8 ms·
The 50% divorce rate stat is a myth, so why won’t it die?
- cousin_it 12y agoSo what's the actual number? The article doesn't say. It's kinda rambling.
- Ntrails 12y agoNobody knows, because no one even agrees how to calculate it. Divorces/Marriages in a given year is worthless. Divorces (of people married in 1970) / Marriages (of people married in 1970) gives you a number for that "cohort" but isn't exactly true - there are many years left for them to divorce, and that is generations ago. Personally I'd say it would be useful to look at divorce rates and marriage rates in terms of overall population and growth and argue whether (Divorces / total people married) was increasing compared to (Marriages / total people unmarried) (I'm sure a statistician can tell me I'm wrong)
- throwawayaway 12y agomarriage ends in either death or divorce, surely they can combine the stats!
- geocar 12y agoExcept someone can be married and divorced multiple times (even within a single year). Counting the marriages or the divorces is a mistake. You need to count the people over time, but also not consider people who never get married.
- cousin_it 12y agoI think the main meaningful number is the chance of divorce for marriages starting today. There are probably many ways to estimate it indirectly.
- nodata 12y ago> Nobody knows, because no one even agrees how to calculate it. What's wrong with "percentage of marriages that end in divorce"?
- privong 12y agoThat can be skewed by people who marry and divorce multiple times, making "percentage of marriages that end in divorce" somewhat disconnected from the probability of any one marriage surviving.
- nodata 12y agoBut if people do marry and divorce multiple times, wouldn't we want the divorce rate to change with it?
- privong 12y agoIt depends on what one wants the "divorce rate" to mean.
- coldtea 12y agoThose are still marriages and divorces. I don't see any skewing. Whether you were married once and divorced once or married 6 times and divorced 6 times, all the times should be counted. The important factor is marriages/divorces not people/divorces.
- jiggy2011 12y agoThat depends on why you are interested in measuring divorce rates.
- coldtea 12y agoIs it though? I think the idea is to see how stable marriages are. And if some people have some "social dicease" that makes them marry and divorce more than others, I'd expect them to be outliers and statistical noise, compared to people that legitimate try to make it work and fail.
- snowwrestler 12y agoI'd be interested in the "survival rate" of marriages that end in divorce, like they calculate for chronic diseases. What's the 5-year survival rate for a marriage across the population? What's the 10-year rate, or 20-year rate? You could segment such data pretty easily by other factors, like region, ethnicity, age at wedding, etc.
- dragonwriter 12y agoThere are a number of studies that gather that kind of data, e.g. http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2013/article/marriage-and-divorce-patterns-by-gender-race-and-educational-attainment.htm http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2013/article/marriage-and-divorc...
- jmckib 12y agoThe best they had was divorce rate per person (including children and unmarried adults). However, I did find some information in one of the links from the article: http://www.nytimes.com/2005/04/19/health/19divo.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2005/04/19/health/19divo.html?_r=0 It mentions numbers from 16 percent (those married between 1990 and 1994) to 41% (men who were then between the ages of 50 to 59 [in 2001]). They agree that the divorce rate has been declining, particularly among college grads.
- the_mitsuhiko 12y agoThe divorce to marriage rate is about 50% in the US: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divorce_demography http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divorce_demography
- cowsandmilk 12y agoAs discussed in the article, that's a horrible number. If you dig into it, most of the divorces are people 50-59 who married when the marriage rate was much higher. The marriage rate has gone down over time because more people are choosing not to marry. You can think of it as either a depressed marriage rate or an inflated divorce rate, but large number of people getting divorced who were married 30 years ago is unrelated to the number of people being married today.
- Ih8registering 12y agoI call bullshit on this. The author is obviously a divorce industry shill : Using 1995 data, National Survey of Family Growth forecast in 2002 a 43% chance that first marriages among women aged 15–44 would be disrupted within 15 years.[12] More recently, having spoken with academics and National Survey of Family Growth representatives, PolitiFact.com estimated in 2012 that the lifelong probability of a marriage ending in divorce is 40%–50% from wikipedia. And that's from 1995 data. Things haven't gotten BETTER since then, LOL. Another "mythbusted" BUSTED. LOL
- the_mitsuhiko 12y agoThe 50% divorce rate is pretty spot on. 50% of all marriages end in a divorce. This has been calculated independently for many different countries over different years (and within a year) and from what I can tell those numbers do not vary much. That obviously does not say the likelihood of an individual marriage succeeding given that some people marry more than once.
