9 ms·
Detroit by Air
- mousa 12y agoThose blocks with one or two houses are so weird. Looks like sim-city.
- johnvschmitt 12y agoI was born there. It's sad, but hopeful. The "Renaissance Center" (celebrating the rebirth of the city) was built in 1980. The last 34 years, I've heard stories of the "inevitable rebirth" of the city. It's just so sad. For 34 years, a few people are hopeful while the city still declines. Detroit has so many good things going for it: An international border. A water trade route to the Atlantic. More fresh water resources than any other state. Rail lines that are well connected to Chicago and the East Coast. What's really sad for me, personally, is the realization that for so many other challenges, like the CA drought, Global Climate Change, etc, we need tons of capital and work. But IMO, for Detroit to get "fixed", we just need a change of MIND (which can be more difficult than getting sustainable energy, but seriously, could change in 1 day, for free, if we had MLK Jr. type people on the ground). So, in short, it's people's minds that are killing Detroit. We desperately need to change minds there. In Silicon Valley, all races collaborate, live & work together, and we thrive. Please let's try to export that culture to Detroit soon.
- SwellJoe 12y ago"Detroit has so many good things going for it: An international border. A water trade route to the Atlantic. More fresh water resources than any other state. Rail lines that are well connected to Chicago and the East Coast." TIL Detroit would be an awesome capitol city in Civ V. But...how much do those things matter in a modern world? I think I agree with the basics of your assertion about racism playing a role in what's wrong with Detroit. But, I think you have rose-colored glasses about Silicon Valley. There is class warfare happening in the Bay area, just like in every major city, and poor people of color are coming out with the short end of the stick.
- johnvschmitt 12y agoIn SV, it's less about color, and more about education. Yes, that's IMO, not fact, OK? But, seriously, I've worked with 1,000+ people in Silicon Valley, and >50% of them are not white. So, Indian, Chinese, and other "colors" can be extremely prosperous here. The market doesn't care about "color", as much as their education, passion, and collaboration. To raise people out of poverty, it is more about attitude than physics. The attitudes in Detroit are far more toxic than the minor class warfare in SV.
- jrochkind1 12y ago> To raise people out of poverty, it is more about attitude than physics. Actually, it's just about money.
- angersock 12y agoSo, what about hispanic and african americans? There's a world of difference between the kids brought up to choose between pre-med and pre-law, and kids brought up to stay away from the cops.
- melling 12y agoThose two ideas aren't mutually exclusive. Education is the way out of poverty. America provides more opportunities than most other countries.
- therobot24 12y ago> The attitudes in Detroit are far more toxic than the minor class warfare in SV. Currently live downriver from Detroit - I disagree that the attitudes are more toxic. We have yet to have protests in front of our busses (then again, we don't have very many buses, and the 'mugger mover' only goes in a circle). Unfortunately racial tensions still exist (especially when you leave the downtown area), but anecdotally I believe things are getting better.
- justinph 12y agoBut...how much do those things matter in a modern world? I think they're going to start mattering a lot more in the future. The drought in the west is likely to continue to get worse. Water isn't exactly abundant in many cities in the south and west, either. Other metro areas that are built on endless sprawl like Phoenix or Atlanta are in trouble when oil gets expensive again (and it will). They have no natural resources and no strategic reason to exist. Detroit does.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- fourstar 12y ago> So, in short, it's people's minds that are killing Detroit. Or it's people like you who grew up there and decided to abandon it.
- nooron 12y agoDo you still live here as well? And to what version of MLK Jr do you refer -- some sanitized and vague liberal hallucination, or the radical Christian egalitarian he was? A lot of things have hurt Detroit. Include corporate malfeasance, changing labor markets, political corruption, bad planning. But I beg you to clarify if you must insist it is minds.
- jrochkind1 12y agoYou were born in Detroit, or in the suburbs, like me? (And I don't mean born at Sinai Hospital and then taken home to the suburbs).
- zenocon 12y ago> But IMO, for Detroit to get "fixed", we just need a change of MIND (which can be more difficult than getting sustainable energy, but seriously, could change in 1 day, for free, if we had MLK Jr. type people on the ground). Yea, care to explain?
