3 ms·
Doesn't this weakness potentially exist with any integrated payment page on any site using any payment platform, though? There is always a level of trust invol
by Silhouette 12y ago
Doesn't this weakness potentially exist with any integrated payment page on any site using any payment platform, though?
There is always a level of trust involved with entering these kinds of credentials on-line. This is why some of the 3-D Secure systems make you (the customer) give them a greeting of your own choice to incorporate in the prompt for your confirmation code.
However, it seems that for many vendors the losses due to a higher rate of aborted checkouts make such systems undesirable. Apparently most customers don't share the author's concern here, presumably either unaware of the potential security issues or just trusting that if anything does go wrong then some protection or guarantee from their payment service/card issuer will get it fixed.
I suspect the author here would argue that it would be better for on-line payments to be push transactions rather than pull, so users always actively send money via a trusted party such as their bank without ever handing over their bank-issued credentials to anyone else. No doubt many of us would agree with that; pull-based payment models are fundamentally insecure and absurdly vulnerable to fraud. But again, that goes for a lot more than just PayPal.
- MichaelGG 12y agoIf 3D is anything like the silly Verified by Visa, it's atrocious. Some strange domain that sounds like a generic phishing attempt. Random password with supposedly a secure phrase to indicate they know me... But anyone with my card details can look that up and show it for me. I see no value in such systems, and they must murder conversion rates.
- Silhouette 12y ago3-D Secure is the umbrella term for schemes like Verified by Visa, and yes, there has been a lot of criticism of both the added security (or not) and the disruption to the payment process and consequent hit on conversion rates. The major advantage for merchants of using these schemes is that liability for various types of card fraud is shifted elsewhere, instead of the merchant getting dumped with the cost of fraudulent transactions even if they did nothing wrong except trust the payment services to do their job. Much of this is likely to change again early next year, because there are SEPA-wide rules coming in that require strong authentication for Internet payments. Even the giant payment services can't ignore them, because liability for fraud on their networks is (finally) going to land on them whether they like it or not after the new rules take effect.