3 ms·
I'm kind of conflicted about this article. As an American living abroad, it's very, very pertinent. On the other hand, it's basically political in nature so I
by davidw 12y ago
I'm kind of conflicted about this article. As an American living abroad, it's very, very pertinent. On the other hand, it's basically political in nature so I'm going to flag it in any case, as I don't think it's fair to complain about political articles except for ones I really happen to like.
Edit: for those actually interested in doing something, this group looks to be legit: http://americansabroad.org/ http://americansabroad.org/
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoArticles about immigration into/out of the United States seem to hold a special place on HN.
- qdpb 12y agoDo you also have to pay "thousands" of dollars to accountants? This particular bit seems to be an exaggeration, as I would imagine any tax software should be able to deal with foreign income. And with only federal income to report, this should be cheap too.
- vajrabum 12y agoHere's an example that explains the tax rules for Canadian Green Card holders who have Canadian tax free retirement savings accounts. It all seems equitable and simple until you start reading deeper and it becomes clear that as a US Green Card holder from Canada working in the US that you probably need regular services from a tax attorney or a very sharp CPA with experience advising Canadians working in the US to keep you out of trouble. You probably only need that for this issue when the rules change but they do change and it's not the only issue that you're going to need professional advice for. The cost of that specialty advice adds up fast. http://www.serbinski.com/working-in-usa/rrsp.shtml http://www.serbinski.com/working-in-usa/rrsp.shtml
- davidw 12y ago> Do you also have to pay "thousands" of dollars to accountants? No, I found a good guy who really knows what he's doing up in Vicenza. But between his fee, and a day off work to go see him and get all my US stuff in order... it does start to add up. > I would imagine any tax software should be able Maybe, but I doubt it does it nearly as well as a competent accountant, who, for instance, knows how to read an Italian tax filing, and knows the details of the US-Italy tax treaty.
- tormeh 12y agoI think this kind of flagging is misplaced. Politics is usually unwanted on HN because political posts usually reduces to "OMG, [Obama/Tea party] SUXXORZ!!!!". When it's sufficiently interesting, politics is ok, the problem is propaganda and discussing values that are a matter of taste.
- davidw 12y ago> When it's sufficiently interesting, politics is ok, the problem is propaganda and discussing values that are a matter of taste. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530 is a pretty good summary of why I don't want to see politics here. I'll also add the "bullshit asymmetry principle": http://ordrespontane.blogspot.it/2014/07/brandolinis-law.html http://ordrespontane.blogspot.it/2014/07/brandolinis-law.htm... - which tends to become important as these discussions grow. It's super easy to say some inane thing, but to properly refute it requires research, links, statistics, reason... it's difficult. I don't think "good political discussions" are a stable state, either - it's something that might happen for a period of time, but then decay sets in.