8 ms·
Instacart Is Raising North of $100M at a $2B Valuation
- minimaxir 12y ago> The raise will value the startup at $2 billion, or more than quadruple the $400 million valuation of its Series B financing from June. Quadruple? In less than 6 months? That's not hockey-stick growth, that's just plain insanity.
- walterbell 12y agoOr pragmatic getting-while-the-getting-is-good.
- mikeyouse 12y agoAs a comparison, Uber raised money at a $18B valuation in June, and then closed a round at $40B a few days ago. While a smaller percentage increase, Instacart's $1.6B increase in value looks pretty trivial compared to Uber's $22B increase over the same time period.
- SeoxyS 12y agoTechnically it's quintupling, not quadrupling. Not sure why the writers chose to phrase it like that.
- nwenzel 12y agoCongrats Apoorva and team! Wow. Instacart wasn't first. Webvan was around over a decade ago. More proof that ideas aren't worth much. Execution is everything.
- mchristoff 12y agoI'd say the lesson here isn't just execution, it's timing.
- mikeyouse 12y agoTo provide some figures for your point, Webvan was founded in 1999 when there were ~100M internet users in the US. Instacart was founded in 2012, when there were over 250M internet users. The success of these services is definitely a question of achieving sufficient scale to break even, which is much easier with a nearly 3x larger market. http://i.imgur.com/44lkXHa.png http://i.imgur.com/44lkXHa.png Edit: Clearly it's not the only reason they've succeeded, they've smartly avoided all the capital infrastructure that Webvan relied on and mobile devices have improved tremendously but when you're talking about tenths of a percentage points in penetration, tripling your TAM is huge.
- lolwutf 12y ago...or, GPS enabled phones.
- qq66 12y agoThe major difference is not the size of the market. The major difference is that Instacart piggybacks on the existing grocery store network, meaning that they don't have to pay for the overhead of a big warehouse. That lets them scale up with their user base instead of having to invest a lot of money up front in warehouses.
- Animats 12y agoSo does Safeway. The trouble with doing this out of grocery stores is that the order system doesn't know what's in inventory, and some fraction of your items won't show up. Amazon Fresh is doing this with their own warehouses and robots. They know their own inventory, and will probably crush these manual-picking operations.
- bduerst 12y agoAmazon has never had to deal with their own delivery fleets before, or perishable goods in their warehouses. While it's true Amazon has other revenue streams, Fresh is still just an experiment at this point. It's a race to see who can take the market, and Amazon is taking a slower, infrastructure based approach. It will be interesting to see if they will see it through to the end.
- abalone 12y agoHow can you say that without knowing Instacart's financials? Without that, can you really say this funding announcement is different from Webvan's funding announcements 15 years ago?
- nwenzel 12y agoI worked at a company that had many dot-com boom and bust companies as customers. 1-800-flowers changed their name to 1-800-flowers.com to increase the value of their brand. Barron's published some research in March (I think) of 2001 from Pegasus Research showing a list of publicly traded companies who, by their own optimistic estimates, would run out of cash and how many quarters of cash they had remaining. I remember because I identified the balance owed by each of those companies to us and gave the Controller and CFO the bad news, Yes, the funding environment is different.
- spullara 12y agoI was using Peapod in 1994, 5 years after it was founded, over a modem and their proprietary software: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peapod http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peapod It massively increased in size during the dotcom boom along with Webvan and Kozma, after it burst it retreated.
- somberi 12y agoInstacart prices are consistently more expensive than having it delivered from the stores directly (including a shipping fee). Here in NYC, where grocery prices are already expensive, it aches me to pay even more. Seems like NYtimes (1) had done an article on Instacart being expensive (and Instacart's FAQ says that they add a markup) Google Express is not a competition yet. They do not carry many popular products / perishables. (1)- http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/22/technology/personaltech/online-grocery-start-up-takes-page-from-sharing-services.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/22/technology/personaltech/on...
- apoorvamehta 12y agoHey! This is apoorva from Instacart. Our prices for most stores are the same as the store and we are working on getting other stores to have the same prices as well. Stay tuned :)
- badusername 12y agoWhich stores are they? I mostly shop at Whole Foods and Costco, if those prices are exact, I wouldn't mind throwing more business Instacart's way. Oh yea, losing 8% cashback at wholefoods that Amex gives is a sting in the back of the mind too. You should work on fixing that.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bwilliams 12y agoInstacart is also a good bit more expensive than Peapod as well, although Instacart's UI is much better.
- grandalf 12y agoThat has not been my experience with Instacart in NY. In fact, the website helps find popular, affordable items which helps me avoid the pricey alternatives that are typically promoted heavily by the stores.
- bduerst 12y ago
- mrmch 12y agoWoah, as an instacart-lover and yc alum, big props to Apoorva and team. Joining the rare group of $1B+ YC companies!
- encoderer 12y agoWe use instacart, and it's great for the small weekday shopping trip. Maybe in our home we're just more selective grocery shoppers than most, but I would never use them for meat and even much produce. Meat, for example.. I've asked for boneless chicken breasts from the butcher and instead i've gotten prepackaged shrink-wrapped, and recently I requested a single double-cut beef tenderloin and instead got 2 single-cuts. In both cases, InstaCart made amends (50% refund) but I have a meal to cook: I don't want a refund, I want what I ordered. Another reason we couldn't move totally to IC is how they handle credit cards. We get 6% cashback at grocery stores using the Amex Blue Cash card. (And have a 5% cashback Visa for the stores that don't take Amex). Unfortunately, IC charges come thru as internet services, not grocery. So that's a 6% price increase right off the top, in addition to mark-ups on products and delivery fees. We purchased their "prime" and will continue to use the service, but i still have the dream of being able to replace all my in-store grocery shopping.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- apoorvamehta 12y agoThanks for the feedback. We are working on those issues. And, trust me, that is our dream as well :)
- jbrad7354 12y agoPlease make the credit card MCC thing a priority. I know Stripe doesn't expose this (yet), but Braintree does.
