5 ms·
More people really need to watch this video. http://xiph.org/video/vid2.shtml http://xiph.org/video/vid2.shtml
by taeric 12y ago
More people really need to watch this video. http://xiph.org/video/vid2.shtml http://xiph.org/video/vid2.shtml
- imaginenore 12y agoWow, that video is awesome. It definitely corrected a few misconceptions I had in my head.
- ehPReth 12y agoThat video player is amazing! What is it?
- Hytosys 12y agoSeems to just be a browser-native <video> tag with an overlay that pretty simply controls the quality/time/subtitles. The logic for the controls is at video.js[1] and the logic for the subtitles is at subtitles.js[2] (check the `playSubtitles` function for VTT[3] decoding). All of the sources (the videos for each quality, and the VTT files for each subtitles track) are specified as HTML attributes in vid2.shtml, the linked page. In short, it was seemingly made in-house. [1] http://xiph.org/video/video.js http://xiph.org/video/video.js [2] http://xiph.org/video/subtitles.js http://xiph.org/video/subtitles.js [3] http://dev.w3.org/html5/webvtt/ http://dev.w3.org/html5/webvtt/
- drcode 12y agoWow, I haven't learned that much in 20 minutes in years! Too bad this new found wisdom has such limited application for anything I'm actively involved with.
- logicallee 12y agoWhat technologies do you work with, and of these, what would you enjoy a ten minute enlightenment on?
- Demiurge 12y agoI learned more from this about digital/analogue conversion than from my EE class that covered this topic!
- thunderbong 12y agoWow! Just amazing! I can't believe the amount of confusing science this video dispelled for me. This should be seen by everybody who think they know what a digital signal is.
- lisper 12y agoIs it just me, or is anyone else hearing something that sounds like wind noise over the narration? (It goes away when he plays sample sounds, and other audio on my system sounds normal.)
- vanderZwan 12y agoYou mean the "noisy fan" (as Monty calls it) of the signal generator?
- lisper 12y agoOh, is that what that is? Makes sense. Thanks.
- iLoch 12y agoI watched the full 20 minutes and have absolutely no idea what he was talking about for most of it. I did have that misconception about the stepping in digital signals though - so I did learn something!
- nitrogen 12y agoTry watching his other videos; I think there's one that is more introductory.
- agumonkey 12y agoxiph.org is like a MOOC without the name, spectacular pedagogical quality.
- robert_tweed 12y agoThis is such an awesome video. I really hope there's a follow-up at some point, because as someone with a decent amount of experience with computer graphics, but only a fairly general understanding of sampling theorem, the stuff that would naturally come next is what most interests me, namely: - What happens when you start combining waves together to create more complex signals? This is pretty important, since any real instrument produces hundreds of harmonics with complex attack and decay properties, so decomposition of the fundamental frequencies won't be as accurate as with toy examples. - Following on from that: the effects of aliasing. It definitely exists and I have a very good understanding of aliasing with respect to computer graphics, but what effect does aliasing really have on an audio signal? In CG it's something that's talked about all the time and there are tons of papers about it, but it seems (from the outside at least) that audio guys only ever talk about aliasing in very hand-wavy terms. - Although we can't hear sounds (much) above 20KHz, we can detect artefacts such as "beats" produced when harmonics are slightly mismatched. Is is possible to show that such information either isn't lost, or that what is lost is either below the noise floor or outside the audible frequency range? This particular one is a fairly common complaint made by audiophiles about 44KHz/Nyquist, so it would be nice to see it addressed head-on. FWIW, I'm a bit of an audiophile myself, but not one of those people who thinks they can hear a difference between 192kbps MP3 and uncompressed, let alone 16/44 vs 24/192. Generally the noise floor in the original recording is too high to tell the difference, even if you could hear a difference in artificially constructed pathological cases. But I am interested in really understanding what information is lost, what isn't, and why that may or may not make any difference. In other words, what are those pathological cases? This video is a really good start and clears up a lot, but in some ways it only scratches the surface.
