3 ms·
The smallish downside of continuing with it may outweigh the very small upside. The image by itself might not be a big deal, but we're trying to disrupt the pat
by sp332 12y ago
The smallish downside of continuing with it may outweigh the very small upside. The image by itself might not be a big deal, but we're trying to disrupt the pattern of women being used only as objects, not perpetuate it.
- FeeTinesAMady 12y agoNo, the upside of continuing to use it is to show the politically correct bullies that we aren't afraid, and you aren't going to get everything you want.
- sp332 12y agoCS enrollment is down. I think it's because the industry is full of inconsiderate assholes.
- FeeTinesAMady 12y agoThere is nothing inconsiderate about using the cropped image "Lena". Nothing. It is not an offensive image. Only hypersensitive people who choose to be offended by everything find it offensive, and those people should be fought against, not placated.
- sp332 12y agoLook, you're under no real obligation to stop being an inconsiderate asshole. I'm just pointing out that there are practical consequences. You don't have to be offended by the image. You don't even have to understand why people are offended, that's fine. But if you don't take other people's feelings into consideration, that's the inconsiderate part. Other people are going to have different opinions than you do. Telling other people they're not allowed to be offended is why you're an asshole.
- FeeTinesAMady 12y agoI'm just saying that anyone who IS offended by it is a whiny, oversensitive asshole who wants to force the world to accommodate them, and that is wrong. Standing up to them does not make me the asshole: babying them makes you the asshole. Edit: just take another look at the cropped picture "Lena". If your argument is that that is somehow offensive, you are wrong, plain and simple.
- sp332 12y agoYou can't understand the meaning of a symbol by studying the symbol. You have to go look at what it means. It's like analyzing a swastika and deciding that neo-nazis aren't offensive. The problem is that only men were part of that project, they treated a woman in an exclusive manner, and now that image is a reminder of that sexist hierarchy.
- FeeTinesAMady 12y agoI'll simplify this for you. I would be an inconsiderate asshole if the picture was actually offensive, ie, if it was goatse, someone in blackface, etc. But it isn't, and unlike you, I have the courage to make a statement about the image: that it is objectively not offensive. There is no one out there who is actually offended by it. They are all people pushing an agenda. So your argument seems to be that because some people could be offended by it, we shouldn't use it, even though the notion that anyone could be offended by it is ridiculous on its face. So what, then, about things like gay pride parades? People can be offended by those, too. According to your argument, we should end that, too. But I'm sure you'd never advocate for that. You'd say something like "it's their right to be in your face in public". And of course it is, even though it can offend people. But that same argument defends people who'd use offensive images in image processing papers, not just ones which are just a target for politically correct assholes. You only care about people being offended if they're on your side. Gay pride parades are not bad things, and just the same, a woman posing for Playboy is not a bad thing, and using the cropped image of the face of a woman's nude picture is even less offensive than a gay pride parade. And nobody should be pressuring anyone to stop either of those things.
- lectrick 12y agoIf we used a male model as a photographic test subject here, is that not the sexist objectification of males? Should we use an unattractive person or an animal instead? Are you going to attack the very notion of beauty or the fact that women are the "fairer sex"?
- sp332 12y agoSure, it could be objectification. It's pretty cut and dried in this case since the image was scanned from a magazine almost at random. The woman had no agency in the decision at all. Of course I'm going to attack that. Women are required to be beautiful or they are deemed worthless, or failures. So they put a lot of work into it from a fear of failure. Men can be beautiful too, especially to a woman's eye which you've never seen through. If men were made to worry about their appearance as much as women, we'd be "fair" too.
- mnx 12y ago>Women are required to be beautiful or they are deemed worthless, or failures. I am truly sad for you if that is the case in your enviroment, but please, please do not generalise like that.
- sp332 12y agoFortunately, it is not the case in my environment. But it is a dominant message.
- lectrick 12y agoThere are predominant gender roles. How can we determine if the predominance is wrong, or just natural? All of this assumes the predominance is wrong. If I go to enjoy a burlesque show (a largely female-dominated event that all consensually participate in), did I merely experience the predominance, or did I also reinforce it? If the majority like something even though a minority do not, does that mean the majority are somehow wrong?