4 ms·

NICE TITLE HN: "The pirate bay down forever (Peter Sunde's blog)" Peter Sunde's Blog: "The Pirate Bay down, forever?"

ZoF 12y ago
I'm genuinely curious as to why an admin hasn't changed this title yet. Certainly enough people have commented about it and it is a grossly misleading omission.
- evo_9 12y ago
  Yeah pretty much the silliest thing about HN now - the endless title tweaking by the mods. And to what end? More than once the title has changed so significantly I thought it was an entirely new article.
  - ZoF 12y ago
    I agree there should be something that signifies a changed title(perhaps just an appended asterisk) but I also think it is useful and oftentimes necessary functionality. How would it be 'silly' to add the question mark to the end of this posts title? Especially given that HN guidelines explicitly state that titles should be the headline of the article.
- tehaugmenter 12y ago
  Not knowing whose blog it is leads you believe it may be a factual article as well. I refuse to upvote misleading information like this.
zodiakzz 12y ago
So even HN submitters will linkbait us now? A new low. Someone penalise them please.
- ZoF 12y ago
  >So even HN submitters will linkbait us now? Pretty much how I feel about this article. Here's a large excerpt(almost half of the article): " As a big fan of the KLF I once learned that it’s great to burn great things up. At least then you can quit while you’re on top. I think I left TPB just a little bit after that top, and not when it’s as shitty as it was when it was closed today. It feels good that it might have closed down forever, just a real shame the way it did that. A planned retirement would have given the community time and a way to kick off something new, something better, something faster, something more reliable and with no chance of corrupting itself. Something that had a soul and could retain it. " This is basically Peter Sunde lamenting the loss of values in the current iteration of TPB and stating he would be glad if it ended now. I'm not making any judgement as to whether his viewpoint is valid/warranted or not, but the implication this title gives(given that we know Peter Sunde was a former TPB employee) is that ThePirateBay is closing forever and this is an article explaining why. That's not what this is. There is nothing concrete here regarding TPB closing forever. This article provides no new information save the fact that this former contributor is discontent with the direction TPB has gone. Please note, I still find this article interesting; it is interesting to note how a key contributor during TPB's infancy feels about the site. The title remains misleading though.

ZoF 12y ago

I'm genuinely curious as to why an admin hasn't changed this title yet. Certainly enough people have commented about it and it is a grossly misleading omission.

evo_9 12y ago
Yeah pretty much the silliest thing about HN now - the endless title tweaking by the mods. And to what end? More than once the title has changed so significantly I thought it was an entirely new article.
- ZoF 12y ago
  I agree there should be something that signifies a changed title(perhaps just an appended asterisk) but I also think it is useful and oftentimes necessary functionality. How would it be 'silly' to add the question mark to the end of this posts title? Especially given that HN guidelines explicitly state that titles should be the headline of the article.
tehaugmenter 12y ago
Not knowing whose blog it is leads you believe it may be a factual article as well. I refuse to upvote misleading information like this.

zodiakzz 12y ago

So even HN submitters will linkbait us now? A new low. Someone penalise them please.

ZoF 12y ago
>So even HN submitters will linkbait us now? Pretty much how I feel about this article. Here's a large excerpt(almost half of the article): " As a big fan of the KLF I once learned that it’s great to burn great things up. At least then you can quit while you’re on top. I think I left TPB just a little bit after that top, and not when it’s as shitty as it was when it was closed today. It feels good that it might have closed down forever, just a real shame the way it did that. A planned retirement would have given the community time and a way to kick off something new, something better, something faster, something more reliable and with no chance of corrupting itself. Something that had a soul and could retain it. " This is basically Peter Sunde lamenting the loss of values in the current iteration of TPB and stating he would be glad if it ended now. I'm not making any judgement as to whether his viewpoint is valid/warranted or not, but the implication this title gives(given that we know Peter Sunde was a former TPB employee) is that ThePirateBay is closing forever and this is an article explaining why. That's not what this is. There is nothing concrete here regarding TPB closing forever. This article provides no new information save the fact that this former contributor is discontent with the direction TPB has gone. Please note, I still find this article interesting; it is interesting to note how a key contributor during TPB's infancy feels about the site. The title remains misleading though.