7 ms·
Grappling with the ‘Culture of Free’ in Napster’s Aftermath
- rectang 12y agoIn US radio, unlike radio elsewhere in the world, performers don't receive royalties -- only composers do. This was set early on in the history of radio and became very hard to change. I'm glad that we seem to have made it through an analogous phase in the history of internet distribution without artists being frozen out.
- untilHellbanned 12y agoDespite the downvotes I might get, there is nothing new to see here. This is the 1 millionth article of the same ilk. We need some fresh points of view. What I've been surprised by on previous HN commenting threads on this topic is how harsh people tend to be on the content creators' side of the balance sheet. People really despise pay walls and other existing attempts for creators to make money (you want all the songs in the world for $5 and not $10, REALLY??). As a creator myself, a scientist who publishes in academic journals, I desperately want to find new ways to help me and my colleagues monetize our works (Edit: by "monetize" I mean fundraise, NOT profit). I'm pretty sure direct consumer-to-creator payments are part of the solution, but that solution isn't exactly lighting the world on fire like Napster did.
- rectang 12y ago+1. As someone who makes my living off writing open source software, I am highly aware of the challenges in finding tenable business models when distribution is free. The particular model which works for me was to become an employee of a company which uses my software. There are other possibilities, such as consulting; it's important that we continue to experiment. Like you, I see creators in other realms as my colleagues and wish them every success.
- yzzxy 12y agoI have yet to see any new points in the disussion of free content since reading Chris Anderson's book FREE back in 2009. The one possible exception would be the advent of Patreon and to a lesser extent Kickstarter, but these are basically just subsets of the business model patterns he described.
- untilHellbanned 12y agoI've created Onarbor, https://onarbor.com https://onarbor.com, which is distinct from Patreon in that people actually publish on the platform instead of just linking to Youtube, whatever. I think that's theoretical more powerful in terms of building a community on the site, but it is slow-going so far.
- bobbles 12y agoDunno if you want some feedback, but this is HN so here it is! Looking at your main page it seems disjointed. You mentioned that this lets people publish and get paid, but I'm getting mixed messages of 'fund things here' vs 'publish here and get paid!' Maybe this could be clearer? (eg. "Support content you love!" "Be rewarded for your creations!" as separate pages?)
- untilHellbanned 12y agoThanks for the feedback!!! Yeah you can publish and fund on the Onarbor site. Currently as I scientist, I have to write papers and then separately write grant applications. This is duplication of effort and a complete waste of many people's time. Onarbor's solution is to combine publishing and funding. I think the problem people have is that this is user behavior that no other site (to my knowledge) on the internet has. People like Peter Thiel say it is good to do something that nobody else is doing. But the fear I'm having is that people will never get it.
- ObviousScience 12y agoI'm ideologically against scientists profiting off their papers, because it's a poor incentive and harms us all, especially if they're already being funded by the public. I see absolutely no reason that a publicly funded scientist should expect to profit off the results or papers that come from publicly funded science. In short, you're not a creator that's free-lancing, you're a creator for hire, and the results don't belong to you - they belong to the financing body, which in that case, is the public at large. A better solution is just to funnel money in to sciences through public funding mechanisms and telling you that the papers and results - free, and readily accessible to the public - are the deliverable we expect for that money. Let me ask you this: why do you think you need to get money from the paper or results when as a scientist, you're already being paid for your work through other channels?
- untilHellbanned 12y agoYou misinterpreted what I mean by "monetize". Of course I'm not trying to profit of my work. I meant getting money to do my research. Currently, I have to write papers and then separately write grant applications. This is duplication of effort and a complete waste of many people's time. The solution I'm working on will combine publishing and funding.
