4 ms·
Anybody who buys into this needs to do a self-check on their critical-thinking skills. First, as others have pointed out, the King is responsible for his actio
by DanielBMarkham 19y ago
Anybody who buys into this needs to do a self-check on their critical-thinking skills.
First, as others have pointed out, the King is responsible for his actions, not you. That means in every one of those scenarios, it's better to just take your stuff and keep it. Any King that set up such a cruel situation is not likely to keep his word anyway.
Second, it might be reasonable in the abstract to make some kind of concession to help other people, but that's in the abstract. Look at it this way - I might choose to give 20 bucks to a bum on the street, or I might not. There are lots of factors that come into play, and there is no universal rule involved.
Finally, there's a neat bit of jujitsu that happens, he switches from asking a question about what _you_ might or might not do in a weird situation to a general principle about what _others_ should do. Last I checked, we aren't in the business of ganging up on our neighbors to impose our morality on them. It's perfectly fine to save your life and let the others die. It might be immoral, it might be bad, disgusting, shameful, sinful, yucky -- pick your adjective. But that's the beauty of freedom. Without that ability to chose, there's nothing moral in the choice anyway. If you start adding up and subtracting lives here and there, you can justify about anything you want to.
It's just a dishonest story. Hunger does not exist because I choose to live a free and productive life. It exists because political systems are broken. The fact that we feed people by acting selfishly is a tough thing to grasp, but once you get it, you realize that it's about a billion times better than just giving a guy a fish.