4 ms·
Making a tool like this has occurred to me, but my idea had a slightly different focus. Rather than attempt to link evidence to statements, which, if we're bei
by cryoshon 12y ago
Making a tool like this has occurred to me, but my idea had a slightly different focus.
Rather than attempt to link evidence to statements, which, if we're being honest, doesn't really bring us closer to the truth since many "sources" are merely other people's words, it was much simpler: identify weasel words, euphemisms, or use of the passive voice. Between these three features, I think that most factual writing could be improved a colossal amount.
I would certainly appreciate an easier way to keep track of claims, citations, evidence, and interplay between a story's moving parts, though. I think that the article mentions a few tools which work toward that goal admirably. Right now, to make a really bulletproof piece, you need to be extremely scrupulous with self-identifying your claims and then providing written explication of evidence or hyperlinked evidence.
Additionally, it'd be really useful to have a tool which kept track of sentence structure and also allowed you to track logical rhetoric by keeping track of "If this, then that" style statements.
This is probably asking too much, though. A final hurdle is that journalists and writers tend to be old-school when it comes to technology, so it might be a hard sell to the older segment of that market.
- lstamour 12y agoSome of this (the identification of words, passive voice) exists already, though results vary: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1094904-proofreading-software-i-want-to-believe#comment_83082658 https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1094904-proofreading-so... (I link to this more because it's a comprehensive list of possible software even though the comparison was done by a vendor.)
- bp999 12y agoHemmingway does some of what your talking about like identifying adverbs, use of passive voice and rating the reading level needed to understand what has been written: http://www.hemingwayapp.com/ http://www.hemingwayapp.com/