6 ms·
I'd argue that the 'consultingish' part is as hard as the startup's main business itself, if you add the human factor. On one hand, you have your ideas, your p
by outworlder 12y ago
I'd argue that the 'consultingish' part is as hard as the startup's main business itself, if you add the human factor.
On one hand, you have your ideas, your product or whatever you're working on – which, by definition, isn't working all that great. On the other hand, you have a client (or more than one), who's willing to pay right now (usually you can negotiate something upfront) or at least just one invoice away. Plus you are able to charge a nice amount, certainly better than you'd make as an employee and better than going broke.
Somewhere down the line, you'll get more work. Maybe from the same client, maybe it's a referral. Do you turn them down now, that you've achieved the required runway? It's hard if you are a sole founder, it is much harder if you have more than one. Harder still if they are married, or with children or, god forbid, have a mortgage.
The consulting (there's no ish unless it is a somewhat minor customisation of an existing product or parts of it) path is a very slippery slope. It should not be taken unless the other option is death. And only after all founders are on the same page.
It's easier to set a goal when everyone is going broke, than when the money has started rolling in. There's nothing in the world that's more blinding than a bank deposit.
- tptacek 12y agoYes, that is what you do when you've cleared the runway: you start saying no to consulting clients. That is, for example, what 37signals did. I'm not sure I see the problem here.
- danieltillett 12y agoBut 37signals bootstrapped. The problem is once the founders take VC money they are taking on what the VC expect them to do which is play a very high risk, potentially high reward game with a very low chance of success. This strategy is almost certainly not optimal for the founders.
- tptacek 12y agoSo what? At this point in the story we're talking about a company on life support. That's why they're consulting and not continuing to put all their time into product. There's not a whole lot VC can do about it at this point.
- danieltillett 12y ago>There's not a whole lot VC can do about it at this point. Except ask for their money back :) If you think you can get away with running a sane growth company (100% Y/Y) and don't have to worry about the VCs asking for their money back, then the most rational thing to do is take the seed money and run the business as a "slow growth" business with an enormous runway. Unfortunately most VC's are aware of this and will not be too happy if you try :(
- michaelrwolfe1 12y agoVCs can't ask for their money back. It belongs to the company and is in the company bank account. They can refuse to give you more, and if they control the board they can try to put in a new management team, but except for cases of fraud or other malfeasance, they cannot get their money back.
- danieltillett 12y agoWhat about redemption rights? These are a pretty big stick to bang over the head of any founders who think it might be better to run the business in a way the VC doesn't like.
- parasubvert 12y agoRedemption rights are relatively rare, and even if such a clause were in the funding, it would be after a longish period after close (5-7 years). Usually it's for older funds. Thus they're not much of a stick. The only stick is the board voting to fire (or strongly encourage resignation of) the all or part of the founding management team, which if you're already on life support, can be a win/win: founders keep their shares, and someone potentially takes the company to profitability and exit. I can think of at least one major software IPO in the past 15 years where this made everyone (including the ousted founder) a lot of money.
- danieltillett 12y ago
- zeeshanm 12y agoJust want to say it is not too bad to have a mortgage as it may seem. It is very situational, though, depending on how you're paying off mortgage. There is definitely risk there but it can be offset. For example, you could generate some income from rent that can help you pay all your bills in addition to filling in monthly mortgage payments. Again, it depends.
- aytekin 12y agoThat's the path we took. The consultingware products we had really slowed us down, but in the end our subscription revenues gradually built up to a point where it simply didn't make sense to continue doing consulting. So, this path can have a happy ending.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoMy product company turned full-time consulting when our 1st products failed to find enough market. We consulted for two years until we got a contract making somebody else's product. Now we're all that company's employees with equity, and have revenue and traction. So it can work pretty well.