- rayiner 12y ago> As a creator myself, a scientist who publishes in academic journals, I desperately want to find new ways to help me and my colleagues monetize our works (Edit: by "monetize" I mean fundraise, NOT profit). What's wrong with profiting from science? I think a lot of people have this, to me incomprehensible, state of mind where they feel like things that don't matter much in the grand scheme of things (InstaSnapWhatsYo) are entitled to make lots of money, but it's morally objectionable to make money on things that matter (science, journalism, etc). That creates perverse social incentives: people who are brilliant but not particularly selfless have every incentive to spend their talents on things that don't matter, instead of things that do.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jholman 12y agoWell, there may be people that actually think that way (that it's okay to profit from useless things, but not okay to profit from useful things), but I think there's a less-incomprehensible version, that has to do with entitlement, perceived entitlement, perceived social virtue, that sort of thing. I see two major halves to this. First: No one cares if InstaSnapWhatsYo goes bankrupt, and if they do, Jan Systrom (founder of ISWY) doesn't make a heartstrings appeal that he's entitled to make money. Live by the market, die by the market, all in the game, y'all, etc. But Lars Ulrich thinks he's _entitled_ to sell 50 million records (emphasis on "sell", as opposed to "give away"), and EMI thinks they're entitled to their cut of the same. So the claims of Ulrich and EMI earn a degree of legitimate skepticism: this thing you're saying is "fair" and "just" in return for your social contribution, we can't help but notice that it's making you very very rich. My point here is that if you're nothing but a mercenary, it's hard to knock you for being a mercenary; if you're claiming social value and also have a vested interest, then this tension gets you some sharp looks. Some of that is legitimate, some of it is just sloppy thinking. (Aside: imo, this is the same type of sloppy thinking that claims that hypocrisy is a the one true sin; if Dahmer calls Manson a bad person, Dahmer is right, hypocrite or not.) Second: Science in particular has another problem, and that is the questionable social value of each individual scientist. Read 40 randomly selected peer-reviewed journal publications, and you're going to read a lot of useless garbage. And yet the authors of the garbage are still getting paid, and they might be making above-median wages for an American (not above-median wages for an American with 10 years of education who works 60-hour weeks, but still). I'm a pretty big fan of the net output of science, and academia generally, and think that we should increase our social expenditure on science, but I can see a rational reason for people to be suspicious of requests from scientists to increase science funding. Sort of accidentally, I note that the entire preceding paragraph also applies to your other example of things that matter, journalism. Every sentence, except the "10 years of education".
- TD-Linux 12y agoI have never liked the streaming services like Spotify for this reason - the royalties seem incredibly small (the DRM is also not great). I feel like Bandcamp (and iTunes) have a much better profit model. Offer full length samples so you know exactly what you are getting, and then charge 25-50 cents per track with 90% of it going to the creator. Despite the higher prices to the consumer, the cost feels a lot more justifiable in my mind. I've spent over $50 a month on Bandcamp before, whereas I can't see myself purchasing a music streaming service for anywhere near that cost.
- ollysb 12y agoI've just subscribed to tidal (was spotify before) for $20/month. I'm now quite happily spending $240/year which is significantly more than I ever spent on CDs(I think I bought 3 CDs in the Sam year once...). Even at $10/month for spotify I was still spending far more money than I ever spent previously. I can't believe that the industry can't flourish on that kind of income per listener. Perhaps the problem is that the majority of spotify listeners for instance aren't actually subscribers?
- ryan-allen 12y agoWhat % of listeners are not paying? It seems mad that for $10 a month you can get no ads and download music to your phone and you don't pay the fee!
- ryan-allen 12y agoIf Spotify were $50 a month it'd still be worth it. I don't know how they divvy up profits but lets look at this example: I pay $12 a month and only listen to one record three times through on that month. You'd expect the artist(s) of the record to get my $12 minus a service fee, but what I'm sure happens is the artist(s) only get the price per play x 3 and Spotify pocket the rest. Subscription models are a huge boon for this reason, but the inequitable split might change artists' minds about these sub services. I tend to listen to a small subset of music over and over, the artists should be getting close to that $12/month cost in my opinion.
