9 ms·
It's wonderful what Google are doing with Google Maps, but I can't help but wish these maps were open to use by their competitors. Imagine a world where all th
by TazeTSchnitzel 12y ago
It's wonderful what Google are doing with Google Maps, but I can't help but wish these maps were open to use by their competitors.
Imagine a world where all the effort Google, Apple, Microsoft and Nokia put into their maps all went into OpenStreetMap instead.
- cylinder 12y agoCan't understand the reasoning behind expecting a company to pour hundreds of millions of dollars and resources into something for free / no return at all.
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoBecause once you get the incentives correctly aligned it's a massive boost in global wealth?
- melling 12y agoBut the company that invested the billions essentially gets no added value. That's not an effective business model. You are right because there would be a huge boon. This could be said for many other things too, like drug research for instance. Rather than pining over a wish, we should come up with a better open source/crowd sourcing method if we really want them.
- zo1 12y ago>"Rather than pining over a wish, we should come up with a better open source/crowd sourcing method if we really want them." Here you go, one method for crowd-sourcing map data: www.openstreetmap.org
- melling 12y agoI already know about that. I think you misunderstood my point. If the poster was satisfied with the current solution then he wouldn't be pining for his wish. I was addressing the generalization. People often wish that company X would donate their efforts
- zo1 12y agoIt's easy to talk about "boosting global wealth" when it's other peoples' money.
- rictic 12y agoThe parent and great-grandparent haven't proposed seizing private property, they're just noticing and drawing attention to waste. The observation is that if we could align incentives such that Bing, Google, OSM, Apple, etc were all investing aggressively into the same map data then everyone would be better off. Maybe we can't! Capitalism is pretty damn good at some problems, optimal even. But it's not flawless, and it is worth noticing and thinking about places where gains appear to be possible.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Because once you get the incentives correctly aligned it's a massive boost in global wealth? The way you get the incentives correctly aligned is to make sure that the people making the decision (i.e., the company building the service) gets reward commensurate with the social utility, such that it is in their rational self-interest to do the socially-useful thing. At which point, they are no longer doing it without compensation.
- gvb 12y agoRemember the Yellow Pages[tm]? It was a free product that made a huge amount of money by charging businesses to be included/advertised. Google Maps is the new Yellow Pages. "Let your fingers do the walking." Many GPSes have "live google" functionality. I have one that allowed me to search for the nearest gas station or restaurant while on the road. There is huge value to Google from that.
- cylinder 12y agoYes, and that's all via Google Maps, not OpenStreetMaps. Just like YP didn't give away their data, you had to use YP to get it.
- rakoo 12y ago> no return at all That's where you got it all wrong; the same common sense argument could be used against using (and contributing to) open source software in companies, and yet the most successful open source softwares are supported by companies. The thing is, contrary to the common sense argument, there is value in not reinventing what others are already doing. That's also a great way to find technical talents who have first-hand knowledge of the tools you use. OSM is very similar here: the data is openly reusable by anybody and any change benefits everyone. There can be a good reason for not contributing and using OSM, and that would be because Maps is such a central product to Google that they don't want anything shared with anybody else (plus they already have a lot of data and are considered as the best in class, rightfully or not)
- ufmace 12y agoThe trouble is that the cost/benefit tradeoff of open source vary massively between types of software and data. A few open source projects have been hugely successful, attracting contributions from many for-profit corporations. Many more are somewhere between useless and abandoned and sorta-kinda useful if you're willing to tolerate various bugs, quirks, and poor UI. The vast majority of all software written will never be open-sourced because of some combination of vertical target markets, the need to be tightly linked to other proprietary things, massive investment needed before it's usable, etc. OSM is an interesting case. I would have thought that the sheer effort required to keep map data up to date across the world would make it severely impractical to have open map data. They seem to be doing a decent job plugging away, but I don't have any data on how good they are at getting really accurate data and keeping up to date with ever-changing road conditions.
- rictic 12y agoI read the parent's post not as reasoning or arguing for a specific policy, but simply observing one of the flaws of capitalism. Capitalism is doing much better than the other existing systems at solving the massive coordination problems of a large modern society. However, we can also tell that it is imperfect and involves some clear examples of wasted effort. Noticing this waste is valuable, even if no one has a good solution at the moment to improve on the existing system. What's the alternative? Should we just assume that our current economic system has an optimal set of incentives that we could not improve upon?
- pkh80 12y agoand that will be paid for, how? Its been said that Maps is likely Google's most expensive product to maintain. Just think about the scope of driving every road in the world as often as possible. It will only be replaced by OSM if OSM gets to be better than Maps on its own.
- Doctor_Fegg 12y agoOSM's already better than Google Maps in many ways - walking and cycling data, detail in several European countries, and so on. And the beauty of it is that it's paid for by the volunteer effort of its contributors.
- nightski 12y agoHow is it being paid for by volunteer effort any more beautiful than Google supporting it's 55k employees with an above average lifestyle?
- 7952 12y agoWhat Google has is massive amounts of raw data. The street information may be time consuming but is still trivial from a mapping point of view, and is often done better elsewhere. But StreetView has amazing potential and is inaccessible for analysis outside of Google. APIs are great but we need raw data!
- Rondom 12y agoYou might want to have a look at Mapillary (which is a crowd sourced StreetView-alternative). Depending on the location the quality can be quite okay and some places have images where StreetView does not have any. All the images are under a CC license. https://www.mapillary.com/ https://www.mapillary.com/
- nfoz 12y agoEconomic competition implies massive waste of effort. Not sharing work and ideas is one of them; others include the psychological/sociological effects of competition and pressure, and also all the resources poured into advertising (which itself does not particularly give us better products/services). This isn't unique to Google Maps; the same goes for competing pharmaceutical companies, educational institutions, and everything else. Imagine if they were all cooperating rather than competing. However there are also some benefits to competition. Notably, the impetus to take risks of private capital in order to build new things / try new ventures. Also, the presence of choice in the market (in this case, you can choose which maps you consider more reliable). I'd love to see more exploration into economic systems involving cooperation and choice, instead of competition. Can we have independent organizations motivated to produce different-but-similar goods, while simultaneously sharing their efforts?
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoI'm not sure competition is always the best model. For certain things it works well, but for things like maps, I think everyone loses out if mapping data is locked in different commercial vendor silos rather than combined into a non-profit, shared single source.
- mamurphy 12y agoCan you give examples of things that wouldn't, theoretically, be better if "combined into a non-profit, shared single source?" The whole problem is the incentive to innovate diminishes greatly for non-profit, single sources for most products. Thus, we have capitalism and "different commercial vendor silos" for most things, including maps.
- ska 12y agoI think you are oversimplifying. After all, the map data isn't really the product here. But you are right the tricky thing would be to maintain an incentive structure. Waving hands wildly: imagine a mapping database that was owned by the government, free to use for non-profit uses, and licenseable by corporate entities. Here's the twist though, the license fees are proportional to the government doing a certain amount of upkeep/improvement on the database, and you are free to provide the same work block instead of a fee. That way, if you can do it cheaper, it will save you money up front and if your competitor can't do that, it's a competitive advantage. I haven't thought about this model carefully just pointing out it isn't necessarily as black and white as you suggest...