3 ms·
> Of these and other causes of action typically alleged in these situations, the breach of contract claim is often the clearest source of a remedy. That's a st
by Someone1234 12y ago
> Of these and other causes of action typically alleged in these situations, the breach of contract claim is often the clearest source of a remedy.
That's a strange claim given that we're talking about a "contract" which QVC has no proof that the other party read or agreed to, and which there has been no explicit exchange ("offer" and "acceptance").
Are web-site contracts/terms even enforceable at all? According to this article[0]/case law likely not. Strange thing for a lawyer to say, but this article makes a lot of strange claims that seem inconsistent with US case law.
[0] http://www.forbes.com/sites/oliverherzfeld/2013/01/22/are-website-terms-of-use-enforceable/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/oliverherzfeld/2013/01/22/are-we...
- domdip 12y agoIANAL. The linked cases are probably more relevant than yours, courts will have different standards if the other party is a (presumably unsophisticated) consumer vs. a corporation. Also unclear if there was other communication b/w QVC and Resultly, which may be important. Also, "clearest source of a remedy" refers to ability to actually get compensation, which may be limited or difficult to argue for under DMCA/CFAA.
- greglindahl 12y agoSeveral cases have allowed contract claims where (1) the crawler created accounts and (2) the account creation flow has a checkbox for the user to indicate that they agree to the contract. Trying to enforce a contract on a crawler that's just fetching pages without ever checking a box is much more difficult... many failures in the past.