- danans 12y ago- In Silicon Valley, all races collaborate, live & work together, and we thrive. I'm a Detroit-area native here, living in the Bay Area for over a decade. I once had the same impression about the Bay Area - that it had figured out harmonious race relations. In fact, it was one of the things (in addition to the tech industry) that drew me out here from Michigan. But I have come to the realization over the years that it was an illusion, and beneath the surface are actually highly economically/racially segregated zones (SV/E.PaloAlto & East SJ, Central SF/Bayview, Oakland Hills / Flats, etc). All these are juxtaposed by signifiant race and class divisions (I'm speaking in aggregate, we all know plenty of individuals who are exceptions). I'm always surprised at how unwilling many folks in SV are to acknowledge the historical racial dimensions the of current inequality crisis in the Bay Area. I attribute a lot of it to well intended idealism that is uninformed (as I was) about the tumultuous racial history of the Bay Area, which included many of the same factors as Detroit: white flight, inner-city disinvestment, corrupt governance, manufacturing decline, division/destruction of communities by freeways, and suburbanization.
- l33tbro 12y agoDetroit is the perfect microcosm of the US wealth polarity trend. Only a few miles from the "ruin porn" live suburbs like Bloomfield Hills - which has the fourth highest income out of any suburb in the US (1). I'm hopeful that the Retroit movement (2) finds traction with young entrepeneurs. There's certainly a cachet that the city has within the popular imagination. Just look at what foreign vodka companies are doing to cash in on Detroit's "authenticity" (3). (1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-income_places_i.. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-income_places_i.... (2) https://re-urbanization.squarespace.com/ https://re-urbanization.squarespace.com/ (3) http://www.mlive.com/business/detroit/index.ssf/2014/08/ourv.. http://www.mlive.com/business/detroit/index.ssf/2014/08/ourv....
- nols 12y agoI think every major city has the wealthy suburbs nearby like that, industries grow and the wealthy owners leave the cities for more space. Bloomfield Hills is ~20 miles away from Detroit. LA's rich and poor cities are much closer than that, and in NYC it's practically neighborhood by neighborhood with the absurdly wealthy cities farther out.
- mikeyouse 12y agoSubstitute Grosse Pointe for Bloomfield if you want an extraordinarily wealthy suburb within single-digit miles of deeply poor neighborhoods.
- wtbob 12y ago> Detroit is the perfect microcosm of the US wealth polarity trend. Au contraire, Detroit is a perfect microcosm of absolutely abominable government and culture. Sure, this has led to wealth disparity, as anyone with the means to get out, has. But the root cause is awful governance.
- jrochkind1 12y agoSo you realize that "anyone with the means to get out" of Detroit started doing so 1968ish after the riots, and it in fact is what caused the population and economic decline of Detroit? One really did come before the other, and it was the exodus of white people (followed by the auto companies) before it was the collapse of the city or any accusations of 'abominable government' (and 'culture', what?). It's kind of just what happened.
- FunCaptcha_Jim 12y agoAs I live in Australia, to see a city like this in such a state is saddening. Of course, everyone has heard stories of Detroit's issues but to see them so starkly pictured is pretty confronting. What's the current economic state of Detroit? Is it still in decline or is there reason to be optimistic?
- dubfan 12y agoThe city government is just beginning to emerge from bankruptcy, so there is some hope there. But they still have a chicken and egg problem: the city has to provide a reasonable level of services to attract businesses and their workers, but they need the tax base to provide those services. What the solution to that will end up being is anyone's guess.
- FunCaptcha_Jim 12y agoThat was my assumption. It appears Detroit could potentially be reliant on a wealthy entrepreneur to take a "leap of faith" or have a third party offer some sort of financial incentive to encourage businesses back. I'm not too well versed on US law but is the federal government able to help in this vein?
- unprepare 12y agoDan Gilbert is likely that wealthy entrepreneur [1] Also, it is worth noting that the suburbs surrounding detroit include some of the wealthiest in the country. There is certainly an investor base [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Gilbert_%28businessman%29#Detroit_initiatives http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Gilbert_%28businessman%29#D...
- cowsandmilk 12y agoDetroit will recover due to its history as a hub. It is a cheap place to live that has direct flights to Europe, Asia, South America, and almost any city in the US. Also, Detroit has plenty of wealth. It just all sits in the suburbs. The article even shows a mansion in Grosse Pointe and another with 23,000 square feet in West Bloomfield. These people are definitely executives at businesses in the Detroit area.