- paulhauggis 12y agoI just don't understand the culture of free. On one hand, everything digital is expected for free (or close to it). Even app prices have gone so low, that the majority of app developers would never be able to earn a living. On the other, lots of hate for big corporations and further complaining when jobs go away (one of the direct results of the free culture). The ability to make a living online makes it so you don't ever have to work for a large corporation. The ultimate freedom. I know plenty of independent artists that can't really make a living with music anymore because albums are now essentially worthless. Many of these people are now forced to sell out to big corporate record labels (and then, the same people that created this environment call them "sellouts").
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoIt enriches our lives though. While free goods cannot be measured in terms of GDP, it makes us all better off. It also brings that enrichment to a much wider audience than would be if it had a pay barrier.
- drcube 12y agoYeah. The main benefit of digital technology is the ability to copy and transmit data freely. Nobody complains when the email I sent is still sitting in a folder in my mailbox. I don't have to hand write a second copy for my own records. This is progress. It's the same as buggy whip makers complaining that automobiles put them out of a job. Only in this century, the buggy whip manufacturers have a much larger and louder lobby.
- rayiner 12y agoIf commercial content had been made obsolete by people using cheap production technology to put their own original content on Youtube, etc, then you might have a point. That'd be the internet's automobile to the big labels' buggy whip. But people don't want indie content, they still want the buggy whips. Technology just enables them to get the buggy whips for free instead of paying for them.
- _nullandnull_ 12y agoI have always wondered why musicians don't have donate links on their site?
- rectang 12y agoProbably for the same reason I don't as an open source developer: the donation model doesn't yield a lot of income. It's more worthwhile to put your resources towards developing other revenue streams. Maybe donation links work for some, and of course creators should have the freedom to pursue that avenue, along with the freedom to pursue others.
- pmoriarty 12y agoKickstarter seems to work pretty well. Why can't there be such a model for non-technological creations?
- rectang 12y agoLots of non-technological projects are funded on Kickstarter. Before Kickstarter existed, I once donated a substantial sum (for me) to a local musician who I was a big fan of and whose albums I had listened to countless times. Fast-forward several years, and now one of the ways this creator funds her work is through Kickstarter.
- rhino369 12y agoThat just enforces the free culture even more.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- fooey 12y ago> Over a six-month period, Ms. Keating’s songs had been played on Pandora more than 1.5 million times; that earned her all of $1,652.74. She had 131,000 plays on Spotify in 2012. She took home $547.71, or less than half a penny per play. People are making money, it's just not the artists This has less to do with a "Culture of Free" and more to do with predatory business practices
- gear54rus 12y agoInterestingly enough, these 'predatory' practices is pretty much what 'culture of free' is about. Big corps who rant about pirates are nothing more than just hypocrites (as in the worst offenders).
- Disruptive_Dave 12y agoAs a co-founder of a marketing platform for independent artists, and not exactly a music industry veteran, I've spent the past 8 months getting very educated on the situation. It's basically a clusterf... Streaming isn't "figured out" yet, and everybody knows it. My two cents: indie artists should take a page from startup founders and get scrappy with easy access to affordable software and marketing/engagement tools. It's certainly doable, but requires a bit of a behavioral change. Musicians want to write/record/play music, not run a business. But they have to start embracing it or they'll continue to be dependent on major label-like overlords. PS - go watch "Artifact" on Netflix as soon as possible. It's a riveting documentary on a signed band fighting a major label who, in turn, sued them for $30mm.
- Malic 12y agoI've long had the belief that the very act of audio-recording, all the way back to Edison's wax-cylinders, would eventually be the end of making significant money for music makers. That and the fact that there is only 24-hours in a day. My point being that it is a matter of scarcity - or the lack thereof. Music, to some degree, doesn't age. Regardless of what new pop album is due out in the near future, we will still listen to Louis Armstrong sing "What a Wonderful World" as it nears it's 50th anniversary. Any newly produced music is competition with the back-catalog of all music ever recorded. And there is only so much time during the day one can spend listening to music, so individual "consumption" isn't going to change much as time goes one. The only real future for professional musicians is ticket sales for live performances and licensing their songs for uses in other media (movies, commercials, "hasn't been thought of yet")