4 ms·
> Some of the things I talked about, like Encrypted Media Extensions, were, for the most part, still a pipe dream with few to no working implementations. Why w
by shmerl 12y ago
> Some of the things I talked about, like Encrypted Media Extensions, were, for the most part, still a pipe dream with few to no working implementations.
Why would anyone dream about this DRM junk? Something to dream about is for example Daala codec which is supposed to arrive in 2015.
Also, is there any non patented and freely available technology for adaptive video streaming? Unless DASH is not patent encumbered.
- olefoo 12y agoYou don't want to encrypt your video chats with your lover? With your business associates? I guess you Don't Have Anything To Hide™.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- shmerl 12y agoEME has nothing to do with security and privacy. It's all about DRM. If you want to encrypt your video chats you'd use something like ZRTP.
- neohaven 12y agoSadly, good, solid DRM (Here's an encryption key, an encrypted file, and a secure way for me to limit when and how you can use those) is the ultimate form of Snapchat. If you don't have DRM backing it up, the scenario is "Here's a key, a locked box, do whatever you want with the decrypted file." Which is less secure than being able to actually limit usage of the decrypted file. Nothing here implies that I think DRM is a good thing, mind you. I just think saying something is "just DRM", as if DRM wasn't basically encryption + limitations on use.
- expr- 12y ago> a secure way for me to limit when and how you can use those That would be having them access the file in a restricted environment (literally, guards and stuff). You can't have people accessing your secrets in the comforts of their own homes and at the same time not be able to reproduce them in some form – even if an exact duplicate of the original data would be infeasible to obtain.
- malka 12y agoIt's the illusion of security. The DRM contains the private key (because, well, you have to decrypt it, at some point). A motivated hacker will be able to get it, and decrypt the file for its own use.
- shmerl 12y agoNo, as soon as you have some black box unauditable code, you shouldn't trust it for any such thing. And DRM by definition is hiding something from the user.
- zimbatm 12y agoWhen using WebRTC then data is already encrypted on the transport layer [1], otherwise use SSL. EME is a rebranding of DRM and nothing else. [1]: http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-avt-dtls-srtp-07 http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-avt-dtls-srtp-07
- lern_too_spel 12y agoThe context is an article titled "HTML5 Video and the End of Plugins." For somebody who only cares about ending plugins, that quote makes sense. A majority of browsers will implement the spec plugin-free, and Firefox-based browsers will have a single sandboxed plugin with less power than an NPAPI plugin, which is the only realistic alternative.
- shmerl 12y ago> For somebody who only cares about ending plugins, that quote makes sense. Replacing NPAPI plugin with some other DRM doesn't make anything better, whether it will be cooked into the browser or remain an external black box. Surely not something to dream about.
- lern_too_spel 12y agoExcept baking things into the browser is what the author's whole point is. The author doesn't care about black boxes. He cares about the end of plugins. He doesn't share your motivations. You're like Stallman wondering why an llvm user would be excited about a new feature in clang. That user doesn't necessarily care about free software purity.
- shmerl 12y agoSo what's so good about cooking things into the browser? Is it a self goal? Regular issues with plugins are security risks and lack of trust. DRM inside the browser doesn't help it and doesn't solve it. I'd say the opposite, it becomes much harder to separate so it only increases the risk. So the author can cheer for the abstract benefit of moving plugins in the browser, but actual benefit isn't explained, since it's actually not a benefit at all.
- mmcclure 12y agoHi there, I wrote this blog post, and I can assure you, as someone that works in the video industry EME is definitely something to dream about. DRM is absolutely, 100% a necessity if you want to deal with any content coming from anyone from whom you actually want their content. I'm not a fan of DRM, but it's simply a reality of the industry. It's weird, but most content doesn't have the same liberal license as Big Buck Bunny :) > So what's so good about cooking things into the browser? Remember RealPlayer? Windows Media Player? Quicktime? DivX? Flash? You don't see the benefit in getting to deal with these things less as a developer and, more importantly, a user?