4 ms·
Did you read the article? There were _several_ great test images used in the Mozilla study under suitable licenses, and Bellard did test with some of those. The
by geofft 12y ago
Did you read the article? There were _several_ great test images used in the Mozilla study under suitable licenses, and Bellard did test with some of those. The Lena picture here wasn't particularly scientifically useful, it was presumably just used out of a sense of tradition. (Mozilla didn't use it.)
http://people.mozilla.org/~josh/lossy_compressed_image_study_july_2014/#image_sets http://people.mozilla.org/~josh/lossy_compressed_image_study...
- ANTSANTS 12y agoWhat do you know, there are other attractive women in those photosets, including at least one that appears to be wearing roughly as little as Lena. It's almost like our brains are wired for facial recognition and thus attractive faces are good test subjects for image compression algorithms or something.
- j2kun 12y agoAre any of the pictures cropped segments of pornographic images?
- ANTSANTS 12y agoI dunno, it's kinda hard to tell with this one: http://r0k.us/graphics/kodak/kodim04.html http://r0k.us/graphics/kodak/kodim04.html The fact that you call the uncropped image "pornographic" (which, yes, it technically is) when Playboy centerfolds are rather tame by modern standards kinda hints at the real problem here: the boring old American prudishness that has been masquerading as feminism as of late. I sincerely could not care less if Bellard had used Billy Herrington's toned ass as a test subject. The sooner that our society can get past this ridiculous fear of sexuality and the human body, the better. Perhaps not coincidentally, Bellard is from France, a culture much more accepting of nudity and sexuality than ours. I would not be surprised if he had simply not considered the possibility of prudes across the pond getting outraged over such an innocuous thing.
- j2kun 12y agoNow show me a picture of a man from that dataset that could possibly be construed as sexual. This is not a matter of prudishness. I would be totally fine (see my other comment in this thread) if researchers used both male and female crops, but they don't. So to make your point you need to show me all of the male French researchers who are accepting of male nudity in their image processing research. I would be very surprised if you could find me a single one.
- ANTSANTS 12y ago>Now show me a picture of a man from that dataset that could possibly be construed as sexual. >This is not a matter of prudishness. There seems to be a contradiction here. >I would be very surprised if you could find me a single one. I agree, not because I think male French researchers would give a rat's ass about the cropped head of a naked guy appearing as a test subject, but because I doubt any would be foolish enough to poke the proverbial hornet's nest and incur the wrath of self-righteous west coast white guys tweeting on their iPhones.
- j2kun 12y agoYou're missing the point, which is that it's not the specific image, but that testbeds use suggestive photos of attractive women and not men. You want people to feel free to use nudity or suggestiveness. Fine. I want them to be equal about which suggestive photos they use. As in not all women. And now you're saying that French researchers don't care, but they do because they don't want to anger Americans? (And somehow they're all white, live on the west coast, and have iPhones?) What a crazy web you're weaving.
- ANTSANTS 12y ago>This is not a matter of prudishness. I would be totally fine (see my other comment in this thread) You mean this one? "Sexualizing women has nothing to do with image processing research." How positively libertine of you. >You're missing the point And you're missing my point, which is that if you really weren't a prude, you wouldn't care either way. Straight men like pretty women, straight women like handsome men, gay men like handsome men, gay women like pretty women, some people like some combination of the above, some guys 40 years ago liked a pretty woman, who gives a fuck? Stop being offended by extremely tame displays of sexuality. >And now you're saying that French researchers don't care, but they do because they don't want to anger Americans? You city slickers don't seem very good with jokes, do you? I'd tell you to "lighten up" but I forgot that's code for "long live the patriarchy."
- geofft 12y agoSounds like we agree, then -- there are enough other images with all the properties of the Lena image that make it useful for image-compression tests that there wasn't a scientific reason to use the Lena one in this analysis.
- malandrew 12y agoBut none of those other images have been used as widely for as long to provide the same utility for comparison. Getting the equivalent for all other papers involves getting the source code for all the other papers, and running those algorithms against these other images and making those images easily discoverable by someone who might come across these other papers (they are unlikely to contain links to your newly generated set). What you're essentially advocating is reducing the available comparative evidence in an entire field of study because some people object to its origin, many of which don't even work in this field of study. I'm sorry, but when you can't even admit that eliminating this image from use might have negative consequences from a utility point of view, it makes it very hard for others to accept your position. Losing a common point of comparison in a field of study working on optimization problems is a step back. If you advocate for "diluting" the image by getting other reference images in common use by practitioners, then I can back that up. That approach actually balances the concerns of both sides and generally enriches the field (more common reference images can only serve to aid in objective and subjective comparison)
- DanBC 12y agoMy comment is not a response to the article, but is a response to loudmax.
- malandrew 12y agoIf it matters so much to you, take that image set and do exactly as DanBC suggested. Create a site with all the different image formats out there with a larger test set. Be willing to take matters into your own hands and change the norms and traditions in that field of study. The best way to accomplish that is by offering something better. I would say that a wiki with many test images for many algorithms is something better. If you do an good job, people will adopt your approach and tradition will change. Complaining on HN isn't going to change tradition. Introducing new ideas usually is usually more successful long-term approach than "book burning" because you disagree with the content.