3 ms·
This result (fewer readers for 'good news') isn't particularly surprising. People read the news to find things they need to take action on, things that interrup
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
This result (fewer readers for 'good news') isn't particularly surprising. People read the news to find things they need to take action on, things that interrupt their normal life flow and tell them what to do. I read a paper that called it the Utopia Paradox[1] which described the situation where all needs are met, people cease to pursue ideas. I would find when starting a new job and leaving behind an email inbox full of demands on my time that the sheer choice of things to do is initially overwhelming.
So when you stop giving people things to worry about, and I think they use it as a crutch to organize their day, they are at a loss. Too often news is "Its going to rain" therefore I need to have my raincoat tomorrow, "Idiots are going to win the election", therefore I need to vote, "Kids are getting kidnapped", therefore I need to protect my kids. But when the news is, "All the trains are on time!" what help does that give you in planning your life? None. And in fact you have now "wasted" time on reading an article that hasn't helped you figure out anything you need to prepare for or worry about, so that are only so many more minutes left in the day to prepare.
It's a very strange cycle. You can play it the other way though, you can both report good news and give planning data, like "The trains are all on time and cars are less reliable than they were, consider changing your plan to use the train tomorrow." That is the sort of positive news I'd prefer we got, "Here is what is going on and here is some action you can take to help it continue and/or mitigate it."
[1] I suspect there are several alternate uses of this name though.
- Joeri 12y agoI can't recall a single time, ever, that the news gave me actionable information that I didn't already get from other sources. Basically, when you subtract all the feel-good stories and all the scare stories, what is left is the weather, information that affects my commute and extraordinary events. The weather i get from looking out the window in the morning. If something affects my commute i have to try to make it anyway, so knowing ahead of time just gives me more stress. And extraordinary events will be told to me in other ways. Taking your examples: (1) nobody should need to tell you to protect your kids, (2) you should always vote, (3) you can see whether you need a raincoat in the morning. Basically, the actionable content of the news is exactly zero. When i watch it, i don't expect to take action, i expect to be informed about the zeitgeist so i can gossip along with everybody else. We like to gossip about bad things more than good things, so if the news tells us only good things, it's not giving us what we want.
- SeanDav 12y agoNot sure how you are going to find out the tornado weather in Chicago by looking out your window in New York, prior to flying out. Or how you are going to find out about a major traffic blockage on your commute route by looking at the traffic in your street. Or even more extreme, how your are going to ask your nurse daughter to take extra precautions because there is a serial rapist of nurses in your city, without listening to any news. Almost by definition, news is something out of the ordinary. I would suspect that news plays a far bigger role in your life than you seem to want to admit.
- pdevr 12y agoNice analysis. The last paragraph has an interesting idea worth pursuing. However, all those who seek and read negative news may not be craving for action. I think it is more of a craving for interesting things or shocking things which "jolt" the brain.
- gizmo686 12y agoI don't think we even need to combine the good and bad news in the way you describe (although clumping related news together is certainly good). The key to useful news seems to be that something changed. For example, trains are on time may not be useful, but train accuracy improved is.
- john2x 12y agoGood point. The "good news" cited in the short article weren't really news were they? They were more statement of facts. The roads remained open. The trains remained on time. That's not new. Could be a combination of bad reporting (due to reporters/writers not used to good news), and the points made by the grandparent post.