5 ms·
Poitras says "the reporting we’ve done has all been filtering what’s in the public interest versus what’s operational" yet in the same interview reveals "the co
by slg 12y ago
Poitras says "the reporting we’ve done has all been filtering what’s in the public interest versus what’s operational" yet in the same interview reveals "the communication flow for the drone system all goes through Rammstein, so it’s part of the nerve center. The controls are elsewhere, but it all runs through fiber optic cables that go in and out of Rammstein" How is it in the public interest to know that all drone communication flows through a specific base especially considering how valuable that fact might be to someone who would want to ground our drone fleet?
That is my only problem with Snowden and how these things are being reported. It started out with valid whistle blowing but there are plenty of real operational national secrets that are being revealed in the process. If Snowden simply stuck to the NSA's overreach in domestic spying, it would be much harder for politicians and the like to call him a traitor and marginalize these issues.
- secfirstmd 12y ago"If Snowden simply stuck to the NSA's overreach in domestic spying" On behalf of the other 6.7 billion people on this spinning green ball, thankfully he didn't. We have rights too.
- slg 12y ago>We have rights too. Not under the US Constitution which is what governs the NSA. That has been one of the main features of government throughout history. They put their own people's rights above the rights of foreigners. EDIT: And doing the opposite will generally be viewed as treason. I am honestly not aware of anything that was revealed that would violate any international treaty the US agreed to, but will definitely listen if you have examples. I also have a hard time believing that any other country with the capability to do the type of international spying the US does wouldn't do the exact same thing (or isn't already).
- pfortuny 12y agoWe may not have US constitutional rights but that is not the same as not having any rights at all. The USC establishes the USA not humanity.
- danieldk 12y agoAlso, EU citizens have rights/protection under the Safe Harbor Privacy Principles: http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-14-27_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-14-27_en.htm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Safe_Harbor_Privacy_Principles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Safe_Harbor_Priv...
- danieldk 12y agoI am honestly not aware of anything that was revealed that would violate any international treaty the US agreed to, but will definitely listen if you have examples. If something is not restricted by international treaties, it does not mean it's ethically ok to do so. I can understand that the US would push the boundaries when it comes to enemies. But it is utterly painful what it has done to so-called allies. Europe has a lot of historical debt to Canada and the US. However, 'betrayal' is the word that comes up describing what many Europeans feel.
- slg 12y ago>If something is not restricted by international treaties, it does not mean it's ethically ok to do so This is where I think we get into problems. You seem to be suggesting that people should be allowed to reveal classified national secrets that are legal both nationally and internationally if they find them unethical. I think this is a dangerous precedent to set. Different people will have wildly different views on what is ethical when it comes to war and espionage. That is why it is important to codify these things into laws and international treaties.
- danieldk 12y agoYou seem to be suggesting that people should be allowed to reveal classified national secrets that are legal both nationally and internationally if they find them unethical. [...] Different people will have wildly different views on what is ethical when it comes to war and espionage. Definitely. That is why it is important to codify these things into laws and international treaties. But treaties (as we have seen in this case) often lag significantly. In the end it is the judgement and the responsibility of the leaker. In this case, I think Snowden made a good call. For many reasons: e.g. the world had the right to know that virtually all internet traffic is tapped or tappable and that cryptography was intentionally weakened. Even if the US is your friend, that makes you vulnerable to criminal organizations and states that are not allies.
- trhway 12y ago>>We have rights too. >Not under the US Constitution which is what governs the NSA. US is a signatory of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_Accords http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_Accords
- slg 12y ago>The Helsinki Accords, however, were not binding as they did not have treaty status. That is at the end of the first paragraph, so I am not sure what you are getting at with your post. Even ignoring that, I didn't find anything that jumped out in that short Wikipedia article. Can you expand on how you believe the US violated the Helsinki Accords?
- trhway 12y ago>Can you expand on how you believe the US violated the Helsinki Accords? 1. a cornerstone of Helsinki is "fundamental freedoms, including the freedom of thought, conscience, religion or belief" 2. it is well established legal principle, incl. in US legal system, that mass surveillance violates such fundamental freedoms (by means of chilling effect in particular) >>The Helsinki Accords, however, were not binding as they did not have treaty status. There is also a binding treaty http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Bill_of_Human_Rights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Bill_of_Human_Rig... and "U.S. Finally Ratifies Human Rights Covenant" http://www.cartercenter.org/news/documents/doc1369.html http://www.cartercenter.org/news/documents/doc1369.html
- mpweiher 12y agoArticle 1 of the German Constitution ("Basic Law"): "Die Würde des Menschen ist unantastbar. Sie zu achten und zu schützen ist Verpflichtung aller staatlichen Gewalt." Not "German". "Human".
