5 ms·
Almost all numbers contain the digit “3” [video]
- logfromblammo 12y agoThe same reasoning applies to every digit. So almost all numbers contain your favorite decimal digit. If I showed this video to a friend who particularly enjoys the digit "6", she would not see the connection, as the video is about "3". No matter how many times I try to explain that there is nothing special about "6", she won't hear any of it. I am quite convinced that the same attitude is rather widespread, and could be effectively monetized by anyone both charismatic enough and unethical enough to exploit it.
- tjgq 12y agoAt the end of the video, he does mention that it works for any digit. A more honest way to present the argument would be to start with "let x be any decimal digit..." but I suspect most non-mathematicians wouldn't be able to follow that.
- timinman 12y agoSerious mathematicians will feel his title was misleading or dishonest. Considering the proportion of mathematicians to the general public, the teacher is probably not targeting mathematicians - he's a mathematician targeting the mathematically curious. With that in mind, the title is perfect.
- moron4hire 12y agoI don't agree. I think the real power of his videos is that, if he is demonstrating anything about mathematics, it's that mathematicians aren't all pedants who can't communicate with anyone outside of their field without accuracy.
- mikeash 12y agoAh, but 6 is interesting! It's the smallest number that can be expressed as the product of two different prime numbers (2 x 3). Of course, all natural numbers are interesting: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interesting_number_paradox http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interesting_number_paradox
- btbuildem 12y agoSo in general, almost all numbers contain any digit? Great.
- niix 12y agoExactly.
- JadeNB 12y agoAn interesting consequence (since there are only finitely many digits) is that, in this sense, almost all numbers contain every digit—a phrasing that, I think, makes the statement less surprising.
- JshWright 12y agoDid you intuitively understand that prior to watching the video?
- mikeash 12y agoI can't speak for him, but I haven't watched the video and this all seems extremely obvious to me.
- sidcool 12y agoIn the end he mentions that it's equally true for the number 5. I guess that's because of the nature of infinity. All numbers would contain almost all other digits when infinity is involved.
- thekingofspain 12y agoProbably a better way to phrase that is almost all numbers contain all the digits.
- tromp 12y agoBy the same token, most numbers are more than 8 digits long. In fact, most are over a billion digits long. Although I've never see a single one in the wild...
- debacle 12y ago5.73x10^1000000000 There you are then. Not that impressive, is it?
- VLM 12y ago3 ↑↑ 4 Where ↑ is the knuth uparrow notation, beats your example in only 4 symbols with about three thousand times as many digits
- ackalker 12y agoI'll see you and raise you a © . Which in my book is c, the speed of light in a vacuum, 299792458 m/s, a mere 9 digits, but inscribed in a circle using Steinhaus–Moser notation[1] is equivalent to a number so mindbogglingly big that I'm not even going to attempt to calculate its measure.[2] [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steinhaus%E2%80%93Moser_notation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steinhaus%E2%80%93Moser_notatio... [2]: Not that it makes any sense to perform this operation on c, but I think that use of © in this way is much more interesting than its current usage.
- VLM 12y agoI admit defeat, using standard notation I can't think of a better ratio of numeric length vs symbolic representation. Well played! Aaronson's got a blog entry tangentially related to this competition http://www.scottaaronson.com/writings/bignumbers.html http://www.scottaaronson.com/writings/bignumbers.html "In an old joke, two noblemen vie to name the bigger number. The first, after ruminating for hours, triumphantly announces "Eighty-three!" The second, mightily impressed, replies "You win.""
- 12y ago
- mynegation 12y agoThis goes against generally accepted mathematical jargon (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mathematical_jargon#Descriptive_informalities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mathematical_jargon#Des...). For countable sets like integers, "almost all" has a meaning "all except a _finite_ set". Obviously the set of numbers that do _not_ contain 3 (or any other digit) is an infinite countable subset of all integers. Frequency has nothing to do with it.
