2 ms·
One practical definition of an expert is someone who can achieve good outcomes even while, or because of, breaking the rules. Great writers break "rules" of gra
by snowwrestler 12y ago
One practical definition of an expert is someone who can achieve good outcomes even while, or because of, breaking the rules. Great writers break "rules" of grammer all the time, sometimes even basic ones in the case of folks like e.e. cummings or Cormac McCarthy.
Why do we have rules at all? If we all knew everything about everything, then we wouldn't need rules; we'd just make every decision correctly on our own. But we don't know everything about everything, so rules provide simple heuristics to guide our behavior.
But sometimes a person knows everything about 1 or 2 things. And in those things, if they really know what we're doing, they don't need rules, because their understanding exceeds simple heuristics.
So, I think the word "expert" is misplaced here, which is IMO part of the problem. Just because you've done something for a long time, that doesn't make you an expert. And expertise is a narrow lane--an expert in bricklaying might not be an expert in construction safety.
All that said, I have found that teaching is a great way to develop personal competence. But it's not because I'm lazy, it's because teaching forces me to examine the rules, and the basis for their creation, which builds real competence and ultimately expertise.