3 ms·
Because once you get the incentives correctly aligned it's a massive boost in global wealth?
by ZeroGravitas 12y ago
Because once you get the incentives correctly aligned it's a massive boost in global wealth?
- melling 12y agoBut the company that invested the billions essentially gets no added value. That's not an effective business model. You are right because there would be a huge boon. This could be said for many other things too, like drug research for instance. Rather than pining over a wish, we should come up with a better open source/crowd sourcing method if we really want them.
- zo1 12y ago>"Rather than pining over a wish, we should come up with a better open source/crowd sourcing method if we really want them." Here you go, one method for crowd-sourcing map data: www.openstreetmap.org
- melling 12y agoI already know about that. I think you misunderstood my point. If the poster was satisfied with the current solution then he wouldn't be pining for his wish. I was addressing the generalization. People often wish that company X would donate their efforts
- zo1 12y agoIt's easy to talk about "boosting global wealth" when it's other peoples' money.
- rictic 12y agoThe parent and great-grandparent haven't proposed seizing private property, they're just noticing and drawing attention to waste. The observation is that if we could align incentives such that Bing, Google, OSM, Apple, etc were all investing aggressively into the same map data then everyone would be better off. Maybe we can't! Capitalism is pretty damn good at some problems, optimal even. But it's not flawless, and it is worth noticing and thinking about places where gains appear to be possible.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Because once you get the incentives correctly aligned it's a massive boost in global wealth? The way you get the incentives correctly aligned is to make sure that the people making the decision (i.e., the company building the service) gets reward commensurate with the social utility, such that it is in their rational self-interest to do the socially-useful thing. At which point, they are no longer doing it without compensation.