3 ms·
A GPG signature is metadata (color). My string of zero and your string of zero may have different GPG signatures, but they are both strings of zero. Stripped o
by digi_owl 12y ago
A GPG signature is metadata (color).
My string of zero and your string of zero may have different GPG signatures, but they are both strings of zero. Stripped of metadata (color) there is no way to tell who the source was.
- rayiner 12y agoAnd in a court setting, source of evidence or testimony is also metadata. It's true that courts care very much about metadata, but so do computers: By default, my iPhone won't install apps that don't have the right signatures. NB: The "string of zero" hypothetical at the beginning is specious, based on a misunderstanding of how copyright works. If two works are similar, but independently created, there is no infringement. But does not follow that if two works are not independently created, there is infringement. They must still be similar enough to infringe. I.e. if you start with the text of Harry Potter, then you change every single word, there is no infringement.
- digi_owl 12y agoBy default a computer will not care about the origins or meta of the string of bits fed to it. That the iPhone cares about the metadata is a behavior imposed by Apple, not a inherent feature of computers in general.
- rayiner 12y agoBy default, a computer won't do anything with the string of bits fed to it. Any behavior of a computer is programmed, and no behavior is more "inherent" than any other.
- couchand 12y agoIsn't the signature itself additional bits? This whole distinction between data and metadata is farcical: metadata is a subtype of data, they are not disjoint.
- digi_owl 12y agoMetadata is a sticky note on a sheet of paper. It may make some statement about what the paper it is stuck to, but it is not written on the paper itself. Metadata basically means data about data. The core issue is that if you have a string of bits (say a long line of zeroes), you can't say from that string of bits alone where it came from, how it was created or anything of that sort. You will need metadata/color/sticky-note to tell you this. Yes you have file formats that can carry the metadata alongside the data (id3 tags in mp3 files for instance). But even if you strip out that metadata the data itself is still there and still usable for whatever you want to do with it.
- couchand 12y agoThat still doesn't explain how metadata is color in this context. From the OP: Those questions are perhaps answerable by "metadata", but metadata suggests to me additional bits attached to the bits in question, and I'd like to emphasize that I'm talking here about something that is not properly captured by bits at all and actually cannot be, ever.
- digi_owl 12y agoHrmf, has it really been that long since i read the article. Had completely forgotten that he touched on the subject of metadata. I stand, corrected, i guess...
- couchand 12y agoThough now, after re-reading the author's statement, I'm not sure I agree with all of it. How can anything not be representable with bits? It's just a matter of finding an encoding scheme. I guess perhaps the author's point is that this coding scheme must be communicated through some side-channel, coloring the bits. The bits themselves could tell you, for instance, which version of a given protocol to use, but couldn't indicate the protocol out of the blue without some other agreement. And this gets back to the discussion of intent. These bits over here are colored by intent. You can codify that color in bits over there, but those are still different bits, and those bits still need to have color information. It's colors all the way down!