7 ms·
Until the next 9/11 or Pearl Habour and then everyone just looks the other way for the next ten years. Japanese internment is still rarely talked about and in
by Someone1234 12y ago
Until the next 9/11 or Pearl Habour and then everyone just looks the other way for the next ten years.
Japanese internment is still rarely talked about and in some states rarely taught in schools(!).
- mikeash 12y agoAt least you'll find few people willing to defend Japanese internment in public, and public opinion is such that it's unlikely anything similar would happen again. Compare to this memo, where you have roughly half of the politically involved population of the country criticizing its release as if the memo itself is somehow reprehensible, and not saying one word about the activities it describes.
- lotharbot 12y agoFrom what I understand (from talking to now very old Japanese-American men who were in the camps as young adults) it was unpleasant and caused significant hardship, but not even remotely similar to what's in this report. It's important to teach about what happened in those camps and to understand why they were wrong. Drawing inappropriate comparisons between those camps and the absolute atrocities in this report isn't helpful.
- Someone1234 12y ago> Drawing inappropriate comparisons between those camps and the absolute atrocities in this report isn't helpful. Nobody did. I said that Americans looked the other way. Nothing more, nothing less. You're clearly reading more into what I said than what I actually said verbatim.
- rayiner 12y agoThe difference, of course, is that those in the internment camps were Americans, while most of these guys are terrorists captured on the battlefield. I do think the comparison is inappropriate, but internment was the atrocity, not this.
- DanBC 12y agoHow do you know all these detainees were "captured on the battlefield"? Because we've been told that? By the same people who said we were not using extraordinary rendition and not using torture? I'm surprised that you think torture is not an atrocity. The US claims to be "giving the gift of democracy" and "spreading freedom". Ignoring international conventions on the rights of prisoners of war (and do not start the weaselly bullshit about whether these people are POWs or not) doesn't seem to be a good way of liberating a nation.
- rayiner 12y ago> How do you know all these detainees were "captured on the battlefield"? By the same people who said we were not using extraordinary rendition and not using torture? Because if the CIA was just ignoring the rules, they wouldn't be trying to lawyer their way around what's "enhanced interrogation" versus "torture." They'd just be pulling out fingernails. > Ignoring international conventions on the rights of prisoners of war You fundamentally misunderstand the rationale behind these conventions. The reason we don't torture the soldiers of civilized nations is because we assume that they will reciprocate when it comes to our soldiers. Stateless militants can't be expected to do that, so the rationale for following those international conventions disappears.
- lotharbot 12y agoWe generally try to uphold high moral standards even if they won't be reciprocated. Many of those conventions provide additional incentive of reciprocation, but that's not the only relevant factor.
- 12y ago
- afarrell 12y ago> rarely talked about I really wish there was a way for to accurately evaluate these statements. I learned about this by age 10 from my mother, it was mentioned multiple times in high school, it is occasionally referenced in conversation online and in person, and comes up on my Fort Minor pandora station about once every 4 hours of playtime. But I live in a liberal social circle that places a high value on learning history.
- gizmo686 12y agoAs another datapoint, the only time I learned about Japanese internment in school was in my high school Supreme Court elective.