3 ms·
> This is the same as true 7 byte "random" password (0-255). Characters 0 through 31 and 127 are "un-type-able." So for each byte you only have 223 potential v
by Someone1234 12y ago
> This is the same as true 7 byte "random" password (0-255).
Characters 0 through 31 and 127 are "un-type-able." So for each byte you only have 223 potential variations.
Plus, frankly, I cannot follow the author's maths. Let me reword it to be more straightforward...
- In a random character password it has a range of 223 characters.
- In a random English word password it has a range of 8,000 words (worst case).
- Assuming a length of 8 typeable characters (223 character set) you'd get 6115597639891380481 permutations
- Assuming a length of 5 English words (8K set) you'd get 32768000000000000000 (530% higher) permutations
That ignores the fact that in a word-password people can still capitalise words, and use other punctuation (e.g. ? ! . and so on at the end, commas in the middle, capitalise names, and so forth). An 8K vocab where everything is lowercase and no punctuation at all is absolute worst case.
I think the best way to settle this argument is not through maths anyway, it is through study. Take x test subjects and have them record a dozen passwords using both methods (English words, and random characters) and then look at the "real world" variations.
I suspect in the "real world" humans naturally build more secure pass phase passwords, not because it is mathematically stronger (although I believe it is) but because even without trying they come up with more variable sentences.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- foxhill 12y ago>That ignores the fact that ... and it ignores the existence of dictionaries.
- Someone1234 12y agoI'm not sure I follow. The author was citing the number of words different groups of people typically know, this is a good starting point as few people know (or use) every single word in the English dictionary. The 8K figure is a low, but realistic baseline (worst case).
- foxhill 12y agoyes, i understand that. what i meant was that, if you wanted to use less common words, all you would have to do is look up a word in the dictionary. besides, whilst many people may only know 8000 or so words, the set of 8000 would vary significantly, i'd imagine.