- musername 12y agookay, but what do you call it if the frequency is diverging to zero for infinity?
- mynegation 12y ago"Asymptotic distribution" or "density" probably. Check out this, for an example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prime_number_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prime_number_theorem
- jerf 12y agoI don't think I'm going to ding what is clearly intended as a general-audience presentation for failing to precisely conform to an uncited definition on Wikipedia, under a section with the word "Informality" in its name.
- ColinWright 12y agoThat turns out not to be the case: > almost all > A shorthand term for "all except for a set of measure zero", > when there is a measure to speak of. In this case there is no measure to speak of, so it is normal to talk about taking the ration in a finite initial segment and then letting the size go to infinity and seeing what happens to the ratio. And a set of measure zero does not have to be finite, either. Almost all numbers are transcendental in the sense given above, and yet there are infinitely many non-transcendental numbers. So I think you are mistaken, although I would be interested to hear a more complete statement of what you mean, in case I have misunderstood you.
- Homunculiheaded 12y agoI really dislike these numberphile videos as they deliberately construct their arguments such that the answer makes math seem like a magic trick and that math is truly confusing, which is the opposite of helping people gain an intuition around math. The trick here is that they start with the intuition of counting, in which each number is itself a single thing, but are actually doing a calculation based on each number being a string of single digits. It's much less shocking if you say: Picking a random 10 digit number is the same as randomly picking 10 single digits. The more digits you pick the more likely it is that you'll get a '3' somewhere in there. So as your string of numbers increases in length the less likely it is that you're string won't contain any given number. If I said to someone "The more dice you throw the more likely it is you'll get at least one 3", I don't think I would get anyone who was surprised by that. The unfortunate thing is that math and number theory in particular are full of genuinely fascinating observations that don't rely at all on a tricks of phrasing to be revealed, and rather than making less math literate people feel 'dumb' (as these videos tend to do), spark in interest in exploring math further.
- moron4hire 12y agoDid we watch different videos? Because what I saw went through an entire process to explain how the math isn't a magic trick and how things that seem completely paradoxical can actually have a quite simple explanation. He even does the leg work of showing empirical results to demonstrate the basic principle of the thing before jumping into a more formal, but thoroughly accessible proof without a heavy reliance on math jargon. To me, if he is presenting math as magic at all, he's more like Penn & Teller than David Copperfield. He uses a hook to gain your attention, then explains the trick clearly to show that there are no devils, there are no demons, it's all just science. I mean, really, what more do you want out of the guy? He's getting people interested in math. Let's try to at least be a little more constructive in our criticisms towards him.
- japhyr 12y agoI teach high school math and science. I had a group of students do a mini-project around the question, "Is there anything bigger than infinity?" The core of the project was students watching this numberphile video [0], and recreating his reasoning on their own. That project helped them reason about higher-level math in a way they never thought themselves capable. The idea of "magic" never came up, but they certainly spoke about their sense of wonder at higher-level math. I really appreciate the way he presents mathematical concepts. [0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elvOZm0d4H0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elvOZm0d4H0
- smsx 12y agoThis video was posted on april 1st if no one has noticed.
- ColinWright 12y agoI hadn't noticed, but it doesn't matter. The result is correct. Are you claiming otherwise? Are you claiming that it's false?
- bhousel 12y agoAlmost all of the news published on April 1st is garbage.
- ikeboy 12y agoI don't think this is actually true; regular news sites and newspapers still go on producing news, and it's only a small percentage that are parodical. I would bet that less than 10% of purported news articles on April 1st are fake. Unless you are also claiming that most news published is garbage anyway, in which case I agree.
- vinceguidry 12y agoHe was making a joke.
- jgwest 12y agoSure, the proportion converges to 1 as the order of magnitude approaches infinity. But this convergence is really really slow...