- acomjean 12y agoI saw Alex MacLean (the photographer) give a talk about his aerial photography in at the lincoln library last century. It was great, not only are the images great, but he takes time to explain why they are significant. From the air is an interesting way to analyze. He's got more on his website: http://www.alexmaclean.com http://www.alexmaclean.com
- marquis 12y agoA recent Jim Jarmusch & Tilda Swinton film, Only Lovers Left Alive, was set partially in a decaying Detroit mansion as the perfect home and city for ancient vampires wanting a quiet home. I found it an interesting commentary on Detroit. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Only_Lovers_Left_Alive http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Only_Lovers_Left_Alive
- mojoe 12y agoMy younger brother recently graduated from college and got a software development job in Detroit. It's nice to see pictures that provide a feel for what Detroit currently looks like. From what I've heard, there is a trend for bootstrapped startups to move to Detroit to take advantage of the low cost of living. Unfortunately the lack of public services in some places is scary, but it seems like things are improving post-bankruptcy.
- therobot24 12y agoOff topic question - i've seen the phrase "bootstrapped startup" at lot, but am unsure of it's meaning. I'm familiar with the web-template 'bootstrap', but not sure how it sets one startup apart from another. Does it mean that they are they funded and out of "stealth mode", or that they specifically use the bootstrap template (meaning low cost, potentially unfunded)?
- hboon 12y agoRefers to a startup that is funded by the founders and from reinvesting the profits of the startup, rather than funding from angels and VCs. It comes from the term bootstrap used in computing.
- smcl 12y agoI think it may actually be from the idiom "to pull yourself up by the bootstraps" meaning to succeed depending solely on yourself: http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pull_oneself_up_by_one%27s_bootstraps http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pull_oneself_up_by_one%27s_boo...
- efraim 12y agoThat is precisely where the term comes from in computing. A computer that is booting up is starting itself up.
- blueskin_ 12y agoThat sounds risky. Chances are, someone who's good at what they do isn't going to want to move to somewhere like Detroit, so they are going to have to replace staff. Sure, salary there is probably a pittance, but the talent pool for any skilled work would also be small.
- dionidium 12y agoA few random thoughts reading this as a St. Louisan. Similar views can be had here: https://www.google.com/maps/@38.6349498,-90.2105613,1547a,20y,41.29t/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@38.6349498,-90.2105613,1547a,20... That same neighborhood from the ground: http://instagram.com/p/qZ9CXbhAXu/ http://instagram.com/p/qZ9CXbhAXu/ Also, noticed some tags that are present here, too. For example, the REFT in that shot of the Eastern Market District. Here's one from St. Louis: http://instagram.com/p/vMiNSnhAT-/ http://instagram.com/p/vMiNSnhAT-/
- zenocon 12y agoAs a local, it is encouraging that what the pilot sees from the air, I also see from the ground: > From the air today, the decline appears to be slowing. The spaces once covered in rubble are cleared and mowed. Open green spaces, along with new community gardens and orchards, look almost bucolic against the downtown skyline. From my plane, I sense the potential for resurgence in these areas. > I think that the inner ring of Detroit will win out in the long run, as cities are and will continue to be the greenest places to live on a per-capita basis. It is really, really hard to bring a city back from this, but it is happening here.
- ianbicking 12y agoWe see a lot of the most blighted areas, but out of curiosity: what's the best neighborhood inside Detroit city limits?
- rmason 12y agoThere are probably seven or eight nice neighborhoods in Detroit. If I was to pick two it would be Indian Village or Palmer Park which both have their own private security 24 hours a day. Big well kept houses with narrow streets. A few more better than average would be downtown, Corktown, N. Rosedale, S. Rosedale (where I grew up)and Sherwood Forest. I tell people to think of Detroit not as a big monolith but as a series of villages, some are OK to visit and others are to be avoided at all costs.
- mklim 12y agoMidtown is doing well now as well. Lived there for three years and just visited again for the first time in 6 months or so for Noel Night. I saw a handful of businesses there that had all been established since the time I moved out. Lots of stuff to do, and it's pretty safe. Response time from the WSUPD is just a couple minutes, and they take calls for a few mile radius outside WSU's campus. http://www.livemidtown.org/ http://www.livemidtown.org/ is a decent marketing site with more info on it.
