5 ms·
The only reason the A-10 is constantly threatened with retirement is politics. The USAF insists they control fixed-wing aircraft, leaving the Army to helis or
by CapitalistCartr 12y ago
The only reason the A-10 is constantly threatened with retirement is politics. The USAF insists they control fixed-wing aircraft, leaving the Army to helis or depend on the AF to support. But the AF looks down their nose at ground support. If we'd get politicians with backbone to yank ground support back to the Army, this yo-yo nonsense would end.
And the reason the A-10 is still around is because it take the federal bureaucracy longer to end a program than it does to start a new war. Then they really need the A-10 because it works.
(Ex-Air Force)
- bengali3 12y agoDo you think the USAF will look down on Textron's "world’s most affordable tactical jet aircraft."[1] and the concept of private companies building tactical aircraft prior to orders From a development cost standpoint I think this is a great experiment as it will skip a lot of the external politics, project managment headaches, requirements changes and politics again. But I fear politics will shun this type of development from taking off. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textron_AirLand_Scorpion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textron_AirLand_Scorpion
- thrill 12y agoDo you think the USAF will look down on Textron's "world’s most affordable tactical jet aircraft."[1] and the concept of private companies building tactical aircraft prior to orders You mean like they did with the F-20 Tigershark? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_F-20_Tigershark http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_F-20_Tigershark
- hydrogen18 12y agoI think you're missing the mark with F-20 Tigershark. The development was started under one political mindset and that mindset was blown away by Reagan. It doesn't make sense to develop an export aircraft when there are existing aircraft with superior capabilities suddenly available for export. There is a point to be made: aircraft are chosen for political reasons, not for their suitably to the mission. The A-10 is an example of an exceptionally suitable aircraft as is the B-52. This is not a reflection of good decision making, but just the outcome of random selection. If you build enough boondoogles (i.e. JSF) you eventually accidentally build a useful aircraft. These aircraft prove their utility and are kept around whereas the glass elephants are quietly retired. For example, consider the B-58. By all measures it was an amazing aircraft that met all of its goals. But by the time it was complete, it was built for a mission that no longer existed. The aircraft literally had no role by the time it became operational.
- sgnelson 12y agoTHe B-1 is another great example of a plane built for a mission that no longer exists. We still fly them, but it was a true boondoggle of it's time.
- hydrogen18 12y agoAbsolutely. It was meant to replace the B-52 but the B-52 is likely to outlive it. I'm not really even sure how it is an improvement on the B-52 anyways. The listed payloads on Wikipedia is higher than that of the B-52, but I'm not sure I trust those numbers. I don't think it much matters that it is supersonic. The US enjoys air superiority in all conflicts by virtue of it being the only one with planes in the air. Perhaps it is slightly less vulnerable to SAMs due to its speed advantage? The US is pretty good at neutralizing SAM installations using missiles, long before any planes get over the battlefield. I don't see how the B-1B can fit into a modern military.
- digi_owl 12y agoNever mind the F-104 "lawn dart".
- chrisbennet 12y agoYeah, but it looked cool. :-)
- Roboprog 12y agoThe Wikipedia description of the Scorpion describes a plane which has a top speed and ceiling that barely match a commercial jet liner. Maybe they are going to sell these to 3rd world countries to harass revolutionaries? The USAF would not use these to fight other countries. Edit: or maybe to sell to rich kids who want to pretend that they are fighter pilots (I suppose it would be a hell of a hobbyist ride) :-)
- hydrogen18 12y agoIt is a morbid reality, but the market for those planes is exactly as you described it. The established warlord who has become wealthy through conquest and now wants ground-attack aircraft to reinforce his authority. It'll be popular amongst supporters as well since it is such a visible emblem of power and collateral damage will be low. But yes, the idea of that plane going up against any modern fighter is a joke. Even the dated Mig-21 would have no problem destroying that plane using just the cannon.
- Roboprog 12y agoI looked at the article again a bit more closely. The Scorpion does have a valid use: as an observation platform. Essentially, replacing the repurposed Pipers or Cessnas that were used in the WW II to Vietnam era for spotting ground targets.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoThe given reason the A-10 is retiring is very effective MANPADS are proliferating and the A-10 is too vulnerable. It doesn't seem so easy to dismiss the point to me. Many systems people claim are great have worked well against dirt poor "insurgents" in recent foolish wars of choice. Arming against a more serious adversary is a separate question.
- Donzo 12y agoThen again, the US chooses to go to war a lot, so that doesn't negate the value of this aircraft.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoManpads are a threat to all aircraft. Any good CAS means going low enough and slow enough to see what's going on. This makes any CAS vulnerable to a variety of ground attacks. The AF solution is to fly higher and faster: great for them less good for the ground troops. A better solution will probably be drones. But, again, the AF is cool on drones when everyone else loves them (including CIA). The major problem is the AF won't let the army provide it's own ficed-wing CAS, but doesn't have enthusiasm for the job.
- digi_owl 12y agoI read a claim that said AF have a higher drone loss than the other branches, because they let their "pilots" do manual landings...
- jschwartzi 12y agoCould an A-10 survive a direct hit from a MANPADS or two?
- digi_owl 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairchild_Republic_A-10_Thunderbolt_II#Durability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairchild_Republic_A-10_Thunde... Would not surprise me...
- 12y ago