5 ms·
I'm not sure it's helpful to describe this as the awful corporatist Americans underestimating the strong, citizen-focussed EU. I am a British citizen living in
by mike_hearn 12y ago
I'm not sure it's helpful to describe this as the awful corporatist Americans underestimating the strong, citizen-focussed EU.
I am a British citizen living in Europe, and I'm for one pretty happy that Uber is trying to drag the taxi industry into the 21st century. Lots of my friends like and use Uber (though I don't use them myself as for some reason the app cannot verify me), I've yet to hear a single complaint about their service.
The Spanish decision doesn't have anything directly to do with protecting people. It was triggered by complaints by the competition, it states that Uber is illegal because it's not authorised not because of some specifically bad thing they're doing .... if this is defending the consumer, why doesn't it look or feel like it?
Frankly, the chance of an Uber-like company getting started in Europe feels close to zero. If it were up to us here to shake up the taxi business and apply basic mobile technology to it, I'm not sure it'd ever happen at all. America is hardly a perfect country and its people are not a perfect people, but you must admire their drive to get things done.
- exelius 12y agoIn Europe you have different views of how markets should be regulated. In the US, deregulation and free markets are the de-facto assumption, but many European economies proudly trend more socialist than we do. Uber's typical appeal to free market economic principles doesn't go over as well in these markets. The Spanish laws in play are absolutely not defending the consumer, they're defending the worker. That's the entire point: in the US, consumer rights often trump worker rights, but that's not the case everywhere.
- Dewie 12y ago> In Europe you have different views of how markets should be regulated. In the US, deregulation and free markets are the de-facto assumption, but many European economies proudly trend more socialist than we do. Europeans in general seem to also have a different conception of what the word socialist means, compared to Americans.
- exelius 12y agoThat's changing; there's no longer the USSR to provide the evil centrally planned economy as a model. But yes, I meant socialist as in the government owns and controls aspects of the economy, with profit maximization often not the goal of those industries.
- Dewie 12y ago> But yes, I meant socialist as in the government owns and controls aspects of the economy, with profit maximization often not the goal of those industries. That already has a name: mixed economy. "Socialist" in the American vernacular is too coarse grained when talking about politics beyond its own borders, since the connotation seems to always just be "left of American politics"... :)
- exelius 12y agoI meant socialist as an adjective, not a noun. The US government has socialist policies as well: social security, for example. Also, government ownership of public transit, or the USPS. I agree the word is a bit inflammatory in the American lexicon, though that is changing as all the old people die off.
- melvinmt 12y agoYep, that's why I said for better or worse, because it's also the reason why the EU sometimes can't have nice things.
- SlashmanX 12y agoWhat's wrong with Hailo? Or is that not as widespread yet? It's a godsend in Ireland
- mattmanser 12y agoWhat about taxis in the uk needs dragging? I phone a taxi, they text me when they're on their way, they pick me up. Mobile apps were happening before uber came along. The UK doesn't have the same problems as the US has, we don't have a shortage of private hires or cabs caused by a limited supply of medallions and we don't have sprawling suburbs with poor public transport.