- ianbicking 12y agoIt's interesting that Indian Village, Palmer Park, and Midtown all benefit from a police force alternative to Detroit PD. I wonder if there are other services like this? I would assume private schooling would be common, but what about things like public works?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- agilebyte 12y agoThere is Navut[0] for Canada and Neighborhood Scout[1] for US to answer that. [0]: http://www.navut.com/finder#/metro http://www.navut.com/finder#/metro [1]: http://www.neighborhoodscout.com/mi/detroit/crime/ http://www.neighborhoodscout.com/mi/detroit/crime/
- lchengify 12y agoThe Packard Plant caught my interest so I looked it up [1]. Most of the plant is structurally sound: Renovations started in October to turn it into a mixed use art / manufacturing facility [2]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Packard_Automotive_Plant http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Packard_Automotive_Plant [2] http://www.wxyz.com/news/region/detroit/demolition-and-rehab-begins-at-the-packard-plant http://www.wxyz.com/news/region/detroit/demolition-and-rehab...
- percept 12y agoYou might find this interesting: http://vimeo.com/39346092 http://vimeo.com/39346092
- rmason 12y agoDetroit was hit very hard by the 2008 real estate collapse. Here's a blog showing pictures before and after. You can see a stretch of houses that were occupied and doing fine in say 2006 and just a bare stretch of ground five years later. http://goobingdetroit.tumblr.com/ http://goobingdetroit.tumblr.com/
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pyre 12y agoThe city of Detroit was in a financial crisis back to at least 2004. I believe that it was the 2004 Census that put the city below 1M people, which lost them a lot of Federal dollars.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt's reasonable to look as far back as the 1970s/1980s when the net population of Wayne+Oakland counties stopped increasing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wayne_County,_Michigan#Demographics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wayne_County,_Michigan#Demograp... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oakland_County,_Michigan#Demographics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oakland_County,_Michigan#Demogr... The decline didn't quite start then, but the drop in population is certainly one of the big contributing factors.
- netcan 12y agoHave there been proposals following this bankruptcy to split Detroit out into sub-"cities?" The actual definition of a city is somewhat arbitrary. In Australia for example, the official "city" unit that manages municipal services is actually not Melbourne or Sydney it's smaller units usually encompassing a population of 100k or so. The division of responsibilities between federal, state and city is different but I think the takeaway is that while "Detroit" is a geographical and cultural unit, it doesn't mean it has to be a municipal one. Maybe such a change of paradigm would be helpful here. The thought of rehabilitating a new entity comprised of suburbs, but not the downtown (or via versa) might be a less daunting task. It;s easier to move the needle. Bankruptcy seems a good time to do something like this.
- maxerickson 12y agoI tried to understand the law on this a bit during a previous discussion. In Michigan, cities are established by a municipal charter. That charter can more or less only be amended by a vote of the people living in the city. I think would be very difficult to make such a proposal that did not end up drawing economic lines (in some sense, such lines are natural). People on one side of such a line would be strongly incentivized to oppose it. So it's likely to be impossible politically.
- helipad 12y agoBrush Park features in a lot of those photos (just up from Ford Field and Comerica Park). There are beautiful historic buildings with great swaths of vacant land. It's a designated historical district, so the city is making it tough for a layperson to buy a lot. For example, all available tax foreclosed lots in the area were removed from the treasurer's auction. I suppose they're trying to prevent ugly condos being built, but then you get a situation like this where an area very close to downtown is so sparse.
- blueskin_ 12y agoNo paywall: https://archive.today/nbdzT https://archive.today/nbdzT
- netcan 12y agoFor any radical community building idea (like a cult or a commune) Detroit poses some interesting possibilities. It seems like an urban acreage with a bunch of houses or other buildings could be bought for the price of an average house. I'm imagining some sort of new age Amish colonizers.
- netcan 12y agoEDIT - This was kind of a joke. But after writing it, I actually think it's it's an interesting idea for some sort of kibutz-ish urban village project.
- SyncTheory13 12y agoYou may be interested in reading Bolo'Bolo by P.M. or http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Widmer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Widmer I've taken a lot of inspiration from this for future plans.
- cwal37 12y agoDetroit seems to be turning the corner at the bottom of a decades-long economic slide, but there are also some interesting long-term environmental trends that I think bode well for it and many smaller rust belt towns. Most pressingly, a lot of those towns are directly on arterial waterways and receive copious amounts of rain. So you get extremely cheap transportation of goods, and you also just have a water supply in general. There may have been a great migration to the Southwest over the last 40-50 years, but it's hard to picture a scenario where that area's ecological budgetary chickens don't come home to roost at some point. Then, Detroit and other communities like it become significantly more attractive.