- bmmayer1 12y agoThat's so interesting. I only use Instacart for meat. I get Costco meat by the freezerful every three months and it works great.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 12y ago
- HorizonXP 12y agoAbsolutely proud of what Apoorva, Brandon, Max, and the entire team have built. I remember working on their first Android app back in Max's apartment. They're truly deserving of their success so far. Can't wait to see what they do next with this war chest.
- ukd1 12y agoCongrats to Apoorva!
- thebyrd 12y agowebvan
- charlespwd 12y agoThis concept is absolutely fantastic. I can't wait to see this cover more cities. The potential for this is enormous. Keep it up guys!
- grandalf 12y agoInstacart is one of the first businesses I've interacted with as a customer that I can hardly help telling everyone I know about. It's just that amazing. And where do they find such pleasantly disposed people to deliver the groceries???
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Chetane 12y agoShopping express doesn't really sell groceries, while Instacart is all about groceries. Both services are very different...
- andreash 12y agoInterestingly they got rejected by YC in the first place: http://techcrunch.com/2012/08/18/how-instacart-hacked-yc/ http://techcrunch.com/2012/08/18/how-instacart-hacked-yc/
- flavio87 12y agoseems like their executing incredibly well and big congrats to the team. I do wonder a bit how defensible this model is - it seems to me that safeway already has most of the infrastructure available to do deliveries and then could significantly outperform instacart deliveries from safeway in terms of customer experience for example. - they always know what's in stock in which facility when you order, no more replaced or missing items - they don't charge the high 20-30% markup that instacart charges to their customers in terms of marketing, they could probably have lower cost of acquisition on scale as well. - they could market their app in-store very aggressively at every single checkout counter. what Safeway is most obviously lacking is a frontend that's as good as instacarts, but now that instacart has shown how to build it, it should be easy for safeway to build this out. maybe they don't have their distribution setup such that they could actually deliver within 1-2 hours? what else am I missing? how can this be a defensible business long term?
- serge2k 12y agoJust ordered some groceries for tomorrow, hope it goes well. I find myself constantly too worn out after work to buy groceries, and buying amazon fresh is only good for some stuff.
- deathflute 12y agoWe used them recently in nyc and user experience was great. However once you do the math, a 10 - 15% markup on most products in addition to delivery fees, tips, (or prime) is simply too much if you use them on a regular basis. The annualized cost for a small family is easily north of $2000. Now I know that "price is what you pay and value is what you get". So there are definitely occasions when I will use them. But I honestly doubt that most of their users realize the true cost of their service.
- 7Figures2Commas 12y agoBased on numerous reports, such as this one[1], Instacart Shoppers are currently being classified by the company as independent contractors. Apparently, Instacart Shoppers are trained, set a work schedule with the company, have their work activities controlled through an app, and even wear Instacart clothing. While classification involves numerous factors, I personally don't see how any of this passes even one of the most fundamental, the "nature and degree of control by the employer" test. Other on-demand companies that use independent contractor classification are facing class action lawsuits [2][3] over classification and given the general trends in the courts[4], there's little doubt we will continue to see the number of class actions alleging misclassification grow. Putting aside the costs of defending and settling a class action, or paying damages in an adverse ruling, the real question for investors in any on-demand company that currently relies on independent contractor classification is what employee classification would do to the economics of the business. Think of this as an "employee stress test." In some cases, on-demand companies are using independent contract classification to shift costs that have traditionally been borne by competitors in their markets, giving them an "unfair" pricing advantage. If they are found to be misclassifying their workers, their ability to compete on price will be affected. In other cases, companies charge a premium for a service that offers convenience. If they are found to be misclassifying their workers and are forced to pay their workers as employees, the premium charged to consumers would either have to increase or the company would need to be able to live on reduced margins. The effects of reclassification would be particularly significant for transportation companies. For example, in California, under Labor Code Section 2802, employers are on the hook for expenditures or losses incurred by their employees "in direct consequence of the discharge of his or her duties, or of his or her obedience to the directions of the employer." This includes expenditures related to travel/mileage. It's going to be very interesting in the coming years to see which of these on-demand companies continue to thrive because I personally think it's inevitable that many of them are going to be forced to reclassify their workers as employees. I suspect some investors aren't giving this enough consideration in their due diligence. [1] http://news.morningstar.com/all/market-watch/TDJNMW2014110765/update-delivery-startups-echo-dot-com-boom-and-bust.aspx http://news.morningstar.com/all/market-watch/TDJNMW201411076... [2] http://uberlawsuit.com/ http://uberlawsuit.com/ [3] http://www.sfgate.com/business/article/Handy-com-housecleaners-lawsuit-could-rock-5891672.php http://www.sfgate.com/business/article/Handy-com-housecleane... [4] http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-10-16/fedex-ground-says-its-drivers-arent-employees-dot-the-courts-will-decide http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-10-16/fedex-ground...
- miraj 12y agoAny plans for expansion beyond USA? I hope Instacart is coming to Canada soon. Toronto is an obvious choice. The other city that would very likely be receptive is Vancouver. They're keen on the sharing 'economy' - including a home-grown car-share company called Modo. There are also a few Whole Foods stores in-town. I also read recently that cities with fewer cars per residents are more receptive to home delivery services. So yes Canada awaits for your arrival eagerly!