5 ms·
Google Map's data keeps getting better and better, they now have lane warnings (e.g. "right two lanes," etc) and traffic warnings with the offering to re-route
by Someone1234 12y ago
Google Map's data keeps getting better and better, they now have lane warnings (e.g. "right two lanes," etc) and traffic warnings with the offering to re-route (if they can find a quicker route). Although Google Map constantly offering to re-route me onto a slower route is a little odd (e.g. "want to re-route? It will be a 5 minute longer trip!").
That all being said, while Google Maps as a data source is amazing, Google Maps as an app and or web-site has a lot to be desired. Up until a few versions ago they had a way to add "My Places" but no way to actually access those places from the app (what?!). They have no search history (still, today), they do have suggestions but they are just somewhat useful, they have no compass (got removed), plus they went all "minimalist" and hide all the UI elements (and removed things like offline maps, for nearly a year).
I've actually been forced to stop using Google Maps as GPS as the app keeps closing during navigation and when re-opened it has "forgotten" what I was navigating to or previously searched for. So now I am forced, mid-journey to exit the freeway just to re-open Google Maps, re-search for my destination, and then re-start navigation just hoping it won't re-close-randomly before I get there...
It doesn't crash. It just closes. It is just gone. Like "poof." Then of course the phone goes into standby as nothing is keeping the screen on. At least if it had search history the situation MIGHT be recoverable, but nope...
- ParadoxOryx 12y agoYou can access your Maps search history here - https://history.google.com/history/lookup?hl=en&st=maps https://history.google.com/history/lookup?hl=en&st=maps
- Someone1234 12y agoThat's not a lot of help when I'm driving down the freeway at 65 MpH. It needs to be within the app.
- tim333 12y ago>They have no search history An odd thing is that if I've searched for something on Google Maps on the laptop and then open their phone app I only have to type one letter and then the name pops up of what I'd searched so there's evidently some sort of history, just not very well implemented. Another funny glitch I had with driving directions is it quite often says 'turn left' about 4 seconds after you have passed the turning which is not quite as it should be. I sometimes switch to Apple Maps of all things though I don't think their traffic info is as good.
- psaintla 12y agoI agree completely, there are so many great features I think they could have added instead of changing the interface. 1.) Send directions to a mobile device. There are many times where I search for directions or map out an alternate route on my desktop. The only way I can access those directions is to email it to myself then open the email on the mobile device. Why not just store the data and let the user retrieve it on their mobile device? 2.) Better accuracy of property in rural/suburban areas. It's odd to say this but Bing Maps is actually much more accurate in rural areas. 3.) More fine grained control over street view placement. 4.) Offline maps! Not everywhere has good cell coverage.
- afterburner 12y agoOffline maps never really went away, but they did get harder to manage. Type "OK maps" in the search bar to cache the visible area (it saves several zoom levels). Apparently with the newest version there's another method: http://www.cnet.com/how-to/how-to-use-google-maps-offline-on-ios-android/ http://www.cnet.com/how-to/how-to-use-google-maps-offline-on... Agreed on the apparent deprecation of social/offline features, but the navigation does seem to be getting better.
- bikerb 12y agoGoogle Maps' offline feature is a bit misleading. You can't search or get directions without an internet connection. Although, if you are already navigating and the connection drops and you have the maps offline it would continue to navigate you.
- afterburner 12y agoYes, that's true, search doesn't work. However, your starred items do remain even while offline. So for travelling without data, given some planning time, you can star a bunch of stuff while you have wifi, and then navigate using the offline map without search. I've tried many other solutions, and this really was the simplest and best for me.
- Someone1234 12y ago
- twoodfin 12y agoAlthough Google Map constantly offering to re-route me onto a slower route is a little odd (e.g. "want to re-route? It will be a 5 minute longer trip!"). I think the point of this is to be reassuring: "Hmm... I wonder if it would be faster if I took a right here to get around this backup? Ah, Google says no." That's increasingly important as the live traffic data gets better and it's worthwhile to use navigation to pick one of several routes you already know. Google is still not perfect in this regard, but I'm certain my batting average at being able to "beat" its recommended route to a frequent destination has been trending down for some time.
- jedc 12y agoYep, that's how I've always used/interpreted this same feature. I know the various different routes I could potentially take, and knowing Google has already calculated they're slower makes me feel better about the one I'm actually on. :)
- skygazer 12y agoTomTom gives the, admittedly less informative, but similarly reassuring message, "You're still on the fastest route." My level of trust has grown toward not needing this reassurance. I will further admit that this learning process was a bit jarring, realizing what I thought was the quickest (or even "straightest") route was often mistaken. It's apparently quite easy to confuse "good enough" with "optimum".
- visarga 12y ago> keeps closing during navigation and when re-opened it has "forgotten" what I was navigating to or previously searched for Maybe the good guys at Google need to learn about caching.
- bhandziuk 12y agoI find the new website to be downright slow, too. If I go to https://www.google.com/maps/ https://www.google.com/maps/ I have to wait too long to load. I can generally get going a lot faster using the older interface (https://www.google.com/maps/mm?authuser=0&hl=en https://www.google.com/maps/mm?authuser=0&hl=en). But, sometimes I just go to Bing because I know it will load fast and I can scroll around super fast, too. Scrolling around in Google maps is always slow. It's like they are loading way too much stuff. All the 3D buildings...useless.
- r0m4n0 12y agoAgreed, they've added so much functionality to the desktop site that you can't simply search for an address without huge overhead. google earth is cool but the typical user doesn't need to load topographical details and 3d buildings when landing on the home page for maps...
- MatthewMcDonald 12y ago>the app keeps closing during navigation I've had a similar issue occur several times in the past month. The app doesn't close, it just stops providing navigation instructions. The worst part is that it fails silently, and it seems to be related to poor cell service. It was a little scary when I realized what had happened, as I was driving on icy roads in an unfamiliar area at night. A notification that navigation has stopped would have saved me time and headache. I'm also not a fan of how it changes your route without telling you. I intentionally selected a routed that took major highways, but after stopping for gas the app changed my route to a shorter (by distance) trip that was on small, poorly maintained roads through rural areas (with very poor cell coverage). When combined with the navigation silently failing in poor cell coverage, this has made for a very poor user experience.
- magicalist 12y agowait, am I crazy? As soon as I touch the search bar in the mobile app the search history is right there. Someone below mentions "send to mobile" from the desktop, but searches from desktop google maps also show up in that search history. You do need to turn it on originally, but I believe that option is also fairly prominent...
- sliverstorm 12y ago"want to re-route? It will be a 5 minute longer trip!" I might jump at the chance. My stress levels are correlated much more strongly to traffic than trip time.
- vlasev 12y agoWhat irks me the most is that it almost never displays the names for the horizontal streets until you zoom in really really close. It drives me crazy sometimes. Turning the map 90 degree doesn't seem to fix this either which is really weird.
- kalleboo 12y ago> They have no search history (still, today), At least on iOS, there is. It even syncs with your history on the desktop maps.google.com so if you looked something up on your computer, it's right there.