- andor436 12y agoOne major issue for Detroit, assuming it can emerge from bankruptcy and state management, is how to provide reasonable levels of services to a vastly-reduced population density. Other Michigan cities (like Flint) are facing similar issues. Check out https://motorcitymapping.org https://motorcitymapping.org and http://report.timetoendblight.org/ http://report.timetoendblight.org/ - good ways to see the scope of the problem.
- cwal37 12y agoTotally. Their in-the-ground infrastructure was built to serve a completely different kind of population. I'm just thinking even longer term. This Planet Money episode[1] does a great job painting a picture of the back and forth between residents having their water shut off and finding ways to turn it back on. [1] http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/08/08/338068996/episode-559-detroits-water-bill http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/08/08/338068996/episode-...
- roc 12y ago> "assuming it can emerge from bankruptcy and state management" Assuming? http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/12/05/detroit-bankruptcy-manager-resigns/19961603/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/12/05/detroit... Edit: I'm downvoted for pointing out that the exit is all but finalized and thus "assuming" is an unnecessary qualifier?
- dylanbox 12y agoDetroiter who works at a tech startup here in the city: great bit of photography and a really interesting message, but there is one notable absence in the contrast between the haves and have-nots is in the city of Detroit. There's a huge wealth gap between Detroit and the surrounding suburbs, but there's a pretty big one in the city as well. There's plenty of investment and activity happening in the "Downtown Development District" than the surrounding neighborhoods, which were hit the hardest from population decline. There's plenty of money and attention that goes to typically young and white tech startups that have recently located (myself included) while other (typically minority) entrepreneurs are left out of the narrative of the "rebirth" of Detroit. It's a lot about race, politics, and access to capital, but it's going to be readily apparent in a few years which areas have been given preferential treatment from state oversight (and tax-write-offs) and local investment.
- personZ 12y agoIt's a lot about race You just made it about race, but really it's talent pool and demographics and education/skill levels. If a software group moves to downtown Detroit, it seems destructive to hold that as a negative, as if having some bright spots is somehow a negative because that software group doesn't hire the pipe fitter with the a grade 7 education.
- dahart 12y agoNo. The story of Detroit's decline and it's comeback has been about race for decades. Talent pool, education, demographics, and skill levels in Detroit are a function of race, which dylanbox has experienced first hand and shared. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detroit#Race_and_ethnicity http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detroit#Race_and_ethnicity
- personZ 12y agoThe context of this discussion is the "rebirth" of Detroit, not race riots or the 1950s. If Detroit's rebirth is a high-skill, high-tech industry, the exclusion of many Detroit residents has everything to do with skills and education, and absolutely nothing to do with race.
- mathattack 12y agoIs this the new model of urban decay? There is a large trend towards urbanism, but not every city is a winner.
- Zigurd 12y agoThe Economist recently published a contrarian article claiming that suburbs are the real winner on a global scale.
- mathattack 12y agoInteresting. Link? I see some suburbs winning and some losing but don't have an aggregate view.
- Zigurd 12y agohttp://www.economist.com/suburbs http://www.economist.com/suburbs
- mathattack 12y agoOf course - how obvious. :-)
- freshyill 12y agoA lot of it actually looks really nice, almost like it's in the country or a very small town. If they can keep tearing down the completely blighted areas, it seems like they can actually turn it into something quite pleasant.
- wmeredith 12y agoI was also struck in the same manner by the green spaces. They seem like a plus, but the tax base resulting from such a low density population does lend itself well to running city services.
- c0nsumer 12y agoThey seem like a plus, until you see the remaining houses up close. They are usually in terrible shape, and decent ones are targets for crime in a city where emergency service response is often measured in hours.
- mmccaff 12y agoI was just talking about the potential reinvigoration of Detroit this morning, because of this NYT article from yesterday: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/08/arts/galapagos-art-space-will-make-detroit-its-home.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/08/arts/galapagos-art-space-w... This is a really unique, innovative venue for the arts that has been operating in Brooklyn for almost 20 years. A long time for a venue to exist in NY, and a testament to their founder. They are headed to Detroit because of how high rent has become. If Galapagos can recreate what they had done in NY, it's a real win for the area that they are moving into.
- Paul-ish 12y agoWho mows the lawns on the empty lots?
- q2 12y agoI can see cars, buildings,greenery but I could not see a single person in any photo. Why is that? Why there are no people on roads?