3 ms·
> When crazy things are happening (like snowstorms), drivers will not be out on the road working unless they're compensated more than usual Balderdash. There's
by tzs 12y ago
> When crazy things are happening (like snowstorms), drivers will not be out on the road working unless they're compensated more than usual
Balderdash. There's a trivial way to get drivers on the road during bad weather without surge pricing: you tell them that if they don't work during bad weather, the won't be allowed to work during good weather.
> Anyone objecting to the concept of surge pricing clearly does not understand basic economics
There's more to economics than what they cover in Ec101. A free market is not always the most efficient way to allocate resources. That's why, for instance, emergency rooms treat people based on the seriousness of their condition rather than based on who is willing to pay the most. Transportation during bad weather can become that kind of resource.
- SilasX 12y ago>Balderdash. There's a trivial way to get drivers on the road during bad weather without surge pricing: you tell them that if they don't work during bad weather, the won't be allowed to work during good weather Honest question: how well does that actually work in practice? Do cabbies generally fear the prospects of turning down have-to-takes? When was the last time one faced any consequences for nope-ing right past a black person? And would it even be practical? And how well does this "vinegar" strategy work to improve supply generally? Would you prefer a world in which grocers had to maintain constant produce prices through the year to the current one in which they charge more as the seasonal supply contracts?
- MetaCosm 12y agoIt doesn't work at all -- because regulation is meaningless without enforcement. The real conversation should be about enforcement... not what is written down, what is enforced. There are a lot of stupid laws and regulations on the books in the US that should be gone, but instead are simply unenforced (http://www.dumblaws.com/laws/united-states/oregon http://www.dumblaws.com/laws/united-states/oregon). Additionally, Uber is exploding in popularity because taxi's did a horrible job, abused their government granted monopolies and basically made life miserable for people... the first person in my peer group to start using Uber regularly did it because of the challenge of getting a cab while black late at night.
- Pyxl101 12y agoI don't believe Uber has the kind of relationship with its drivers that you're suggesting. From what I understand, Uber drivers are independent contractors and determine their own working hours and working days. I also had the impression that Uber drivers can turn their "available" signal on and off at will. So many of them run their own private car companies and switch the "Uber available" app off while handling their own rides. They're required to accept rides only when their signal is "on". Moreover, I think you're underestimating an important effect: which is that significant events like snowstorms, maybe sporting events will affect both supply and demand. The impact may not be something that anyone can forecast. When the Uber surge price rises to 6x normal, new supply will enter the system, and demand will leave it. Say an Uber driver is relaxing at home and did not plan to work today. He receives a notification that fare is now 6x normal. That will entice him to work today, even if he wasn't planning to. Or a driver that works predominately in a different area might travel to the area that needs more drivers. Etc. The fact that price can fluctuate in this way ensures that sufficient supply is available. The high price literally creates supply. There is no economic incentive for a taxi driver to come into work on his day off in order to give rides in a snowstorm if he'll receive the same prices the following day. Similarly, when the price rises to 6x, Uber users might decide to call a friend for a ride, instead of taking an Uber, ensuring that people who have alternative means of transportation use them, leaving the drivers available for those who wish to pay or have no alternatives. Thinking through all the side effects and eventualities, the fact that price can fluctuate according to supply and demand provides a significant benefit in the way of allowing more rides to occur.