4 ms·
You can’t detox your body. It’s a myth
- ChrisGranger 12y agoI wish quacks like Dr. Oz would stop promoting this 'detox' fantasy.
- nilkn 12y agoI think the public is going to have to learn the hard lesson that even if the person on TV is a real doctor they may not be trustworthy and may not really have your best interest in mind. 'Detoxing' is just the latest in a long line of thoroughly debunked scams that Dr. Oz has promoted.
- dragonwriter 12y agoAs long as it continues to be profitable for quacks to promote fantasies, quacks will promote fantasies.
- bequanna 12y agoThis is mentioned in the article as well, but I believe the real issue is the automatic credibility given to people that possess credentials. Many people seem perfectly happy to put their health and life in the hands of a medical professional and do a minimal amount of work/research for themselves. For example, given the popularity of the below drugs, few seem to ask: 'Do I really need to kill my liver cells to lower my cholesterol?' (statins) 'If we don't know how these antidepressants work, and some studies show they don't work, why am I taking them?'
- meepmorp 12y ago> 'Do I really need to kill my liver cells to lower my cholesterol?' (statins) A small number of people taking statin drugs (<1% for atorvastatin, the most popular drug in the class) experience abnormal liver enzyme levels, and the drugs are contraindicated in the case that a patient has existing liver disease. But that's hardly destroying one's liver cells in the majority of people.
- bequanna 12y agoMaybe I should have been more general: 'Why am I taking {drug} for {condition} with [serious possible side effects] when I could simply change my diet and activity level?' MOST of the health issues we are prescribing drugs for are treatable/curable with lifestyle changes.
- pzxc 12y agoHmm. Well, although there is certainly plenty of snake oil sold on the market, you CAN detox your body just like you can "tox" it. If you smoke and drink and eat poorly every day, you are putting toxins into your system. If you stop doing this, your system will "detox". But you don't need a product to do it -- fasting is probably the most effective way. The possible benefits/drawbacks of this is another matter. But don't pretend like there aren't toxins we put into our system, or that if we stop adding more toxins that the level of toxins in our system won't reduce. Because it will. And that is detoxification.
- dalke 12y agoThat isn't detoxification, it's excretion. The article even says it: "If toxins did build up in a way your body couldn’t excrete ..."
- sopooneo 12y agoStrictly uninformed logic hear, but it seems considering "excretion" and "detoxification" mutually exclusive concepts is not correct. If you were putting toxins (of any definition) into your body, slightly faster than your liver/skin/lungs could remove them, they would slowly build up. Perhaps they would make you feel sick before they killed you. Or perhaps the filter rate is proportional to the current level, so you reach an equilibrium at a point that makes you feel ill, but doesn't kill you. If all this is in any way valid, then we might hypothesize that simply stopping putting "toxins" into your body for a period would allow a daily net loss as your body filtered them out. This would not require any special "cleanse", but simply living strictly on foods/drinks that did not contain whatever stuff you were trying to eliminate. This might allow them to decrease to a level where you felt better. Perhaps after that you would go back to your old life-style and let the "toxins" build up again, or you could input them at a level that your body could eliminate them. Apart from aversion to the now coopted phrase "cleanse", could someone with actual knowledge say whether any of this conjecture aligns with actually physiology/metabolism?
- dalke 12y ago
- webnrrd2k 12y agoI agree with the article, except it's missing another type of useful detox -- chelation therapy. It's generally used with heavy metal poisoning. I have a friend who ate way too much sushi and had seriously elevated mercury levels. Eventually her body cleared the mercury out on it's own, but I believe she went through a initial round of mild chelation therapy.
- dalke 12y agoChelation therapy has only been shown effective for acute and higher exposure poisoning. Chelating agents have serious side effects. For low exposures the best solution is to avoid or remove the source of the exposure. Quoting from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3846980/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3846980/ (italics mine): > Chelation treatment of asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic patients is unlikely to benefit patients and may actually cause harm, as discussed elsewhere in this publication. Patients seek clear cause–effect relationships for their “poisoning,” but it is not always possible to determine the cause of symptoms. Physicians should seek a thorough diagnosis in spite of the pressure to find a simple environmental culprit. Internet advertising by marketers of “toxic testings” have made testing and treatment popular in some alternative medicine practices and has encouraged some people with health problems to seek these treatments. However, it is not possible to remove all “toxins” from the body, and treatments remove essential elements as well. Furthermore, the efficacy of chelation treatment has not been generally demonstrated for all but severe recent acute exposures to a few metals. In addition to concerns about short-term adverse impacts that may result from chelation, public health practitioners are also concerned about the potential subtle and latent effects that have not been characterized. > In responding to citizen’s requests for information, public health officials are often confronted by extremely emotional appeals to solve personal health problems. Commercial laboratory marketings “toxin testing” offer hope that there is another treatment option. They also appear to prey on the guilt of caregivers, suggesting that not every treatment option has been tried until chelation products are used. However, no assessment of the true risks and benefits of chelation treatments are being provided.
- webnrrd2k 12y ago
- kolev 12y agoSweating detoxifies (far infrared saunas being best). Cilantro, chlorella and activated charcoal are natural chlelation agents.
- dalke 12y agoAs the article points out, when pressed, advocates can rarely specify which toxins are removed, or point to studies which demonstrate effectiveness in humans. Take cilantro for example. Quoting from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3654245/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3654245/ : > (iv) Cilantro (leaves of Coriandrum sativum), a popular culinary and medicinal herb, gained attention when a soup was reported to enhance mercury excretion following dental amalgam removal and remains popular despite limited evidence [46]. In animals, it decreased lead absorption into bone and inhibition of the delta-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase (ALAD) enzyme [47]. Less encouragingly, in a recent trial in 3- to 7-year old children exposed to lead, a cilantro extract was as effective as placebo in increasing renal excretion (improvements across treatment and placebo groups were ascribed to improved diet during the intervention) [48]. See the "limited evidence" and "as effective as placebo"? The same review article points to https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jts/36/1/36_1_121/_article https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jts/36/1/36_1_121/_arti... concerning chlorella and methyl mercury. (That paper in turn cites other several animal studies for cadmium, lead, and dioxins.) If you read that paper, you'll see it was dosed at 4 mg Hg/kg body weight, which is rather acute, and measured across 6 mice. The results can't simply be extrapolated to humans. So, where is your evidence which shows that cilantro and chlorella are effective chelation agents for humans?