3 ms·
The only concrete things that you've suggested you would do is call colleges and previous employers' HR departments. That's both pretty trivial, and there are
by chrisseaton 12y ago
The only concrete things that you've suggested you would do is call colleges and previous employers' HR departments.
That's both pretty trivial, and there are lots of companies that already provide that service. They're usually marketed as background checks to do just before the offer, as you say, but I'm sure they could also do it up front as you're proposing.
- justincormack 12y agoHR departments normally have legal advice to say as little as possible. It would be hard to get a tech opinion out of them.
- chrisseaton 12y agoHe doesn't want a tech opinion - "Did they work for you from this year to that year?"
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoI once worked for a company that got sued by my predecessor, and won. However they spent so much in legal fees, that the lawsuit nearly bankrupted them. The code that my predecessor wrote worked very poorly, so they got bad press reviews, lots of product returns and so on. I was hired specifically because I said I was really good at debugging. After that, the company owner had a specific policy of not providing references. He gave a very neutral answer: "Our policy is not to provide references." However he was completely cool about verifying employment. His concern of course was that my predecessor would sue him again, were the company owner to give that guy a bad reference. Ironically, that same company owner is one of my own references. He's always happy to say good things about me.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoI've never so much as heard of someone verifying employment and graduation before interviewing a candidate. If it's done at all, it's the last step, after the interview but before the offer. While it's common for references to be contacted, it's quite uncommon for employment to be verified. Note that that's quite a different thing: "Did Bart Simpson do a good job for you?" is checking a reference. "Did Bart Simpson work for your company in 1999?" is verifying employment. One's references must be people who one actually knew, usually direct managers but sometimes coworkers. The person who supplies the employment verification need not have ever met the candidate. And yes I know this is not rocket science - but consider what I just said, that AMCC interviewed candidates for six months before they found someone who actually had done what the claimed, in my case writing OS X drivers. AMCC did a background check on me, but only AFTER I got the job offer, and with my written permission. While it might still have required six months to find a qualified candidate, AMCC could have saved a lot of effort and expense by sending some emails or making some phone calls before inviting candidates in to onsite interviews. Consider that it's quite common to pay for plane fare, car rental and hotel accommodation if the candidate has to travel. The employer still pays even if they don't make an offer.
- MichaelCrawford 12y agoI would do more than just verify employment, but I don't want to go into a whole lot of detail, not in public anyway. However I will say that I've been a manager, and even when I wasn't a manager I participated in hiring. I've also been working full-time as a coder since 1987. I wrote my first program in 1976. I can smell bullshit when I find it on a coder's resume.