3 ms·
I got a PhD in physics in 1993. I think the advice we received still rings true today. Don't attend grad school unless: 1. You are so in love with the subject
by analog31 12y ago
I got a PhD in physics in 1993. I think the advice we received still rings true today. Don't attend grad school unless:
1. You are so in love with the subject matter, that you can't think of doing anything else. I'd give the same advice to someone thinking of going to music school (my Plan B when I was a kid).
2. Somebody else is paying for it. My spouse and I finished grad school with no debt.
Without wanting to be too negative about it, I think that the inferiority complex thing, and expecting to receive marketable skills, aren't good enough reasons. Are computational physicists really more employable than common, or garden, computer programmers? A lot of programming can and is done by trial and error or looking up stuff online, and a lot of people doing it are basically self taught. (I'm looking in the mirror when I say those things).
I went to grad school because my parents had science degrees, and seemed to have good careers and happy lives. And I was interested in learning more, in an academic environment. I already knew how to program, but saw it as a drudge job -- easy but ultimately boring if you were doing it for someone else. (My summer internships at a data processing center may have biased my perspective). During the time that I was in school, the people who seemed to be doing the coolest things with computers were the physicists.
Note that I have to be careful what I say about programming, in a nest of programmers. ;-) I really have a lot of respect for what folks are doing, but am describing the limited environment that I was exposed to 20+ years ago.
- noobermin 12y ago>I already knew how to program, but saw it as a drudge job -- easy but ultimately boring if you were doing it for someone else. Hmm, that sounds like grad school, to be honest. The difference is it is _hard_ and ultimately boring because you're doing it for someone else. >During the time that I was in school, the people who seemed to be doing the coolest things with computers were the physicists. Hmmm. My experience with "computational physics" is 1) Run the simulation, probably in 2D a) because the codes suck and are written by subpar programmers b) your analysis scripts are dumb and only work if you output everything, so your simulation spends most of its time in IO 2) Plot the outputs in matlab. Bullshit your way through understanding as if you understand it, write papers,make presentations, enjoy your pizza parties because that's all you have in your life. May be I just have a bad choice of groups to choose from. This is my opinion, though, so take it with a grain of salt.
- ohquu 12y agoThank you for the great reply! I hear statement (1) quite a lot, but it seems like a really subjective criterion. When I hear this, I think, "If I'm not as passionate as Feynman, I should not go to grad school." And so I haven't. Am I looking at this the wrong way? When I compare the subjects I enjoy and the careers that allow freedom and decent pay, physics seems to be the only thing that remains. Is that not enough? I don't have the confidence to know whether I'll love the subject in ten years. I also think anyone who has that confidence is either a Feynman-type or has deluded themselves. Regarding (2), don't most hard science grad programs pay the students? I'm also not saying that computational physicists are more employable than common programmers (or that they're better software developers!). I'm just saying I enjoy working on problems similar to those encountered in computational physics. I enjoy figuring out how things work and modelling them. In case I ended up hating physics by the end of graduate school, at least I'd have a strong background in mathematics and programming, and those skills could be transferred to domains with similar problems. If you don't mind me asking, are you still working in physics? Based on your "about" section, you seem to be interested in a great many things, like myself. Before entering graduate school, could you truly not think of doing anything else, i.e., did you truly obey criterion (1)? I can think of many things I'd still like to do while I'm young: start a business, write songs professionally, act... but it's hard to take risks like that when you've got a good (and more practical) thing going.
- analog31 12y agoI suppose (1) is an exaggeration. But there are a number of risks inherent in joining a grad program -- ways that students fall out and don't get their degrees. At least I think you need to be aware of those risks and willing to absorb them. And one of those risks is that you emerge with your PhD and folks wonder how you're actually smarter than you were without one. (2), yes, but it's just a reminder to set a bar for yourself, that you have to get into a decent program with decent support in order for it to be worthwhile. It might not be so much the principle of getting paid to work, but having enough of a financial cushion so you don't have to deal with crises by quitting grad school. I obeyed criterion (1) but not Feynman level. That's too strong of a criterion, like you suggest. Rather, the alternatives to grad school all looked pretty blah. I've been _extremely_ lucky. My thesis project was very much a hackathon in optics, electronics, software, etc. Today I work for a company that makes scientific instruments, and I work on assimilating new technologies on a 1 - 2 year time frame before we attempt to develop them into the next generation of products. So I do a lot of experimenting, learning theory, etc. I solve difficult problems that crop up with our products, in production and in the field. Truth be told, I also spend a reasonable amount of time on mainstream work, e.g., project engineering. I've tried my hand at both project management and people management. Those were OK. I don't have enough mental organization to do the project management thing when I'm actually competing with other project managers for resources. Over the duration of grad school, I kinda lost interest in basic research. It's cool, but I'm not a _great_ physicist, and I've simply never had an idea for my own line of research, which would kinda put a damper on an academic career. I prefer to work on shorter term projects where I can add value by developing an understanding of how things work. I also feel that the industry I'm in genuinely creates good solid jobs for people. I don't face the dilemma of wondering if I have to exploit people in order for my own work to progress.