7 ms·
This article, like most others, overlooks the primary reason the A-10 has been slated for retirement for so long even though no one contests its effectiveness i
by jandrewrogers 12y ago
This article, like most others, overlooks the primary reason the A-10 has been slated for retirement for so long even though no one contests its effectiveness in its role. Due to the way the aircraft was designed, it has very limited upgradeability compared to most US military aircraft.
While the airframe still makes for a great weapons platform, the sensor suites, avionics, and countermeasures are obsolete, and not in a good way. They've been doing a lot of nasty hacks to allow it to support modern weapon systems and electronics but there are a growing number of important capabilities that simply cannot be "backported" to that airframe.
This has been increasing its vulnerability to more advanced threats and reducing its ability to deploy more advanced weapons over time. Its shelf-life has been extended by virtue of it being used in practice against adversaries with unsophisticated weaponry. This makes it immediately useful in practice but the military is well-aware that it would not be nearly as successful against a more sophisticated adversary and this is why they have been angling for an alternative.
It is a relic of the Cold War not just in its history but, unfortunately, also in its defenses and weaponry with no obvious upgrade path. Its survivability and effectiveness are predicated on being used against Cold War level adversaries. To replace it with something that could support the capabilities they desire, they would need to design a completely new airframe.
- ori_b 12y agoIs the USA likely to go to war against anyone with sophisticated weaponry any time soon? It seems like we're mostly interested in wars in the third world at this point, and the A10 seems pretty well suited to that.
- bduerst 12y agoI know someone will have a differing opinion, but a lot of times it's not about having weaponry for the wars you will fight, but the wars that you won't fight. It's more game theory: If you have state of the art weaponry, the competition is less likely to start a war with you. This mentality also lead to the nuclear arms race, and today it is more about a race for automation and precision than just mass destruction.
- krisgee 12y ago>Is the USA likely to go to war against anyone with sophisticated weaponry any time soon? A military is like a parachute. It seems pretty useless until you need it.
- johnohara 12y agoRecent news article regarding the deployment of US tanks and armored vehicles requiring "close air support." http://news.yahoo.com/us-army-may-station-tanks-eastern-europe-general-221757453.html http://news.yahoo.com/us-army-may-station-tanks-eastern-euro... Army families pay close attention to the deployment of A-10's for good reason. On one side, A-10's provide critical assistance against enemy tanks and armored vehicles (combat leverage). On the other, it means soldiers (family members) are being deployed for possible ground combat.
- threeseed 12y agoRussia, Iran, China are all countries of concern in the middle to long term. Iran would obviously retaliate against efforts to destroy their nuclear infrastructure. Russia has stated that it will defend Russians anywhere leaving many Eastern European countries in question. China has stated quite clearly this year that it will start to assert its position as a counterweight superpower to the US.
- JabavuAdams 12y agoInteresting, but is this really an obstacle, or one of those relatively fixable obstacles that's exaggerated by people who really want shiny new planes? It just seems strange to me -- computers have gotten faster, batteries have gotten smaller, etc. If all of your avionics are theoretically lighter and smaller, how is it an issue to pack more functionality into the same airframe? Hell, remove the pilot and armoured bath-tub and make it into a drone.
- jandrewrogers 12y agoModern military aircraft generate and move an enormous amount of electrical power throughout the airframe to supply all of their avionics and weapons. Power systems take up a lot of space. The A-10 is an old school design, and there was no use case for installing large power systems when it was originally built. Unlike some other ancient airframes which had the spare room to retrofit power systems, the A-10 had little room to spare in its original design for a modern power system.
- JabavuAdams 12y agoOk, interesting. That's not something I'd considered.