- rspeer 12y agoI can point you to a follow-up on one of those: An example on Wikipedia [1] lets you hear the effect of aliasing on a sawtooth wave. When audio is aliased, the high harmonics will wrap around the Nyquist frequency and come back as audible, inharmonic tones. Aliased audio really sounds quite bad, in a way that would make any listener say "oh god make that horrible noise stop". This is probably why it's easier to recognize the effects of aliasing in video than in audio -- you're not hearing much aliased audio. Aliased video is fairly common and seen as acceptable in some contexts, while anyone who produces aliased audio is going to fix their mistake before inflicting it on listeners. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliasing#Online_audio_example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliasing#Online_audio_example
- gfody 12y agoThe argument for mainstream 24bit dynamic range shouldn't be for higher fidelity reproduction for audiophiles. It should be for enabling more sophistication in our playback devices. In the YouTube era not every recording is perfectly mastered by audio engineers to fill the available range. And I could be listening on high end home theater equipment or the tiny speaker in my smart phone.
- laxatives 12y agoWhat about 24 bit enables "more sophistication in our playback devices". Doesn't sufficiently high fidelity mean you can already listen on your high end equipment?
- gfody 12y agoIt would allow our playback devices to correct poor quality source material without introducing distortions or clipping. All the same reasons why 24bit is preferred in the studio. Basically studio-quality post processing would be possible on any mainstream content resulting in higher fidelity ultimately. Also, if you consider mashup style content where people are producing derivatives based on already mastered material it would generally increase the quality of that material.
- q_no 12y agoThanks for sharing! I really enjoyed the video, though I didn't understand everything (english is not my mothertongue).
- falfour 12y agoThat was an awesome video, resulting in some follow up questions. Is it correct to say that lowering the bits increased the ground noise level, then why, (basically is quantization on the amplitude of the wave??)? If lowering the number bits still produces the same output wave as input wave what and where is the lower limit that changes the sound? Finally how is this 24 bit 16 bit related to my 128kbps mp3s?
- aidenn0 12y agoWith proper dithering, lowering the bits raises the noise floor. This is because dithering is approximately equal to changing the quantization error from something regular to something random. If you don't dither, then the quantization error will likely be something harmonic rather than the hiss you hear in that video. This is much more noticeable[1]. Lowering the number of bits produces the same wave, but with more error. Dithering ensures that the error is random noise, which is why you hear "tape hiss" in that video as the bits gets lowered. With a tone frequency chosen to maximize the harmonic quantization error and no dithering you would start to hear it. Lastly, 24 and 16 bit are largely unrelated to mp3s. In practice, mp3s are decoded to 16 bit audio, but they don't store the audio as PCM, but (roughly) rather as frequency/amplitude pairs which could in theory be decoded at any sample size. In any event, the absolute magnitude of error introduced by encoding a 128kbps mp3 is way, way, way larger than 16 bit quantization error, and the goal of the mp3 encoder is to find a way that is as inaudible as possible. MP3 is an old format at this point, so it does have audible defects in some types of music at even the maximum bitrate (certain percussive instruments are an issue). Vorbis and AAC work in some ways similar to mp3 but are strict improvements (though for the love of music, don't use the FAAC decoder, it's generally considered horrible). 1: Still not noticeable at 16-bit audio, as a similar test to the one in the article was done with no dithering on the 24 -> 16 bit conversion. at somewhere between 12 to 14 bits it would start to be discernible.
- falfour 12y agoAhh, a lots been cleared up but I don't understand "Lowering the number of bits produces the same wave, but with more error" If the wave is the same how can there be more error? and is quantization error caused by quantizing the steps in amplitude?
- gcb0 12y agocaveat: xiph works mainly promoting digital codecs. so... there is a reason they like you to think DAC (digital to analog converter) is a moot problem.