- intopieces 12y agoSince you're going against the facts presented in the article, would you mind citing your sources? It will help readers evaluate your claims more effectively by allowing them to account for biases.
- coldtea 12y ago>would you mind citing your sources? The article doesn't claim any sources for the "overestimation" either -- or attempts to give any more accurate number. It's mostly a rehash of the linked NYT article that actually points out rates around 38-45% (so pretty damn close to 50%).
- spydum 12y agoThe article never actually provided fact or studies showing it is NOT 50%, they just ridiculed the national marriage project. All they showed was that less people per population were getting divorced. This does not answer the question about the divorce rate or where more or less people were getting married.
- intopieces 12y agoNot quite. The article says there is insufficient data. The commenter says there is (by virtue of making the claim). If I am to be convinced the opposite of the article's claim, I need to see the data the article claims doesn't exist.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- aleh 12y agoNow, if something as seemingly straightforward as divorce rate is controversial to calculate, how about causes/existence of global warming which is orders of magnitude more complex and is driven by much more powerful special interest groups.
- intopieces 12y agoThe science behind global warming is relatively uncontroversial [0], it's what we should do about that is fraught with peril, special-interests wise. But that's inevitable, really, given that environmentalism is itself a "special interest," albiet one that concerns us all in one way or another. [0]http://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensus/ http://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensus/
- feinte 12y agoWe have more precise data about global warming. Sensors are good at measuring temperature or sea rising, less at measuring divorce rates.
- cowsandmilk 12y agoThe US government stopped tracking divorce rates in 1996, so we have little data. We still have a shitload of weather stations and air monitoring stations that actually give us data.
- aleh 12y agoYep, we have shitload of data and then use complex model of earth climate to extrapolate this data. Being complex the model is extremely sensitive to parameters (Butterfly effect) and gives a lot of freedom in choosing parameters, which in turn makes it easy to tune the model to get the expected result. In itself it would not be too bad, this is how we learn how things work, but add a media looking for sensation and political interests and this whole area of research becomes as scientific as astrology.
- snowwrestler 12y agoYour comment reflects a common misunderstanding, which is that the theory of global warming depends on the use of computerized general circulation models. It does not. The physical basis of the theory is easy to understand, and was discovered in the 19th century: the atmosphere is obviously a heat reservoir, so what is trapping the heat? The answer is that certain atmospheric gases absorb and re-emit infrared light. The obvious hypothesis is that if you increase the amount of those atmospheric gases, you'll trap more heat--just like building a taller dam will trap more water in a reservoir. This hypothesis was first proposed at the end of the 19th century. And today, that is indeed what a wide variety of measurements are showing: the gases are going up, and so is the temperature. The hard part is predicting what exactly will change in a given location. Will New York get warmer or colder? Will Seattle get drier or wetter? Will Tokyo see more of the same storms, or fewer stronger storms? These are the questions that computerized GCMs will help us answer. But we know that something is going to change. You can't dump more energy into a complex system (the climate, in this case) and expect it to keep working exactly the same way.
- epx 12y agoWell, the actual divorce rate is certainly not that different in magnitude. It is not 5-10%.
- intopieces 12y agoI think the actual number is not the point of the article, exactly. The author is trying to point out that the method is flawed, and statistics is much more complicated than anyone one number from one source.
- pmorici 12y agoAm I reading this wrong or does this article start out by implying that the number is over estimated and then goes on to give two examples of general long term trends, increasing population, and decreasing marriage rate that would lead to underestimating the number by the commonly used method?
- coldtea 12y agoPlus it never gives an actual number, and never mentions tons of estimation efforts and stats that place it close to 35-50% (as if all of those were merely based on repeating the myth).
- Shivetya 12y agoWell maintaining that believe relieves those from toughing it out to fix their marriages, supports the divorce lawyer market and their marketing, and politicians who like to capitalize on strife. Seriously, I know the holidays are tough but my drive to and from work the local stations are all covered with divorce lawyer ads.