- bdunbar 12y agoPhht - just run some extension cords on the outside. Problem solved. Man, the DoD is just not thinking outside the box.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>This article, like most others, overlooks the primary reason the A-10 has been slated for retirement for so long even though no one contests its effectiveness in its role. Due to the way the aircraft was designed, it has very limited upgradeability compared to most US military aircraft. The real reason is that it has always been the red-headed step-child of the ch-Air Force. There has never been any real interest in the CAS role from the mgmt, other than to keep that turf away from the Army and Marine Corps. >While the airframe still makes for a great weapons platform, the sensor suites, avionics, and countermeasures are obsolete, and not in a good way. They've been doing a lot of nasty hacks to allow it to support modern weapon systems and electronics but there are a growing number of important capabilities that simply cannot be "backported" to that airframe. I was about to make a similar comment that the A10 performs its role well despite having relatively primitive weapons / targeting systems. But I disagree about the reason for the obsolete weapons / electronics. Sensors and computers have only gotten smaller and better, and I am afraid I don't understand why you think that the A10 cannot be fitted with proper electronics and sensors. >This has been increasing its vulnerability to more advanced threats The definition of a CAS role practically implies that the airplane can only operate in an arena where air-superiority is assured. The A10 is by definition vulnerable to "more advanced threats" and so will any acceptable substitute share similar vulnerabilities. >Its shelf-life has been extended by virtue of it being used in practice against adversaries with unsophisticated weaponry. Exactly the kind of adversary it is being deployed against, though it has proven itself against others as well. >It is a relic of the Cold War not just in its history but, unfortunately, also in its defenses and weaponry with no obvious upgrade path. To replace it with something that could support the capabilities they desire, they would need to design a completely new airframe. I agree, and I hope they call it the A10-mkII, and that it is practically a modern rebuild of the A10.
- jandrewrogers 12y agoThe vulnerabilities and limitations of concern are not addressed by air superiority. It lacks modern protection from more sophisticated ground threats. Basically, the US military is concerned because they know that they already have ground threat capabilities that would significantly reduce the survivability of platforms like the A-10. Looking forward, they expect this level of weapon sophistication to trickle down to increasingly unsophisticated adversaries. The A-10 lacks the power systems required to drive modern defenses and weapons. It is no different than how the US military has been planning for the obsolescence of heavy armor.
- sgnelson 12y agoThe "Upgradeability" argument is a moot point considering there is no other airframe that can come close to replacing the A-10 in the missions it is best at. To say that the plane isn't nearly "upgradeable" enough (A point on the face I would dispute, as it's already been upfitted with Pave gear) is to say, "let's get rid of the plane because it's not good enough for future battles we might fight, and if we do, then we'll have absolutely nothing capable now." It's an argument that completely lacks any real world basis. I don't get rid of my only computer because it's a Pentium 3 because it's old, until I have something that can actually replace it (and no, it won't/can't be replaced by the JSF). Also, I point out that the A-10 is actually young compared to some of the planes we're still flying. B52 anyone? U-2? We don't stop flying planes because they're old, we stop flying them because there is something better to replace them. At this time, no such thing exists for the A-10. Also, it's insane to say that the missions that the plane "Might" be used for in the future don't suit the plane, considering the missions it actually has, are almost perfect for it (ground support in Iraq as the article states). The truth is that the Air Force doesn't want the plane and they're trying to come up with any excuse to kill it, despite the fact that it actually saves US troops lives.
- 542458 12y ago> The truth is that the Air Force doesn't want the plane I'm not disputing the truth of this (as their actions seem to agree with you), but what do you think motivates the air force to want to get rid of such a successful platform?
- autokad 12y ago#1 cost (mostly due to lack of upfront funding to keep costs down) #2 it doesnt look/scound cool like those 'new' planes. it sounds great to have a cool new jet fighter with (some) stealth and can do neat loopty loops and use the latest and greatest air to air and electronic warfare systems, BUT none of these new planes actually come anywhere close to fulfilling the close ground support role the A-10 offers. its much akin to wanting the best fantasy stat players on your sports team but come to find those metrics don't win championships / make teams.
- InclinedPlane 12y agoTotally makes perfect sense. It's not a good plane to fight the hypothetical wars against adversaries that the US might never engage on the battlefield. Though it is actually hugely effective against the current enemies of the US. And for that reason it should be retired from service. Makes perfect sense.
