2 ms·
Slight problem - DXD is not PCM. It's downsampled DSD, which isn't a true PCM format and is of debatable value in a bit-depth test. DSD uses single-bit delta-s
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
Slight problem - DXD is not PCM. It's downsampled DSD, which isn't a true PCM format and is of debatable value in a bit-depth test.
DSD uses single-bit delta-sigma modulation at a very high sample rate. You have to downconvert it before you can hear it, and this adds noise/dither/distortion. One of the problems with DSD is that it's not entirely clear what useful bit-depth you're left with after downsampling, because there are theoretical reasons for criticising one-bit sampling. See e.g.
http://sjeng.org/ftp/SACD.pdf http://sjeng.org/ftp/SACD.pdf
A useful test would start with high quality unmastered and unprocessed 24-bit PCM recordings and A/B them with 16-bit downconversions. (Remember, even orchestral recordings are mixed in a studio and the individual stems usually have some dynamic processing and gain riding, even if it's not as obvious as dance music pumping.)
I'd expect a test like this to use a bit meter like Bitter to confirm there's useful information in the lower bits, and not just rely on a vague estimate of the dynamic range.
http://www.stillwellaudio.com/plugins/bitter/ http://www.stillwellaudio.com/plugins/bitter/
Ironically, all of the reviews of the Bozza track say that the BluRay audio version sounds cleaner than the SACD source used here. (I have no idea if this is true. But if someone has both and wants to do a blind A/B, that would be interesting.)
It's also worth mentioning there are easy-to-find test tones you can use to check how clean your audio hardware is at extreme sample rates. They're not directly relevant to bit-depth tests, but they're a good torture test for audio.
http://www.audiocheck.net/testtones_highdefinitionaudio.php http://www.audiocheck.net/testtones_highdefinitionaudio.php
- hvidgaard 12y agoIt doesn't make sense that it is unmastered. We want to test the difference of a properly made 24 bit output downsampled to 16 bit and the original. There is difference between 16, 24, and 32 bit recordings, but it just so happens that 16 bits are enough to give an effective 120dB dynamic range, if you use proper dithering. If you do not want to use dithering "because it's not pure", you still have 96dB of dynamic range. So with dithering 16 bit allow you to represent a mosquito and a jackhammer in the same room. And even without (and that isn't a good idea, as the noise now consist of harmonic distortion which is a lot easier to hear than dithered noise) I really doubt anyone can tell the difference, 96dB is still quite a bit.
- ska 12y agoThat Lipshitz paper is really worth reading.