- coldtea 12y ago>Well maintaining that believe relieves those from toughing it out to fix their marriages, supports the divorce lawyer market and their marketing, and politicians who like to capitalize on strife. That's pop psychology. Plus assumes the belief is some myth... The divorce rate IS close to that number. Whether it's 50% or 45% doesn't matter much, as another poster said, it's not like its 5% or 15%. From Wikipedia: In 2002 (latest survey data as of 2012), 29% of first marriages among women aged 15–44 were disrupted (ended in separation, divorce or annulment) within 10 years. Using 1995 data, National Survey of Family Growth forecast in 2002 a 43% chance that first marriages among women aged 15–44 would be disrupted within 15 years. More recently, having spoken with academics and National Survey of Family Growth representatives, PolitiFact.com estimated in 2012 that the lifelong probability of a marriage ending in divorce is 40%–50%.
- hawleyal 12y agoSo you are disagreeing with the entire premise of the article. You are calling bullshit. That's interesting, given that the author specifically debunks the stats you are quoting.
- coldtea 12y ago>That's interesting, given that the author specifically debunks the stats you are quoting. He doesn't debunk much, if anything at all. He has a predetermined conclusion and he hacks his way to reach it. Instead of quoting statistics and measurements, he quotes a NYT article (that doesn't back him up as much as he think) and does the equivalent of rigorous hand waiving with nebulous arguments.
- 12y ago
- mhd 12y agoIs it because we only use 10% of our brains?
- tempodox 12y agoAccording to every TV show in the country, the divorce rate must be at least 100%. If anyone still wants to get married, they have to get un-divorced first and nobody seems to think it's worth the trouble.
- pherocity_ 12y agoSorry, but this is bollocks. We don't know what the number is because we don't have the data or an agreed upon methodology to calculate the stat. But I have seen stats that do indeed put the rate in the 40% range; whether you agree with the methodology or not, does not mean that the number is a myth. And any pedant saying that 46% isn't 50% is correct, but clearly missing the forrest for the trees.
- Flimm 12y ago40% of what?
- pherocity_ 12y agoSeriously?
- guilbep 12y agoWhat? what about those stats? http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/marriage_divorce_tables.htm http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/marriage_divorce_tables.htm Article not worth reading
- athenot 12y agoDataviz angle here... To me, it's like determining the age of a population. Saying that the population is 40 years old on average doesn't have much value. Instead, we need a richer representation, like an age pyramid [1]. Plot on a histogram the number of divorcees for each year they got married. Of course there is going to be few divorces for those married this year, and a lot more for those married 50 years ago. Then you can compare the shapes of the histogram over time or between regions. And that can yield insight on the matter. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_pyramid http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_pyramid
- intopieces 12y agoI think the title should be "The 50% stat is meaningless." This would head off at the pass the arguments in this comment section, which seem to focus on what the number actually is instead of the point of the article.
- carsongross 12y agoBy not discussing the plummeting marriage rate [1] and changes in the data sets [2] this article is deeply flawed. There is reasonable evidence that divorce rate has remained about the same for the last 20 years despite the plummeting marriage rate [3]. People correctly sense that marriage is a deeply wounded institution in the west, particularly for the lower (and, increasingly, middle) classes. [1] - http://www.prb.org/images10/usyoungadultmarriage.gif http://www.prb.org/images10/usyoungadultmarriage.gif [2] - http://dalrock.wordpress.com/2014/12/04/ny-times-happy-talk-about-divorce/ http://dalrock.wordpress.com/2014/12/04/ny-times-happy-talk-... [3] - http://www.bgsu.edu/content/dam/BGSU/college-of-arts-and-sciences/NCFMR/documents/FP/FP-12-05.pdf http://www.bgsu.edu/content/dam/BGSU/college-of-arts-and-sci...
- dragonwriter 12y agoThe entire article here is equivocation -- a rate is a ratio between one variable and another, and the frequently cited 50% rate is a ratio of (marriages ending in divorces):(all marriages), and the lower rate that the article presents and charts is the ratio of (divorces in a year):population.