4 ms·
To which trips are you referring? Do you have any data to support your statement? I created a quick list of cities where high-speed rail should fit the distan
by melling 12y ago
To which trips are you referring? Do you have any data to support your statement? I created a quick list of cities where high-speed rail should fit the distance metric.
- tptacek 12y agoWhy, yes. I do have data. Thank you for asking. The top 10 cities in the US by GDP are, in order: * New York * Los Angeles * Chicago * Washington D.C. * Houston * Dallas * Philadelphia * San Francisco * Boston * Atlanta Here, for your reading pleasure, are the ground travel distances between all of those cities: New York Los Angeles 2475 Chicago 790 Washington D.C. 226 ** Houston 1416 Dallas 1389 Philadelphia 94 ** San Francisco 2907 Boston 215 ** Atlanta 750 Los Angeles Chicago 1745 Washington D.C. 2288 Houston 1379 Dallas 1235 Philadelphia 2401 San Francisco 380 Boston 2611 Atlanta 1947 Chicago Washington D.C. 696 Houston 1083 Dallas 924 Philadelphia 759 San Francisco 2130 Boston 983 Atlanta 716 Washington D.C. Houston 1400 Dallas 1328 Philadelphia 136 ** San Francisco 2816 Boston 437 ** Atlanta 639 Houston Dallas 239 Philadelphia 1544 San Francisco 1927 Boston 1848 Atlanta 792 Dallas Philadelphia 1464 San Francisco 1726 Boston 1791 Atlanta 781 Philadelphia San Francisco 2876 Boston 307 ** Atlanta 783 San Francisco Boston 3099 Atlanta 2472 Boston Atlanta 1099 I have, I hope helpfully, starred the sub-700-mile routes that are already served by the Acela. The average ground distance between these cities is (wait for it) 1,356 miles. Later You edited your comment upthread to include specific routes. My response --- apart from wondering why taxpayers in Arizona should fund a rail linkage to Orlando, the 30th biggest economy in the country, to Tampa, the 27th --- is to suggest that adding Florida to this graph would not improve the average cost of the edges.
- melling 12y agowhat does the average distance have to do with anything? Build between the cities where the distance makes sense. looks like there are several options. What about other population centers? Why is the gdp your criteria? Tampa and Orlando and Miami wouldn't make your list.
- tptacek 12y agoI said: most of the economically important trips in the US are more than 600 miles apart, except for the part of the country that is already well-served by rail You disputed this and asked for data. I provided data. If you would like to change the argument to "most of the important theme parks in the US are poorly connected to second-tier Florida cities by rail", I will happily concede that point. :) In the graph of the 45 trips between top-10 US cities, only two --- LA to SF, and Houston to Dallas --- fall under your "less than 700 mile" criteria. Just 4% of the most economically important trips not already served by the Acela are amenable to rail transit. Once again: most of the economically important trips in the US are more than 600 miles apart, except for the part of the country that is already well-served by rail. Incidentally: if you think "top 10" is unfair as a threshold, consider that the 11th city would be Seattle, and the 12th Miami. The average would go up if we included them.
- melling 12y agoThe average distance is irrelevant. Do the distance and population warrant the high-speed train service? Are there lots of flights between any two of these cities? The population of Spain is 50 million, for example. They've made high-speed rail work effectively.
- tptacek 12y agoThat's why my data is based on the top US cities by GDP. You can also find the busiest domestic airport pairs to back the analysis up. Oddly, the busiest air route in the US is NYC-Miami --- which is not amenable to rail travel.
- 12y ago