- smockman36 12y agoIt's clear that the same principle applies for every digit. But is the converse true? ie: Almost all numbers DON'T contain the digit "3"
- jlebar 12y agoNot unless we equivocate and redefine "almost all" to be something other than what he used in this video, right? He showed that the ratio of "whole numbers containing 3" to "whole numbers" is close to 1. So the ratio of "whole numbers not containing three" to "whole numbers" is close to 0.
- judk 12y agoAlmost all numbers contain all ten digits.
- ebbv 12y agoIf you really want to blow your mind, almost all numbers contain all the digits 0-9. That's a lot more interesting and surprising to me than that they contain any one digit. But the reality underlying this is actually really boring; when you start talking in terms of n -> infinity any fraction will become insignificant as it self multiplies.
- mikeash 12y agoAlmost all integers contain the first ten trillion digits of pi, consecutively and in order. And yes, it's really not that interesting. Infinity!
- ikawe 12y agoAlmost all numbers contain the sequence 861523871623871623871263.
- jnevill 12y agoImagine a game like minecraft, but you only get 10 blocks. Now you will compose an infinite number of saved games using anywhere from 1 to infinity number of blocks and each time you place a block in each saved game, you pick a block randomly. Some saved game will be a single block, and others will be infinitely vast. Larger than our real universe, containing every block. It's not a stretch of the imagination to see that the majority of the games will contain at least 1 of each of the ten block types.
- KhalilK 12y agoIt is an April Fools' video, nothing to see here.
- ColinWright 12y agoSo, just to be clear, you're claiming that the result is false?
- DINKDINK 12y agoIt can be a April Fools video and still be correct. Basically it's a moot video because you can use the same logic to prove that any digit has the same properties or converse property (that three exists almost NO where because the probability of a number doesn't have three is P(n)=1-1/10^n and as n->∞ P(n)->0
- ColinWright 12y ago> ... because the probability of a number has > three is P(n)=1/10^n and as n->∞ P(n)->0 Er, no. The probability of an n digit number having a three is P(n) = 1 - (9/10)^n, and as n->∞, P(n)->1. I don't understand why you say it's a moot video. The result as stated in the video is complete and correct.
- DINKDINK 12y agoI meant to say doesn't have 3 and have updated the comment to reflect the equation I believe is correct.
- seccess 12y agoFor those of you who aren't familiar, Brady Haran, the creator of numberphile, produces a ton of awesome videos of experts talking about science and math. Besides numberphile, he does Sixty Symbols (physics), Periodic Videos (chem), and computerphile (comp sci) [0]. [0] http://www.bradyharan.com/ http://www.bradyharan.com/
- peterderivaz 12y agoAnother similar idea is the Kempner series. If you add 1/n for all natural numbers n, then the series tends towards infinity. However, if you leave out any integers that contain a digit 9, then the series converges (to just under 23). (It would also converge if you left out numbers containing a digit 3, just to a different limit.)
- kayamon 12y agoIn real life data sets, Benfords Law shows that the digit '1' occurs with much higher probability.
- Too 12y agoThis one is actually true and interesting for real. If you haven't heard of this before i highly recommend reading up about it. When measuring random things in nature, regardless of what unit and base you use to measure (inches, cm, m, feet, etc), measurements with lower first digit appear more frequent than others! This is due to things in nature usually being exponentially distributed, when you have an exponential distribution you will "move away" faster from higher valued digits and reach the next power of ten faster, there you will restart with a low first digits which is slow to move away from. For example, assuming a spread of about 50%, then 1+50%=1.5 (still starting with 1) but 5+50%=7.5 (not starting with same digit), and 8+50%=12 (starting with 1 again).
- oneeyedpigeon 12y agoIn an infinite universe, almost everyone is a smartass mathematician :)
- xclojure 12y agoHere is a visualization of the number convergence: (loop [i 1 t [10N] v [1.0]] (if (> i 300) (map (fn [[a b]] (/ a b)) (partition 2 (interleave v t))) (recur (inc i) (conj t (* 10 (last t))) (conj v (+ (* 9 (last v)) (Math/pow 10 i))))))