- MCRed 12y agoThe enumerated powers clause does not authorize the NSA, so effectively, everything they do is unconstitutional.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The enumerated powers clause does not authorize the NSA, The NSA is a foreign signals intelligence service principally, though not exclusively, supporting the military. I don't really see any argument that the existence of the NSA -- however much the case may be made of particular activities of the NSA violating various provisions of the Constitution -- is any less within the purview of Art. I Sec. 8 enumerated powers (particularly, the power to "raise and support armies") than any other non-uniformed part of the military support structure in the US government.
- karmacondon 12y agoSo you feel that your rights include knowing which military bases intelligence information flows through? I can understand people being outraged at the idea of NSA spying and wanting specific programs to end immediately. Whether certain intelligence operations violate your Constitutional or philosophical rights to privacy is an issue that's important to democracy and should be debated vociferously. But there is no legal or moral right that entitles you to know what air force base controls our drone fleet, what the nuclear launch codes are or where our achilles heels are located. Dumping troves of sensitive data is a bad idea, even if you want the NSA to be completely abolished. Snowden could have just as easily made a speech, instead of handing millions of unread classified documents over to private individuals.
- patrickg_zill 12y agoMay I ask, do you believe, that the Russians, Chinese, Israelis, etc. don't already know all this, already?
- at-fates-hands 12y agoThe bigger issue here for me is Snowden and his small team of people are doing the same thing the government does. They regulate the flow of what documents they want the public to see, while still holding a large trove of other documents, deciding unilaterally when they will get released. For someone who had a lot issues with the government, Snowden seems to be emulating quite well with this draconian process of releasing the remaining documents at such a slow pace.
- stith 12y agoSnowden has said many times that he is not the one deciding which documents to publish and when. He gave them all to the reporters, who make all of those decisions on their own. Replace "Snowden and his small team" with "The reporters who have the documents."
- csandreasen 12y ago... which is a cop-out. He decided which documents to give to the reporters. If they decided to release something that isn't in the public interest or is harmful to national security, nobody can say "well, Snowden wasn't the one who released it." He shouldn't have given them those documents to begin with.
- noiv 12y ago> He shouldn't have given them those documents to begin with. Why do you propose Snowdon should have chosen the suicide mission? It it essential to disconnect the leaker from the documents to bring life threatening action down to a minimum.
- csandreasen 12y agoI'm not saying he should have released the documents himself, I'm saying he shouldn't have given anything to the reporters which weren't in the public interest. Whistleblowing is when you see something illegal and you reveal those specific instances of illegal activity. You can debate whether or not what has been revealed has been beneficial or not, but that doesn't change the definition of whistleblowing - it's not taking a job specifically to gain access to classified information you've never seen before with intention to leak it[1], downloading hundreds of thousands of documents, then handing them over to a few reporters and saying "I'm not sure what's appropriate to reveal to the public, so I'll let you decide." If those reporters reveal something that isn't in the public interest or is damaging to national security, it's a cop-out to say that he wasn't the one who revealed it - he gave it to the reporters and he's responsible for anything they choose to report. I see people saying all of the time that there's a huge difference between what Manning and Snowden did. The way I see it, the difference is that Manning gave thousands of documents to Julian Assange hoping that he'd act responsibly with them, whereas Snowden gave hundreds of thousands of documents to Greenwald, Poitras and Gellman hoping that they'd act responsibly with them. [1] http://www.cnn.com/2013/06/25/politics/nsa-leak-snowden-job/ http://www.cnn.com/2013/06/25/politics/nsa-leak-snowden-job/
- runjake 12y agoA couple points: * Ramstein is a large city unto itself with the proper security perimeters and provisions. Even if you get on the base itself, you're not going to walk into the fenced off drone ops area. Revealing it as the location/hub is not a major security issue. * If the military cared enough, they would camouflage the tell-tale cookie cutter design of rows of trailers + satcom equipment from Google Maps, but they don't. Even the CIA doesn't seem to for its less-than-public UAV ops facilities in VA and the Middle East. * Ramstein is already well-known as the hub of virtually everything US military going on in the other side of the world, from medical, to logistics, materiels, intelligence, etc. Source: former military with knowledge/experiences.