Unfortunately, that's not true, but it's a common myth that's repeated. Poor whites do nearly as well as rich blacks, on average. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racial_achievement_gap_in_the_United_States#Theories_about_the_origin_of_the_racial_achievement_gap http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racial_achievement_gap_in_the_U... We're still searching for something that would correct for racial differences in testing, but socio-economic background does not correct for it. And even supposing it did, it doesn't directly refute the premise, because it conflates cause/effect, which is why sociologists are searching for other explanations (other than the obvious one, of course, because it goes against our societal values).
- DenisM 12y agoI wonder if there is a large enough cohort of black kids adopted into white families? That would provide a control for extra upbringing variables, those not tied to wealth.
- peteretep 12y ago> Poor whites do nearly as well as rich blacks, on > average. Help me out here, I couldn't find that in link you provided, or in fact any evidence at all that there might be a genetic component to racial differences in intelligence?
- throwaway451 12y agoSomeone linked it below. Do you think Aborigines in Australia have the same IQ as the Japanese? Or Pygmies? Part of accepting diversity is accepting that diversity is very real. But we want it both ways.
- Gatsky 12y agoYes, I do. It's biologically implausible that race has a significant impact on intelligence. If you think that socio-cultural factors don't have a massive impact on IQ scores, then look at what has happened to the IQ scores of women in the last century, and not surprisingly, that this varies between countries [1]. [1] http://m.psychologytoday.com/blog/beautiful-minds/201207/men-women-and-iq-setting-the-record-straight http://m.psychologytoday.com/blog/beautiful-minds/201207/men...
- trhway 12y ago>My understanding is that IQ correlates to socio-economic background, but once that's adjusted for, all race considerations fall away. If you've got a credible source that says something else, I'm sure we'd find it interesting. be my guest, the first simple Google search immediately brings it : http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2964318/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2964318/ "Our primary finding is that when compared to Caucasians, an African-American cohort exhibited smaller cerebral volumes but larger absolute left OFC volumes. Additionally, the OFC and amygdala appear to occupy a significantly greater proportion of the total cerebral volume in the African-American cohort. [...] Our findings are generally concordant with recent work that brain structure may vary significantly across populations of different racial or ethnic backgrounds [5]."
- peteretep 12y agoI think you may have meant to link to a different paper? The one you've linked to is a meta-study on people with mental health problems, and says variously: * "Conclusions: The biological implications of our findings are unclear as we do not know what factors may be contributing to these observed differences" * "This study was a secondary data analysis examining volumetric MRI data gathered from healthy control subjects participating in a study of bipolar disorder"(!) * "the parent study was not designed to examine ethnic or racial differences" And then goes on to say nothing at all about intelligence.
- psychometry 12y agoJust because a smart person claims something as fact doesn't mean it is. Scientist or not, he's still probably a racist.
- seanflyon 12y ago"racism rooted in facts" would still be racism.
- waps 12y agoDepends if you're basing decisions on the ethnicity or on the facts.
- seanflyon 12y agoI am not sure I understand the point you are making or what you mean by "the facts". If hypothetically one ethnicity really were inferior and proven inferior, discrimination based against that ethnicity would be rooted in fact, but would still be racism.
- waps 12y agoI disagree. Take a hypothetical, but concrete, situation : blue people are less "bulky" than green humans, and thus can't carry as heavy loads. Then, if the situation is a fire department hiring, there's 2 ways to go about this : 1) you don't invite blue humans, only green ones -> discrimination. 2) you invite both, test them, and all the blue applicants happen to get disqualified during some test, this is not racism (the odds are very good this will happen if you try it, sadly, but that's not the fault of any fire department. Nor are the resulting ethnic imbalances in companies indications of racism) Then there are the difficult cases. Like for a fireman interview not inviting anyone under 70 kg because it's just not going to happen ... (This is the current European legal standard for discrimination. Where racial/sexual/religious/ethnic/... differences directly conflict with tasks to be carried out, like in the case of a fire department it is OK to refuse based on those criteria, provided you give individuals a chance. E.g. there was a European-level case of a muslim who was refused as a fireman because he refused to carry women, that was not considered discrimination. They actually hired a muslim doctor, and then fired him because he refused to operate on a woman, while he was on call, at 3am. That too was considered not discrimination, nor was a certain reluctance to hire this guy (any doctor would of course have been fired for refusing to operate on anyone))