5 ms·
Honestly, I think the pirate bay getting busted would be a good thing, as it would probably lead to the creation of more distributed, robust filesharing platfor
by wyager 12y ago
Honestly, I think the pirate bay getting busted would be a good thing, as it would probably lead to the creation of more distributed, robust filesharing platforms.
The actual bulk data distribution is already quite P2P; the only remaining centralized part is the part that distributes the magnet hashes.
- Joona 12y agoI'm pretty sure you can actually download the magnet links as an archive, which shouldn't be too big either.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoCould the magnet links be served as a torrent?
- Joona 12y ago(If I understand your question correctly,) sure, but it would instantly be outdated, because you can't include the torrent you just created.
- forgotpasswd3x 12y agoPossible a magnet to the magnet bundle?
- aaren 12y agoyes, but because the magnet link is a hash of the content it is only ever a snapshot of the magnet bundle.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoSo version the magnet link (similar to git) and always serve the latest magnet link via a DNS TXT record.
- aaren 12y agowhere does the version control repo live?
- toomuchtodo 12y agoExcellent point. I'll continue to think on this!
- aaren 12y agoIt might be that a blockchain is the way to go. Bitcoin lets you store 80 bytes with each transaction. Maybe that isn't enough for a magnet link and description, but you could use multiple transactions. Maybe there is more optimal blockchain design though. Ideally you'd want a way of validating the content as well.
- mpeg 12y agoOr just host the site in the Tor network.
- aaren 12y agoA hidden service is still centralised though, right? Given the current chasing of The Pirate Bay, I'd expect this hidden service to get the same scrutiny as The Silk Road. My take on The Silk Road was that whilst it was quite possibly bad operational practice that took it down, it could have yielded to traffic analysis. I'd expect the same fate of Tor Pirate Bay.
- mpeg 12y agoBut opsec can be improved upon, with enough care in how you host your torsite, what software it's on and who manages it, it should be possible to run it pretty safely, save for an attack against Tor. I imagine the third generation black markets on Tor will last longer than the second one did
- 12y ago
- draugadrotten 12y agoCould the magnet links be distributed by adding them to dummy transactions using the BitCoin "coinbase" blockchain method?
- Cakez0r 12y agoCurious about this too.
- dfc 12y agoYou can download "an archive" that has all of the magnet links at the time of the creation of the archive. This is not helpful for finding new content. Most importantly downloading a 9 gig archive of magnet links is not a workable system for average users; Bittorrent is only as good as the number of peers in the swarm.
- Joona 12y agoTrue, and I would love to see a solution to it, but downloading an archive makes it at least a little bit less centralized.
- elros 12y agoI don't think it's intended as the main mean of consumption, just as yet another measure to make sure it's hard to destroy the information.
- runn1ng 12y agoI actually made a magnet link archive a year and something back ( http://www.karelbilek.com/piratebay/ http://www.karelbilek.com/piratebay/ ), mostly as an experiment Only the magnets and names - 76 MB; all the magnets + descriptions + comments - 631 MB It's not that workable for any particular usage (other then statistics I guess) and I never upgraded it since then. There were some attempts by other people to regularly archive TPB (and semi-mirror sites like torrentz.eu and bitsnoop were "mirroring it" by reposting its torrents until the very end) but I am not sure if somebody actually dumped it online regularly in an archive
- aaren 12y agoCould a way around the centralisation be to encode the magnet hash database (like btdigg) as metadata in the distributed hash table? Then we just need a seed to get at this somehow, which could be spread around forums. Offload searching of the database onto clients. Talking in vague terms because I'm stretching beyond my knowledge here. btdigg: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BTDigg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BTDigg
- Raphael 12y agoGnutella has p2p search.
- icebraining 12y agoHaven't read the technical details, but http://www.tribler.org/ http://www.tribler.org/ already offers decentralized torrent search.
- runn1ng 12y agoFully decentralized P2P networks are probably older than bittorrent (Gnutella, eMule, and their similar clones). The fact is people don't want 100% decentralized P2P network; people want the fakes and the viruses removed and so on.
- murbard2 12y agoSure, then just have trusted third parties (such as TPB) sign the torrents. It would be pretty hard to shutdown someone signing hashes from an unknown location.
- runn1ng 12y agoIn a fully decentralized environment, you would need to somehow know who to trust and make some karma/feedback in a decentralized way. Given that PGP's web of trust never really caught on, I am not sure if this would work. But maybe it would and I am just too pesimistic.
- murbard2 12y agoDecentralization is a tool, not a goal. TBP, and some verified uploaders managed to gain a good reputation and they didn't abuse it, did they?
- dandelion_lover 12y agoWhy not just use I2P? Though it is not so fast, but for many things acceptable.
- minthd 12y agoThe pirate bay has a comment system, and an option to verify torrents are uploaded by someone. It's possible to implement those in a p2p way, but than it comes close to the improved systems on silk road with reputation ,etc - so maybe they prefer not to go there.