- mpyne 12y ago> It's not a good plane to fight the hypothetical wars against adversaries that the US might never engage on the battlefield. More to the point, it is taking away resources to field the planes that would be needed for that hypothetical fight against an adversary with a modern military. Worse, the inability of the U.S. military to fight and win against states with modern militaries makes war more likely, not less likely. While the A-10 is certainly a good CAS platform against armed forces unable to oppose it with even 20-year old anti-air defenses, the U.S. does have other aircraft that can perform that role (even if not to the standard as the A-10). Between the AC-130, Army helicopter aviation, F-15, -16, -22 and -35, there's no lack of capability to put ordnance on target in support of ground troops. The big thing those airframes are missing (except for the helos and AC-130) is loiter time and cannons that go "brrrpt", but neither of those are so critical to CAS as is popularly implied. In other words, the USAF is arguing against maintaining a weapon system that doesn't deter conflict against states one iota, doesn't deter conflict against extremists (who are not deterrable by the same military calculus in any event), and whose most prominent capability isn't that much of a leap ahead of other platforms the USAF (and US Army) already have to maintain and field anyways. Although it can certainly kill people, the A-10 was designed to hunt and destroy Soviet tanks, and yet you don't see too many tanks being fielded by ISIS (even with the Iraqi tanks they've captured, they don't have the logistical or maintenance capabilities needed to properly employ them).
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoTaking away the A10 to feed the JSF program is like deleting txt files to get hard disk space back. >In other words, the USAF is arguing against maintaining a weapon system that doesn't deter conflict against states one iota, None of that other garbage deterred any conflict. >doesn't deter conflict against extremists (who are not deterrable by the same military calculus in any event), Right, so, why mention it? > and whose most prominent capability isn't that much of a leap ahead of other platforms the USAF (and US Army) already have to maintain and field anyways. [x] Can draw enemy fire while wingman locates attackers. Not a capability of any other aircraft in the stable. Thanks to another poster (tim333) we have yet another recent example of an A10 actually doing a job like that, which no other group would do. http://www.af.mil/News/ArticleDisplay/tabid/223/Article/466762/bagram-pilots-save-60-soldiers-during-convoy-ambush.aspx http://www.af.mil/News/ArticleDisplay/tabid/223/Article/4667... I don't know where the AC130 were but the helicopters didn't want any part of it. The A10 pilots were all like "I'll go draw some fire while you look for 'em." You can't do that in a helicopter.
- protomyth 12y agoTrue, but our ground troops (some relatives and friends) love this thing because it can hang around for an extended period of time. The F-35 and helicopters cannot. That is what matters and until we get something that has the performance of the A-10 (the F-35 does not), we need to keep this one active. The other truth is that the Air Force doesn't like it and never has. I seriously believe that they have lost sight of their origin and am starting to think as a cost saving measure the Air Force should be put back under the Army. They want fighters not something that gets dirty. "Its survivability and effectiveness are predicated on being used against Cold War level adversaries." It does pretty well against the Taliban.
- ricree 12y ago>True, but our ground troops (some relatives and friends) love this thing because it can hang around for an extended period of time. The F-35 and helicopters cannot To what extent do/will drones fill this role? My understanding was that flight time was an area they often excelled at.
- protomyth 12y agoA drone shoots off its missiles and turns into an observer. An A-10 can hang around and shoot enemies that threaten the ground troops. No drone that I'm aware of has been built to provide continuous troop protection for a long period of time.
- tootie 12y agoIf our enemies don't have antiaircraft capabilities that can beat it, it's not obsolete. So long we're fighting countries that use salvaged soviet weapons, we won't have a problem. We're not going up against China any to e soon.
- tim333 12y agoThere's some footage of the upgrades that they have done here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YktOuoqA-I&feature=youtu.be&t=4m35s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YktOuoqA-I&feature=youtu.be... It's quite an interesting documentary in general on the A10s role. "Grunts of the Air." Made by the air force then shelved.
- runjake 12y ago[citation needed] I have a hard time seeing that. Serious nasty hacks to retrofit new avionics systems into improbably obtuse spaces is par for the course. My wrists are totally destroyed from years of screwing and unscrewing retrofitted black boxes with a screwdriver at weird angles. I don't know anything about the A-10 airframe, but I kinda suspect its an airframe structural issue. Your theory isn't impossible or unlikely, but got any documentation?
- curiously 12y agoI disagree with this The f-35 is a good example of how post cold war weaponry has gone to shit.