3 ms·
I'd like to see a modern implementation and some unbiased testing done before I got too excited. From what I could tell, the tech got more hype than was justifi
by jerf 12y ago
I'd like to see a modern implementation and some unbiased testing done before I got too excited. From what I could tell, the tech got more hype than was justified by its ability to perform, and I suspect the fact that it still isn't in much use may have more to do with difficult being better at anything in particular than a current existing solution rather than a lack of people interested in it.
(And note my phrasing of "got more hype than was justified by its ability to perform"... it isn't that it has no ability, just that it got more hype than it should have. Same thing happened to "wavelets". Yes, I know about JPEG2000... again, the point isn't that they are "bad" or "can't work" but that they got more hype than their real performance justified.)
- anigbrowl 12y agoIT's not the most competitive in compression or speed terms as far as I know, but the resolution independence is a Big Deal to me. I first saw this technology about 20 years ago and I am still impressed by it because nothing else has delivered that for photographic images. It's like SVG for photography. At the time, encoding required a) an expensive license and (IIRC) b) an accelerator board if you intended to do anything other than leave your CPU churning overnight - obvious disadvantages relative to formats like jpeg.
- spot 12y agothis is 100% BS, it's an illusion. you should read the Talk page of the wikipedia entry, where it's obvious there are some misinformed/deceptive folks took control of the page. See the comp.compression FAQ is a much better resource, as is the paper Brendt Wohlberg and Gerhard de Jager, "A review of the fractal image coding literature", IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, vol. 8, no. 12, pp. 1716--1729, Dec 1999 in particular " purely fractal-based schemes are not competitive with the current state of the art"
- anigbrowl 12y agoI'm not talking about the Wikipedia page, which does not in any case make mild claims about the technology. I'm recounting my personal experience of using it and being impressed by the results.