4 ms·
> He talked more about encoding, not compression. Not really. Call it what you want, but the claim was that you could fit many movies in the same space as one
by kstrauser 12y ago
> He talked more about encoding, not compression.
Not really. Call it what you want, but the claim was that you could fit many movies in the same space as one small one (by today's standards), presumably based on similar content shared across multiple movies. Suppose I record a movie of me walking through my city for an hour, and you record one of close-ups of surfers. I find it highly unlikely that you could find a non-trivial amount of duplicate frame content between the two.
Now let's mix in frames from Un Chien Andalou. I'd bet that the union of our three movies' compression dictionaries would be approximately the size of the sum of them.
> Was Jan Sloot the biggest conman of the 90s?
He was quite possibly sincere, but he was still wrong. He was squaring a circle and it just can't be done.
- compbio 12y agoJan Sloot claimed a compression factor of around 8x in his patents. The claim in the news article is "All movies ever made would fit on one CD-ROM", which is incorrect and misleading. "The keycodes to unlock all movies ever made would fit on one CD-ROM" would be correct and totally possible, just like all magnet links on the PirateBay probably fit on a single DVD. A block of 8x8 pixels, possibly with some filters, could easily repeat, say, a piece of the blue sky. Think of compressing three modern-day English books. Compressing each of them individually with their own table would likely result in a larger size than compressing the three books together with one big table. The compressor can make use of repetition of data across the three books to keep the file size smaller. You can test this with a good compressor. It's a principle that is used in normalized compression distance (comparing the length of individually compressed files, by the length of compressing their concatenation, to obtain a similarity metric).